Florida Min. and Materials Corp. v. Van Antwerp, 91-01801

• Decision Date: 24 June 1992
• Docket Number: No. 91-01801,91-01801
• Citation: 601 So.2d 621
• Parties: FLORIDA MINING AND MATERIALS CORP., a Florida corporation, Appellant/Cross-Appellee, v. Margaret VAN ANTWERP, as personal representative and surviving spouse of John E. Van Antwerp, deceased, Appellee/Cross-Appellant. 601 So.2d 621, 17 Fla. L. Week. D1577
• Court: Florida District Court of Appeals

Page 621

601 So.2d 621

FLORIDA MINING AND MATERIALS CORP., a Florida corporation Appellant/Cross-Appellee, v. Margaret VAN ANTWERP, as personal representative and surviving spouse of John E. Van Antwerp, deceased Appellee/Cross-Appellant.

No. 91-01801.

601 So.2d 621, 17 Fla. L. Week. D1577

District Court of Appeal of Florida Second District.

June 24, 1992.

Dennis P. Dore of Dennis P. Dore, P.A., Tampa, for appellant/cross-appellee.

James M. Callan, Jr., of James M. Callan, Jr., P.A., Clearwater, for appellee/cross-appellant.

PATTERSON, Judge.

Florida Mining and Materials Corp. (Florida Mining), the defendant in this wrongful death action, appeals from a final judgment entered after jury trial in favor of Margaret Van Antwerp, as personal representative and surviving spouse of John E. Van Antwerp (Van Antwerp). Van Antwerp cross-appeals. Both parties dispute the manner and amount of setoffs which the trial court applied to the $270,000 jury verdict in arriving at its $81,000 final judgment in favor of Van Antwerp. We reverse on the cross-appeal, rendering the issues in the appeal moot.

On March 25, 1986, John Van Antwerp was employed by R.H. Ower as a truck driver. In that capacity, he picked up a flatbed trailer Florida Mining had loaded with precast concrete slabs and delivered it to a job site Ellis Construction Company, Inc. (Ellis) controlled as general contractor. On arrival, employees of Cuyahoga Wrecking Corporation (Cuyahoga), a subcontractor of Ellis, directed Mr. Van Antwerp to park the cab and trailer in an uneven sandy area littered with debris. Cuyahoga employees then attempted to stabilize the trailer by placing materials under the wheels. When Mr. Van Antwerp released the chains holding the slabs in place on the trailer, the slabs began to tilt and fall. Mr. Van Antwerp attempted to get out of the way but stumbled and fell over debris. The slabs fell on him and he was killed.

Van Antwerp sued Florida Mining for negligently failing to properly secure the slabs to the trailer and Ellis for negligently maintaining the job site. Van Antwerp did not sue Cuyahoga, which was in bankruptcy. Florida Mining and Ellis cross-claimed against one another and later obtained permission of the bankruptcy court to bring third-party actions against Cuyahoga for contribution and indemnity. Van Antwerp did not assert a claim against the third-party defendant. ¹

The case was court referred to pretrial mediation, which resulted in a settlement between Van Antwerp, Ellis, and Cuyahoga in the total amount of $100,000. The case then proceeded to trial with Florida Mining as the sole defendant. The trial court submitted the case to the jury in a manner which resulted in a $270,000 verdict in favor of Van Antwerp and determined John Van Antwerp to be 10% negligent, Florida Mining 30% negligent, and Cuyahoga 60% negligent. ² Over objection by Van Antwerp, the trial court entered an $81,000 judgment against Florida Mining, which represents 30% of $270,000. In arriving at this amount, the trial court apparently relied in whole or in part on section 768.81, Florida Statutes (Supp.1986), ³ which requires the apportionment of damages based upon the respective parties' percentage of fault. This was error. Section 768.81 applies only to causes of action arising on or after July 1, 1986. See Walt Disney World Co. v. Wood, 515 So.2d 198 (Fla.1987); Sec. 768.71(2), Fla.Stat. (Supp.1986). This case arose on March 25, 1986, and is governed by the doctrine of joint and several liability, which holds...