Evans v. Abbott
| Decision Date | 25 September 2003 |
| Docket Number | NO. 03-02-00719-CV.,03-02-00719-CV. |
| Parties | Frank Evans, Appellant v. Greg Abbott, Attorney General of the State of Texas, Appellee. |
| Court | Texas Court of Appeals |
Before Justices Kidd, Patterson and Puryear.
In 1999, the Austin Independent School District ("AISD") filed a petition for condemnation of land belonging to E. and Hettie Evans, as trustees for "The St. Johns Church of God in Christ # 2." AISD named appellant Frank Evans, E. Evans's brother, as a party with possible interest in the property. An attorney ad litem was appointed to represent the interests of appellant Frank Evans, the other named possible heirs, and all unknown heirs. In November 1999, a hearing was held before three special commissioners, and they found that the condemned property was worth $73,000, and awarded that sum to as well as appellant and several other parties. AISD deposited $73,000 with the trial court in December 1999.
In January 2000, Norris McDonald filed an affidavit stating he was "Bishop of the Church of God in Jesus Name f/k/a St. John's Church of God in Christ #2." McDonald stated that he had been friends with E. and Hettie Evans for about thirty years, and that they granted him a life estate in the property. McDonald stated that since 1994 he had spent about $15,000 and had done substantial work making the property suitable for use as a church. He sought to withdraw from the deposited funds the present-day value of his life estate and the sums he spent on the property. In March 2000, the trial court found that "the presence of a potential charitable trust" required that the Attorney General be given notice and an opportunity to investigate, and ordered the attorney ad litem to notify the Attorney General of the proceeding.
In July 2000, the Attorney General filed a petition in intervention, and in February 2001 moved to remove the attorney ad litem and to dismiss the claims of McDonald and other alleged heirs. The Attorney General attached as exhibits a 1975 warranty deed conveying the property from M.L. McGee to "E. Evans and Hettie Evans, for the St. Johns Church of God in Christ #2," and a copy of the records from the Travis County Appraisal District showing the "St Johns Church of God in Christ #2" as the owner of the property. The Attorney General sought to have the funds distributed to the Church of God in Christ, Second Ecclesiastical Southeast Jurisdiction of Texas. Appellant then filed his first pleadings in this cause, objecting to the Attorney General's motion and asserting a right to the deposited funds. The trial court ordered the bulk of the funds distributed to the Church of God in Christ, as requested by the Attorney General, awarded McDonald about $9,000 but denied his claim of a life estate, and denied appellant's and all other purported heirs' claims against the condemnation proceeds. Appellant then filed his notice of appeal.(1)
On appeal, appellant contends first that the Attorney General's petition in intervention was untimely and therefore should have been denied, and second that the trial court's order distributing the funds and denying appellant's claims is based on insufficient evidence.(2)
In his first issue on appeal, appellant contends that the Attorney General's intervention was untimely. A party may intervene if he could have brought the action, or a part thereof, on his own. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 60. An intervenor need not secure permission to intervene; a party who opposes the intervention has the burden to challenge it by a motion to strike. Guarantee Fed. Sav. Bank v. Horseshoe Operating Co., 793 S.W.2d 652, 657 (Tex. 1990) (op. on reh'g). A party may intervene any time before the final decision on the merits. In re Estate of York, 951 S.W.2d 122, 125 (Tex. App.—Corpus Christi 1997, no pet.); Litoff v. Jackson, 742 S.W.2d 788, 789 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 1987, no writ) (citing Smalley v. Taylor, 33 Tex. 668, 669 (1871); Delley v. Unknown Stockholders of Brotherly & Sisterly Club of Christ, Inc., 509 S.W.2d 709, 717 (Tex. Civ. App.—Tyler 1974, writ ref'd n.r.e.)).
The Attorney General filed his petition in intervention in July 2000, about eight months after the Special Commissioners filed their award and about seven months after the funds were deposited by AISD. In his petition, the Attorney General recites that he received notice of the condemnation proceeding in March 2000, when the attorney ad litem, acting pursuant to an order signed by the trial court, sent the Attorney General notice. See Tex. Prop. Code Ann. § 123.003 (West Supp. 2003). In March 2000, shortly after the Attorney General received notice of the proceeding, he informed the district clerk that he was investigating to determine whether he should participate and asked to be informed of any hearings. Appellant did not move to strike the Attorney General's intervention, nor did any other party. Appellant raised no complaint as to the Attorney General's involvement until the Attorney General filed a motion to distribute the funds, at which time appellant claimed a right to the deposited funds, essentially objecting to the Attorney General's proposed distribution, not to the intervention. Even if appellant had objected to the intervention, "[w]hether an intervention should be struck is in the discretion of the trial court and its exercise of that discretion is subject to review for abuse of discretion." Nacol v. State, 792 S.W.2d 810, 812 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 1990, writ denied). Appellant has not shown that the Attorney General's intervention was untimely or that the trial court abused its discretion in allowing the intervention. We overrule appellant's first issue on appeal.
In his second issue, appellant contends that the trial court's order distributing the deposited funds is not supported by the evidence. However, the record contains the 1975 warranty deed of the property to E. and Hettie Evans, "for the St. Johns Church of God in Christ #2," and the tax records of the Travis County Appraisal District indicate the property was owned by the St. Johns Church of God in Christ #2. See Tex. Prop. Code Ann. § 112.001...
To continue reading
Request your trial