Eldred v. Kessler

Decision Date07 February 1900
Docket Number709.
PartiesELDRED v. KESSLER.
CourtU.S. Court of Appeals — Seventh Circuit

Appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Indiana.

The Chambers patent, No. 492,913, was granted upon an application filed November 21, 1892, and the drawings and specifications are as follows:

(Image Omitted)

'My invention relates to certain new and useful improvements in an electric lamp lighter, and it consists of the devices and appliances, their construction, combination, and arrangement as hereinafter specified and claimed, and illustrated in the accompanying drawings, in which Fig. 1 is a side elevation showing parts in section; Fig. 2 is a side elevation illustrating a modification of the invention; Fig. 3 is a detail view of the insulated cap; Fig. 4 is a partial side elevation, illustrating a modification of my invention; Fig. 5 is another detail, showing the insulating cap in section adjacent to the upper end of the lamp. The principle of my invention depends upon providing poles of an electric circuit adjacent to the end of the lamp to be lighted, the circuit being normally open, and in closing and breaking said circuit to produce an electric spark to ignite the lamp. My invention contemplates preferably making the electric circuit through a properly constructed lamp and an adjacent arm, and in breaking said circuit by a movement of the lamp or arm, to produce an igniting spark adjacent to the lamp when it is desired to light the lamp. To effect an economical use of electricity, and prevent an unnecessary running down of the battery, it will obviously be requisite to have the electric poles of the battery normally out of connection, so that the circuit shall be open. The object of my invention is to provide a device of this class of superior utility, which shall be simple, economical, and efficient, and which may be readily operated. I carry out my invention as follows: A represents any suitable support. B, B, is an electric battery. B' is an induction coil, connected therewith. C and C' are the wires connected with said coil. D denotes a standard upon which rests a lamp, E, provided with a wick tube, as at e. The chamber of the lamp is constructed preferably of metal. One of the wires, as the wire C, is electrically connected with said standard; the current, when the circuit is completed, passing through the standard and lamp and adjacent to the exposed portion of the wick. F denotes an arm which may be supported on said standard, D; said arm extended into proximity to the lamp wick. The other wire, as the wire C', is extended through said standard, and insulated therefrom, and electrically connected with said arm. G denotes insulating material, and H is a connecting metallic bar, electrically uniting said wire, C', and the arm, F; said bar being insulated from the standard, D, and from the lamp. The arm, F, may be fulcrumed upon the bar, H, as at h, and provided at its lower end with an operating handle. At the end adjacent to the lamp wick, the arm, F, is provided, preferably, with a piece of wire, F'; the wire being cooled, as shown at f, between its outer extremity and the arm. The extremity of the arm projects normally over the wick, at which point it is also provided with an insulating cap, F2, and with an extension, F3 (Fig. 5); the cap and its extension acting as an extinguisher. The lamp may have a removable engagement with the standard, D'; the standard being constructed with a flanged seat, d, for the lamp, the flange being provided with a retaining recess, as at d', and the lamp being provided with a pin, e', engaging said recess. The operation of the device as now described is evident. By moving the arm, F, upon its fulcrum, the wire tip, F', is brought first into contact with the metal of the lamp adjacent to the wick, thereby completing the electrical circuit. As the arm, F, continues to be moved further, said wire point is disconnected from the lamp, producing an electric spark adjacent to the lamp wick, and igniting the lamp. J is a spring to automatically return the arm, F, to normal position out of electrical connection with the lamp, and bringing the insulating cap and the extinguisher into position to extinguish the lamp. By removing the spring from its bearing upon the arm, it may be held out of normal position, allowing the lamp to burn freely for any length of time desired. The lamp may be thus removed from the standard and carried about, if desired. I do not limit myself to any particular material to supply combustion in the lamp, but find gasoline very suitable, and I prefer to saturate a supply of cotton, as indicated at e2, within the lamp, or analogous material, with the gasoline. Alcohol or other suitable material may, however, be used, instead of gasoline. As shown in Fig. 4, the lamp is hinged to the standard, as at E2. As so constructed, the arm, F, may remain stationary, and the lamp be moved, so as to form electrical connection with the wire tip upon the arm, F, and automatically light the wick. By this construction, shown in said last-named figure, either the arm or the lamp may be moved, as may be desired, to produce ignition. In Fig. 2, the lamp, instead of being directly supported upon the standard, is suspended upon shaft, K, of a gear, K', meshing with a gear, L, rigidly connected with the arm, F. By this latter construction, evidently, when the upper end of the arm is moved in one direction, the upper end of the lamp is moved in the opposite direction. In this case both the arm and lamp are movable. It will be seen, thus, that the lamp is self-lighting and self-extinguishing, by moving either the arm, F, or the lamp. The lamp, being movable, may be taken out from the support and carried about. The device is adapted for a wide variety of uses. It may conveniently be used as a cigar lighter, for lighting gas jets, and for other analogous purposes. As shown in Fig. 1, the standard, D, is vertically adjustable in the base, A, so as to raise and lower the lamp to a desired height. A set screw, M, may be provided to hold the standard in position. A screw, j, insulated from the standard, D, serves to hold the spring in place, while an additional similarly insulated screw, N, serves as a stop for the arm, D, when automatically returned to normal position. The screws may be made of insulating material, or the standard, D, may be provided with insulating material.'

