Desantis v. Fla. Educ. Ass'n
Decision Date | 21 December 2020 |
Docket Number | No. 1D20-2633, No. 1D20-2634,1D20-2633 |
Citation | 313 So.3d 151 |
Parties | Governor Ron DESANTIS ; Florida Commissioner of Education Richard Corcoran; State of Florida Department of Education; and the State Board of Education, Petitioners, v. FLORIDA EDUCATION ASSOCIATION; Stefanie Beth Miller; Ladara Royal; Mindy Festge; Victoria Dublinohenjes; Andres Henjes; National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, Inc.; and NAACP Florida State Conference, Respondents. Governor Ron Desantis ; Andy Tuck, Chair of the State Board of Education; State Board of Education; Florida Commissioner of Education Richard Corcoran; State of Florida Department of Education; and Jacob Oliva, Chancellor, Division of Public Schools, Petitioners, v. Monique Bellefleur, individually and on behalf of D.B. Jr., M.B., and D.B.; Kathryn Hammond ; Ashley Monroe; and James Lis, Respondents. |
Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Joseph W. Jacquot, Raymond F. Treadwell, and Joshua E. Pratt, Executive Office of the Governor, Tallahassee; Matthew H. Mears, Judy Bone, and Jamie M. Braun, Florida Department of Education, Tallahassee; and Kenneth B. Bell, David M. Wells, Lauren V. Purdy, and Nathan W. Hill of Gunster, Yoakley & Stewart, P.A., Tallahassee, for Petitioners.
Kendall B. Coffey, Josefina M. Aguila, and Scott A. Hiaasen of Coffey Burlington, P.L., Miami; Lucia Piva, Mark Richard, and Kathleen M. Phillips of Phillips, Richard & Rind, P.A., Miami; Ronald G. Meyer of Meyer, Brooks, Blohm & Hearn, P.A., Tallahassee; Kimberly C. Menchion, Florida Education Association, Tallahassee; Katherine E. Giddings and Kristen M. Fiore of Akerman LLP, Tallahassee; Gerald B. Cope, Jr. of Akerman LLP, Miami; Ryan D. O'Connor of Akerman LLP, Orlando; Jacob V. Stuart of Jacob V. Stuart, P.A., Orlando; William J. Wieland, II of Wieland & DeLattre, P.A., Orlando, for Respondents.
The Governor and several state agencies and agency heads petition this court for relief through certiorari. They ask us to quash the trial court's orders denying their motions to dismiss filed in two cases. In those motions, the petitioners argued, essentially, that the respondents lacked standing, that their complaints failed to state legally cognizable causes of action for declaratory relief, and that the respondents raised non-justiciable political questions. We lack jurisdiction to proceed.
Certiorari ultimately is discretionary relief, but before we have authority to order a response or otherwise proceed on the merits of these petitions, we must satisfy ourselves that the petitions plead a basis for jurisdiction—that the petitioners stand to suffer a significant harm that cannot adequately be corrected in a later, plenary direct appeal. See Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp. v. San Perdido Ass'n, Inc. , 104 So. 3d 344, 351 (Fla. 2012) (); Jaye v. Royal Saxon, Inc. , 720 So. 2d 214, 215 (Fla. 1998) (); see also Williams v. Oken , 62 So. 3d 1129, 1132 (Fla. 2011) ( ).
In making this threshold jurisdictional assessment, we note that certiorari is extraordinary relief, and it may "not be used to circumvent the interlocutory appeal rule which authorizes appeal from only a few types of non-final orders." Martin-Johnson, Inc. v. Savage , 509 So. 2d 1097, 1098 (Fla. 1987). "Generally, all other appellate review is postponed until the matter is concluded in the trial court." Id. Florida judicial policy limits common law certiorari review so as to avoid "piecemeal review of nonfinal trial court orders [that] will impede the orderly administration of justice." Jaye , 720 So. 2d at 215. Following on this principle, "[o]rdinarily, orders on motions to strike or dismiss claims do not qualify for review by certiorari." Martin-Johnson , 509 So. 2d at 1099 ; see also Williams , 62 So. 3d at 1134 (); Hotel Roosevelt Co. v. Hill , 196 So. 2d 233, 233 (Fla. 1st DCA 1967) ( ).
The petitioners fail to allege an adequate basis for certiorari jurisdiction in these two cases. On the face of the petitions, we find nothing that distinguishes these cases from the typical declaratory judgment action against a state officer or agency that challenges the constitutionality of a statute or state action. Invariably, a motion to dismiss ensues in such a case. Oftentimes, the motion will fail, and the sued state officer or agency must litigate and defend against the asserted claim, just as a private defendant must do in a private right suit. Frustrating as this might be, the time and expense of defending a case, in the face of a denial of dismissal that the defendant fervently believes is erroneous, is not the type of harm that can support certiorari. Cf. Jaye , 720 So. 2d at 215 ; Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp. , 104 So. 3d at 355 ( ); id. at 356 (); see also Martin-Johnson , 509 So. 2d at 1099–1100 (...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Reliable Restoration, LLC v. Pan. Commons, L.P.
...continued defense of a lawsuit as irreparable harm that could support certiorari jurisdiction); see also DeSantis v. Florida Educ. Ass'n , 313 So.3d 151 (Fla. 1st DCA Dec. 21, 2020) (explaining that jurisdiction to consider certiorari relief cannot be based on the time and expense exhausted......
-
University of Florida Board of Trustees v. Carmody
...doctor] was a qualified expert under the statute ... is insufficient to merit certiorari review"); see also DeSantis v. Fla. Educ. Ass'n , 313 So. 3d 151, 154 (Fla. 1st DCA 2020) (deducing from Williams that "a mere erroneous ruling that results from that process cannot establish the jurisd......
-
Univ. of Fla. Bd. of Trs. v. Carmody
... ... is insufficient to merit certiorari ... review"); see also DeSantis v. Fla. Educ ... Ass'n, 313 So.3d 151, 154 (Fla. 1st DCA 2020) ... (deducing from ... ...
-
Synot Constr., LLC v. Page
...344, 355 (Fla. 2012) (rejecting "continuation of defending a lawsuit" as basis for showing irreparable harm); DeSantis v. Fla. Educ. Ass'n , 313 So. 3d 151, 154 (Fla. 1st DCA 2020) ("Frustrating as this might be, the time and expense of defending a case, in the face of a denial of dismissal......