Comfort v. Higgins
Decision Date | 18 December 1978 |
Docket Number | No. 60647,60647 |
Parties | Hartley B. COMFORT, Clarence R. Comfort, Viola Comfort, Samuel T. Comfort and Edward W. S. Owens, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Jennie C. HIGGINS, Lucia Lee Bates, Dr. James L. DeFoe, Rev. William J. Williamson, Rev. S. H. Wainwright, Rev. J. Layton Mauze, Robert M. Nichols, Trustees, St. Louis Women's Christian Association, a pro forma decree corporation, Memorial Home, Inc., a not-for-profit corporation and John M. Dalton, Attorney General of the State of Missouri, Defendants-Respondents. |
Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
Carroll J. Donohue, Alan B. Hoffman, T. Hartley Pollock, St. Louis, for plaintiffs-appellants.
Norman C. Parker, St. Louis, G. Michael Bauer, Asst. Atty. Gen., Jefferson City, for defendants-respondents.
This cause was transferred pursuant to Mo.Const., art. V., § 10, and rule 83.01 upon certification by a member of the court of appeals, St. Louis district, that the majority opinion, holding that the settlor of the trust involved herein established the same with a general rather than a specific charitable intent, was in conflict with prior opinions of this court and the court of appeals. 1 Portions of the opinion of the court of appeals and the dissent are used below without quotation marks. We reverse and remand.
Plaintiffs-appellants (appellants) appeal from a judgment against them in two consolidated causes of action. Appellants filed an action, cause No. 217613, on April 10 1957 against respondents St. Louis Women's Christian Association (SWCA), Memorial Home, Inc. (MHI), and the seven trustees named in a trust instrument dated August 29, 1912. The trust made the trustees legal owners of property on which Memorial Home Board, (predecessor to Memorial Home, Inc.), an auxiliary of SWCA, was to establish a Home for the Aged, to be called Baxter Protestant Memorial, in memory of the settlor's father, on the ancestral land of the settlor. Appellants claimed that the trust failed, that it had been established by the settlor with a specific rather than a general charitable intent, and therefore that title to the trust property should be quieted in them as heirs of the settlor either by reversion or by virtue of a resulting trust.
On January 9, 1961, MHI filed an action, cause No. 238649, seeking to quiet title to the real property in it subject to the trust. The two cases were consolidated for trial in 1974.
In August 1975, the trial judge filed his fifty-one findings of fact and twenty-three conclusions of law. He found that the settlor evinced a general charitable intent, the trust had not failed, and that appellants thus had no claim to the property and denied them relief. He quieted title in MHI in fee simple for the charitable and benevolent uses mentioned in the 1912 deed. In addition, the trial court purported to award to MHI the amount paid into the registry of a different division of the circuit court as the result of a public utility condemnation proceeding concerning the property.
The deed by which the settlor, Mourning B. Hardy, set up the trust in question is as follows, in pertinent part:
The property was initially in the name of John Baxter and passed upon his death in 1887 to his children, Hartley Baxter and Mourning Hardy (settlor). In 1894 Hartley Baxter and his wife conveyed their interest to Mourning. Mourning's husband died on February 7, 1912. Settlor died February 25, 1917.
The parties have presented this court with numerous exhibits which recount the history of the usage of the Baxter property. The facts are as follows:
Since about 1881, MHI, one branch of SWCA, has maintained Memorial Home, a residence home for the elderly in the City of St. Louis. In addition to the maintenance of Memorial Home, SWCA has controlled Women's Christian Home (organized 1868), Blind Girl's Home (organized 1867), Russell Home (organized 1907) and Catherine Springer Home (organized 1919).
Upon the death of Mourning B. Hardy, MHI assumed control of the Baxter property subject to a $3,000.00 mortgage which MHI subsequently retired. At the time of Mrs. Hardy's death, the principal building on the property was a house of rough hewn timber constructed in 1836. The two-story house was approximately 30 feet by 40 feet in dimension. It had neither running water, plumbing, electricity nor central heating.
Between 1918 and 1943, MHI made various repairs and improvements to the building, including painting and installation of bathroom facilities. The evidence shows that during these years MHI never used the building as a year-round residence home for the elderly. Rather, small groups of the residents of Memorial Home were taken to the Baxter property for short summer outings between 1918 and 1943. However, for a number of intervening years the building was not even open because the Memorial Home residents preferred the comforts of Memorial Home to the rigorous conditions of the Baxter property, or because those residents who enjoyed the summer outings were considered too frail to go. On account of storm damage in 1939 and severe vandalism, the building deteriorated and a decision was made to demolish it. Since 1943, there has been no structure on the Baxter property.
The acreage surrounding the building has been leased for farming purposes since 1918 and MHI has paid all the taxes. There is evidence that the trustees participated in the management of the property until the last surviving trustee, Dr. DeFoe, died in 1944. SWCA's charter expired in 1932 but was revived in 1937.
In 1955, Memorial Home Board was incorporated as Memorial Home, Inc., (MHI). In 1956 SWCA quitclaimed all of its interest in the Baxter property to MHI. In addition, all assets held by SWCA for the benefit of Memorial Home were transferred to MHI.
Between 1957 and 1974, MHI continued to pay the property taxes on the Baxter property, rejecting all offers of sale, formed a Baxter Road Development Committee, drafted several resolutions endorsing development of a home on the property, and commissioned three sets of architectural drawings and a development feasibility...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Pilgrim Evangelical Lutheran Church of Unaltered Augsburg Confession of St. Louis, Mo. v. Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod Foundation
...has expressed a general charitable intent, a court may apply the doctrine of cy pres to continue the trust if requested. Comfort v. Higgins, 576 S.W.2d 331, 336 (Mo. banc 1978). If the settlor makes an express provision as to the disposition of the property in case the particular purpose fa......
-
Wulff v. Washington, WD
...All concur. 1 The following authorities provide some guidance in the matter of deposits in court of disputed funds: See Comfort v. Higgins, 576 S.W.2d 331 (Mo. banc 1978); State ex rel. State Highway Commission v. Paul, 368 S.W.2d 419 (Mo. banc 1963); 26A C.J.S. Deposits in Court ...
-
Woods v. State, 15995
...to which a cause has been assigned has exclusive jurisdiction of the cause and no other division may take jurisdiction. Comfort v. Higgins, 576 S.W.2d 331, 340 (Mo. banc 1978); State v. Armstrong, 605 S.W.2d 526, 529 (Mo.App.1980). However, the record before us indicates that the cause was,......
-
Vollmann v. Rosenburg
...the trust has failed. The language of the will demonstrates Mable Bick evinced a specific intent in creating the trust. See Comfort v. Higgins, 576 S.W.2d 331, 338 (Mo. banc 1978). Accordingly, the cy pres doctrine cannot be used. The issue is upon the failure of the trust whether the prope......