Creasy v. Lawler

• Decision Date: 28 June 1957
• Docket Number: 3140
• Parties: J. K. CREASY, William W. McNamee, Frank Ranallo, A. W. Tuiccillo, Ed Kleeman and R. G. Cummiskey, on Behalf of Themselves and Other Property Owners and Lessees Similarly Situated, Original Plaintiffs, and Charles Sodini, Joseph Sodini, Donald Dawson, Malinda Dawson, Thomas J. Clark, George J. Paulos and Joseph Ranallo, Additional Plaintiffs, Appellants, v. Joseph LAWLER, Secretary of Highways of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and George M. Leader, Governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Defendants, Appellees. Appeal of J. K. CREASY et al.
• Court: Pennsylvania Supreme Court

133 A.2d 178

389 Pa. 635

J. K. CREASY, William W. McNamee, Frank Ranallo, A. W. Tuiccillo, Ed Kleeman and R. G. Cummiskey, on Behalf of Themselves and Other Property Owners and Lessees Similarly Situated, Original Plaintiffs, and Charles Sodini, Joseph Sodini, Donald Dawson, Malinda Dawson, Thomas J. Clark, George J. Paulos and Joseph Ranallo, Additional Plaintiffs, Appellants, v. Joseph LAWLER, Secretary of Highways of the Commonwealth of

Pennsylvania and George M. Leader, Governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Defendants, Appellees. Appeal of J. K. CREASY et al.

No. 3140

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

June 28, 1957

Argued April 17, 1957

Appeal, No. 28, May T., 1957, from order of Court of Common Pleas of Dauphin County, Dec. T., 1956, No. 2183, in equity, in case of J. K. Creasy et al. v. Joseph Lawler, Secretary of Highways of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and George M. Leader, Governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Order affirmed; reargument refused July 26, 1957.

Same case in court below: 8 D. & C.2d 535.

Equity.

Defendants' preliminary objections sustained and final order entered dismissing complaint, opinion by SOHN, J. Plaintiffs appealed.

Edward P. Good, with him Thomas D. Caldwell, A. E. Kountz, William A. Meyer, Alexander Unkovic, Kountz, Fry & Meyer and Caldwell, Fox & Stoner, for appellants.

Thomas D. McBride, Attorney General, with him Joseph L. Donnelly, Deputy Attorney General and Leonard M Mendelson, for appellees.

Before JONES, C.J., BELL, CHIDSEY, MUSMANNO, ARNOLD and JONES, JJ.

OPINION

PER CURIAM

Order affirmed on the opinion of Judge WALTER R. SOHN, reported in 8 D. & C. 2d 535.