DiNuzzo v. Dan Perkins Chevrolet Geo, Inc.
Citation | 294 Conn. 132,982 A.2d 157 |
Decision Date | 10 November 2009 |
Docket Number | No. 17869.,17869. |
Parties | Evana DiNUZZO v. DAN PERKINS CHEVROLET GEO, INC., et al. |
Court | Supreme Court of Connecticut |
Geraldine Ficarra, with whom was Robert J. Nicola, Trumbull, for the appellant (plaintiff).
G. Randall Avery, Stamford, for the appellee (defendants).
NORCOTT, KATZ, PALMER, VERTEFEUILLE and ZARELLA, Js.
The sole issue raised by this certified appeal is whether the Appellate Court properly reversed the decision of the compensation review board (board) upholding the decision of the workers' compensation commissioner for the third district (commissioner), who awarded the plaintiff, Evana DiNuzzo, survivor's benefits under General Statutes § 31-306(a).1 The Appellate Court concluded that there were insufficient subordinate facts in the record to support the commissioner's finding that the death of the plaintiff's husband, James DiNuzzo (decedent), was causally related to a compensable injury and, therefore, that the plaintiff was not entitled to survivor's benefits. DiNuzzo v. Dan Perkins Chevrolet Geo, Inc., 99 Conn.App. 336, 337, 913 A.2d 483 (2007). We agree and, accordingly, affirm the judgment of the Appellate Court.
The opinion of the Appellate Court sets forth the following relevant facts and procedural history. "Following the decedent's death, the plaintiff ... submitted a claim for dependent widow's benefits pursuant to ... § 31-306.... The decedent was employed by the [named] defendant [Dan Perkins Chevrolet Geo, Inc.]2 and sustained a compensable injury to his cervical spine when he was involved in a motor vehicle accident on June 26, 1997. As a result of the injury, the decedent experienced radiculopathy into his left side and [left arm]. He underwent [surgery, after which he] continued to experience [pain in his neck and the left side of his body, as well as numbness and tingling in] his left arm.
Id., at 338-40, 913 A.2d 483. Id., at 341, 913 A.2d 483.
On appeal to the Appellate Court, the defendant claimed, inter alia, that the board improperly had affirmed the commissioner's findings for two interrelated reasons, namely, that those "findings were predicated on expert medical testimony grounded in conjecture speculation or surmise," and that "the expert medical testimony was not supported by the subordinate facts...." Id., at 338, 913 A.2d 483. The Appellate Court agreed with both of the defendant's contentions. Id. In doing so, the Appellate Court first observed that the commissioner, in concluding that the plaintiff was entitled to survivor's benefits, had credited the testimony of Filiberto, the decedent's personal physician. Id., at 343-44, 913 A.2d 483. The Appellate Court stated: Id., at 343-44, 913 A.2d 483. The Appellate Court then concluded that the record was devoid of such facts, explaining: 3
4
5 ...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Kaczynski v. Kaczynski, No. 18235.
... ... T.J.E., Inc., 2 Conn.App. 294, 297, 478 A.2d 257 (1984), namely, that ... ...
-
Clements v. Aramark Corp.
...this respect, and in keeping with the remedial nature and humanitarian spirit of the act; see, e.g., DiNuzzo v. Dan Perkins Chevrolet GEO, Inc ., 294 Conn. 132, 150, 982 A.2d 157 (2009) ; our decisions reflect a relatively "[broad] conception of employment and of the nature of the risks ari......
-
Sapko v. State , No. 18680.
...of for the necessary causal connection.” (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) DiNuzzo v. Dan Perkins Chevrolet Geo, Inc., 294 Conn. 132, 141–42, 982 A.2d 157 (2009). As we previously have indicated, “[t]his court has defined proximate cause as [a]n actual cause that is a s......
-
Marandino v. Prometheus Pharmacy
...causation [in a workers' compensation case]." (Citation omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) DiNuzzo v. Dan Perkins Chevrolet GEO, Inc., 294 Conn. 132, 141, 982 A.2d 157 (2009). "An actual cause that is a substantial factor in the resulting harm is a proximate cause of that harm.... ......
-
Workers' Compensation Developments 2009
...at 149. For further discussion of DiNuzzo, see Section IV.B, infra. 59. Id. at 254. 60. See Conn. Gen. Stat. §§ 278 and 298 (2007). 61. 294 Conn. 132 (2009). 62. 294 Conn. 564 (2010). DiNuzzo was argued on February 8, 2008, and the official date of the opinion was November 10, 2009. Marandi......