Infringement is alleged of claims 1, 7, 10, and 12, reading as follows:

'(1) In an electric lamp lighter, the combination, with a lamp, the burner of which is formed into or provided with an electrode, and extinguisher formed into or provided with the opposite electrode, the means for establishing and breaking the electric connection between said electrodes substantially as set forth.'
'(7) In an electric lamp lighter, a metallic supporting standard, a metal lamp, a metal arm insulated from the standard and lamp and led into proximity to the lamp, an electric circuit through the arm, lamp, and standard, having its poles adjacent thereto; said lamp and arm and the one made movable in relation to the other, to make and bread said circuit at said poles, the circuit being normally open, substantially as described.'
'(10) In an electric lamp lighter, a lamp, a support therefor, an arm, led into proximity to the lamp, provided with an extinguisher, an electric circuit having its electrodes at the adjacent portions of the arm and lamp; said arm and lamp the one movable in relation to the other to close said circuit to ignite the lamp, and self-retracting to extinguish the lamp, said circuit being normally open, substantially as described.'
'(12) In an electric lamp lighter, the combination of a lamp, a support therefor, an arm overhanging the lamp tube, an electric circuit in electrical connection with the lamp and with said arm, a metallic bar, H, connecting said arm with the circuit and insulated from the standard and lamp; said lamp and arm the one made movable with relation to the other, to close the circuit and ignite the lamp, substantially as described.'

The Eberhard & Schimkatt patent, No. 522,934, was granted upon an application filed September 25, 1893, and the drawings and specifications are as follows:

'Our invention relates to improvements in electric cigar lighters, and it consists in certain features of construction and in combinations of parts hereinafter described and pointed out in the claims. A preferable construction embodying our invention is illustrated in the accompanying drawings in which Fig. 1 is a side elevation of the lighter, portions being broken away and in section to more clearly show the construction; Fig. 2 is a front side elevation of the lighter, or left-hand side elevation relative to Fig. 1, portions being broken away and in section to more clearly show the construction; Fig. 3 is an enlarged elevation in section, hereinafter more fully described. Fig. 4 is a top plan in section on line 4, 4, Figs 1 and 2. Referring to the drawings, A represents a lamp preferably composed of a metallic or electric current conducting tube open at its upper end for receiving a wick or suitable absorbent and inflammable material, a. The remaining portion of the tube is bent to form a loop or handle, A', that serves as a reservoir for receiving the oil or liquid fuel; said reservoir having a nozzle, A2, for filling purposes, a cap or plug, A3, being provided for said nozzle. The lamp is pivotally hung, as at C, between a pair of arms or brackets, B, that are suitably connected at the top by a cross member, B', suspended from the ceiling or support overhead by means of the insulated wires, D and D', that lead from the two terminals of an electric battery
...

To continue reading

Request your trial
7 cases
  • Hurd v. Seim
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Northern District of New York
    • July 26, 1911
    ...by Eldred's (the Chambers patent). That adjudication was affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals in the Seventh Circuit. Eldred v. Kessler, 106 F. 509, 45 C.C.A. 454. That became the law of the case in that circuit as to particular subject-matter between these parties and their privies. Th......
  • Eldred v. Breitwieser
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Western District of New York
    • August 30, 1904
    ... ... The patent relates to an ... improvement in electrical lamplighters. The moving papers ... show that the Circuit Court of Appeals for this circuit in ... Eldred v. Kirkland, 130 F. 342, and the Circuit ... Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Eldred v ... Kessler, 106 F. 509, 45 C.C.A. 454, have differently ... construed the scope of the patent in suit. In the latter ... case, which was the earlier, it was decided that the Chambers ... patent must be narrowly construed, and, as the defendant ... therein did not infringe the precise construction, the ... ...
  • General Ry. Signal Co. v. Union Simplex Train C. Co.
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — District of Delaware
    • May 4, 1938
    ...on the issue of noninfringement and dismissed the bill. The decree was affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. 106 F. 509. Subsequently Eldred filed a bill for infringement in the Western District of New York against a customer of Kessler, alleging infringement of ......
  • Eldred v. Kirkland
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Northern District of New York
    • July 18, 1903
    ... ... circuit to ignite the lamp, and self-retracting, to ... extinguish the lamp, said circuit being normally open, ... substantially as described.' ... This ... patent in question has been in litigation and was passed upon ... in the case of Eldred v. Kessler (Seventh Circuit, ... Feb. 7, 1900) 106 F. 509, 45 C.C.A. 454, that case was well ... considered both at the circuit and in the Circuit Court of ... Appeals, and this court does not deem it necessary to go ... further than to say it agrees with the holdings of the court ... in that case ... ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT