Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., No. 22851.
Decision Date | 31 July 2000 |
Docket Number | No. 22851. |
Citation | 93 Haw. 477,6 P.3d 349 |
Parties | Cheryl CRICHFIELD and Gary Crichfield, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. GRAND WAILEA COMPANY, a Domesitc Limited Partnership, Defendant-Appellee, John Does 1-10; Jane Does 1-10; Doe Partnerships 1-10; Doe Corporations 1-10; Roe "Non-Profit" Corporations 1-10; and Roe Governmental Entities 1-10, Defendants. |
Court | Hawaii Supreme Court |
Roy K.S. Chang and Harvey M. Demetrakopoulos, on the briefs, Honolulu, for the plaintiff-appellants Cheryl Crichfield and Gary Crichfield.
Patricia M. NaPier, Normand R. Lezy, and Tonya C. Kong, of Goodsill, Anderson, Quinn & Stifel, on the briefs, Honolulu, for the defendant-appellee Grand Wailea Company.
The plaintiffs-appellants Cheryl Crichfield ("Cheryl") and Gary Crichfield ("Gary") [collectively, "the Crichfields"] appeal from the second circuit court's order, filed on September 13, 1999, granting summary and final judgment against them and in favor of the defendant-appellee Grand Wailea Company ("Grand Wailea"). On appeal, the Crichfields contend that the circuit court erroneously granted summary judgment against them and in favor of Grand Wailea, inasmuch as there was a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether the Crichfields were present on land owned by Grand Wailea for a "recreational purpose," within the meaning of the Hawai`i Recreational Use Statute (HRUS), Hawai`i Revised Statutes (HRS) chapter 520 (1993 & Supp.1997), see infra section III.A.
We vacate the circuit court's order and remand the matter to the circuit court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
During the first week of September 1997, the Crichfields were registered guests of the Four Seasons Hotel on the island of Maui. On their last scheduled day in Hawai`i, the Crichfields were walking around the grounds of the Grand Wailea Resort, Hotel, and Spa ("the hotel"), which is located adjacent to the Four Seasons Hotel. The Crichfields left the walking path in order to get a better look at the fishpond and statuary on the hotel's grounds. While on the grass near the fishpond, Cheryl decided to remove her slippers. Lifting her left leg, she pushed her left slipper off her foot using her knee. When she placed her left foot back on the ground, she slipped and fell. In an effort to break her fall, she thrust out her right hand. Cheryl broke her arm, resulting in severe complications. The accident occurred on September 6, 1997.
On January 29, 1998, the Crichfields were interviewed by John Reitzel, a representative of Ward North America. He introduced himself to the Crichfields as an independent insurance administrator working on behalf of Grand Wailea. During her recorded interview with Reitzel, Cheryl described why she and her husband had taken a walk on the grounds of the hotel:
We had taken a scuba diving lesson and finished and decided to walk next door to see the grounds of the Grand Wailea statuary and the pond and had walked on the sidewalk that was adjoining the Four Seasons and walked up that way.
According to Cheryl, the accident took place "[r]ight on the edge of the pond, on the beach[;] there's a very large exotic fish pond with statuary and it was right, right there." She described the accident as follows:
We left the sidewalk, walked over toward the edge of the pond, um, I stopped to look at, to say something to my husband, I was kind of facing him. Went to take off my shoes, my sandals, because I wanted to walk on the grass. Took one sandal off, put my foot down and as I put my foot down, it felt, it was slick as glass. I started to fall. I've had four hips replaced, I've had my hips replaced four times due to advanced osteoporosis and I did not want to break a hip and I put my arm down to, break my fall. And in doing that, I broke my arm.
At the time of the accident, around 1:00 p.m., it was a "beautiful clear, clear as a bell, beautiful day."
In his recorded interview with Reitzel, Gary described the accident as follows:
(Some ellipsis points added and some in original). Gary did observe, however, that the area around Cheryl had become muddy after the police and emergency people arrived and traipsed around her.
On April 10, 1998, the Crichfields were interviewed by Chris Walby, a second representative of Ward North America. Cheryl explained further why she and her husband had decided to walk around the grounds of the Grand Wailea on September 6, 1997, as follows: That morning, Cheryl had become claustrophobic during a scuba diving lesson and could not continue the lesson. Gary, however, had completed the lesson and had gone scuba diving.
(Some ellipsis points added and some in original). Cheryl also added that, just prior to taking off her slipper, the last step she took "was squishy" but that she didn't feel any actual moisture on or in her slipper. Rather, it was "a spongy muddy feeling." At the end of the interview, Walby again asked what "the purpose [was] for your going to the Grand Wailea," to which Cheryl replied: "To look at the statuary and the pond and just the different, different location, I wanted to see what another hotel would look like."
In his interview with Walby, Gary explained that he had first visited the Grand Wailea two days before the accident because he "had been told there was some beautiful artwork, some bronze sculpturing, to view on the property." He "wandered around the grass area where these sculptures were and took pictures of them at that time with [his] camera and returned back and told [his] wife[,] `We have to go, we have to go, you have to see this.'" In response to Walby's question, "[S]o was that the sole purpose of your returning to the Grand Wailea on the date of the accident," Gary responded, "Yes it was."
On July 22, 1998, the Crichfields filed a complaint against Grand Wailea and the Doe defendants, in which they asserted claims grounded in negligence, breach of warranty, and strict products liability. On August 27, 1998, Grand Wailea filed its answer, in which, inter alia, it asserted HRUS as an affirmative defense. The Crichfields filed an amended complaint on September 23, 1998, which Grand Wailea answered on October 15, 1998, again asserting HRUS as an affirmative defense. Grand Wailea filed a motion for summary judgment on all of the Crichfields's claims on June 18, 1999. In the motion, Grand Wailea argued that Cheryl's negligence claim—and, a fortiori, Gary's derivative...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Troyer v. Adams
...light of this history, it is incumbent on this court to apply Act 300 as intended by the legislature. See Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., 93 Hawai'i 477, 483, 6 P.3d 349, 355 (2000) (holding that when the Supreme Court construes a statute, its foremost obligation is to ascertain and give ef......
-
Sallee v. Stewart
...who had fallen into a frozen pond was not engaged in a recreational use. 80 N.J. 391, 403 A.2d 910, 915 (1979). Similarly, in Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., a land user who asserted she was on a hotel's property to eat lunch was injured when she left a footpath to admire the hotel's fishpo......
-
Coon v. City and County of Honolulu
...plain language, we nonetheless note that the ordinance's legislative history confirms our view. Cf. Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., 93 Hawai`i 477, 488-89, 6 P.3d 349, 360-61 (2000) (reviewing legislative history to confirm court's holding based on statute's clear and unambiguous language);......
-
State v. Entrekin
...the statute's plain language, we nonetheless note that its legislative history confirms our view. Cf. Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., 93 Hawai`i 477, 488-89, 6 P.3d 349, 360-61 (2000) (reviewing legislative history to confirm court's holding based on statute's clear and unambiguous language......
-
Chapter § 4.04 LIABILITY OF HOTELS AND RESORTS FOR COMMON TRAVEL PROBLEMS
...the carpet's condition was an "obvious hazard that [guest] would reasonably have been expected to avoid"); Crichfield v. Grand Wailea Co., 93 Haw. 477, 6 P.3d 349 (Haw. Sup. 2000) (slip and fall in Hawaii hotel); Richardson v. Sport Shinko, 880 P.2d 169 (Hawaii Sup. 1994) (guest kneels on s......