Early v. Palm Beach Newspapers, Inc.
Citation | 354 So.2d 351 |
Decision Date | 31 May 1977 |
Docket Number | Nos. 49650,49625,s. 49650 |
Parties | 3 Media L. Rep. 2183 Lloyd F. EARLY, Appellant, Petitioner, v. PALM BEACH NEWSPAPERS, INC., etc., et al., Appellees, Respondents. |
Court | United States State Supreme Court of Florida |
Jos. D. Farish, Jr., Farish & Farish, West Palm Beach, for petitioner.
Harold B. Wahl, Jacksonville, Cecil H. Albury, West Palm Beach, John F. Law, Palm Beach, for respondents.
The Court having determined that it is without jurisdiction, it is ordered that the appeal from the District Court of Appeal, 334 So.2d 50, case no. 49,650, be and is hereby dismissed sua sponte.
Case No. 49,625 having heretofore been submitted to the Court on Petition for Writ of Certiorari, jurisdictional briefs and portions of the record deemed necessary to reflect jurisdiction under Florida Appellate Rule 4.5 c (6), and it appearing to the Court that it is without jurisdiction, it is ordered that the Petition for Writ of Certiorari be and the same is hereby denied.
Conflict does exist with several decisions cited by the petition, and accordingly this Court should exercise its discretion and assume jurisdiction of the cause to resolve the conflict and to dispose of the issues on the merits.
Petitioner, elected County Superintendent of Public Instruction of Palm Beach County, was successful in the trial court in an action for libel against respondents. A jury verdict awarded him $1,000,000 in compensatory and punitive damages, and final judgment was entered thereon. As appears from the District Court of Appeal, Fourth District, decision under review, respondents, two daily newspapers in Palm Beach, their editors and a reporter from each, embarked upon a concerted campaign admittedly designed to bring about the removal of Mr. Early from his elected position, and, in pursuance of said objective, published over a period of approximately fourteen months several hundred news articles and editorials, all of which were generally hostile to or critical of Early and many of which were defamatory.
In an order denying respondents' motion for new trial, motion for mistrial and motion for J.N.O.V., the trial court explained:
Upon appeal, the District Court of Appeal, Fourth District, reversed on the ground that the petitioner had not carried his burden of showing by clear and convincing evidence that the defamatory statements were made with knowledge of their falsity.
Petitioner submits that the subject District Court of Appeal, Fourth District, decision creates a new rule of law which permits the District Court to reweigh the evidence, retry the case, and generally substitute its judgment for that of the trial court. The Fourth District Court's decision does conflict with several decisions cited by petitioner to the effect that an appellate court is not free to substitute its judgment for the trier of fact or to reweigh the evidence and reach a different conclusion than the trial court, Crane & Crouse, Inc. v. Palm Bay Towers Corp., 326 So.2d 182 (Fla.1976), and to the effect that the existence or nonexistence of malice where the facts are controverted and there is evidence on the subject is a jury question. Coogler v. Rhodes, 38 Fla. 240, 21 So. 109 (1897), Montgomery v. Knox, 23 Fla. 595, 3 So. 211 (1887), Myers v. Hodges, 53 Fla. 197, 44 So. 357 (1907), Firestone v. Time, Inc., Fla., 305 So.2d 172, cert. granted, 421 U.S. 909, 95 S.Ct. 1557, 43 L.Ed.2d 773.
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Scott v. News-Herald
...with the holdings of other courts. See Palm Beach Newspapers, Inc. v. Early (Fla.App.1976), 334 So.2d 50, certiorari denied (Fla.1977), 354 So.2d 351; Cone v. Phipps Broadcasting Stations (D.Ga.1979), 5 Media L.Rep. (BNA) 1972; State v. Defley (La.1981), 395 So.2d 759. Accord Pickering v. B......
-
Brown Transport Corp v. Atcon, Inc
...Inc., 439 U.S. 910, 99 S.Ct. 277, 58 L.Ed.2d 255, opinion below, 334 So.2d 50 (Fla.App.1976), appeal and cert. dismissed, 354 So.2d 351 (Fla.1977): statements labeled as opinions or editorials and containing no misstatements of fact may not be the subject of a constitutionally valid libel I......
-
Church of Scientology of California v. Cazares
...decisions define the law of that state. In Palm Beach Newspaper, Inc. v. Early, 334 So.2d 50 (Fla.Dist.Ct.App. 1976), cert. denied, 354 So.2d 351 (1977), the court applied the principles of New York Times and Gertz to defamatory actions in Florida. In Early the court overturned a $1,000,000......
-
Wilkinson v. Florida Adult Care Ass'n, Inc., 83-1063
...373 So.2d 462 (Fla.1979) (town mayor); Palm Beach Newspapers, Inc. v. Early, 334 So.2d 50 (Fla. 4th DCA 1976), appeal dismissed, 354 So.2d 351 (Fla.1977), cert. denied, 439 U.S. 910, 99 S.Ct. 277, 58 L.Ed.2d 255 (1978) (superintendent of county school system); Thomson v. Cash, 119 N.H. 371,......