Fox v. Bennett

Decision Date18 March 1892
Citation84 Me. 338,24 A. 878
PartiesFOX v. BENNETT et al.
CourtMaine Supreme Court

(Official.)

Exceptions from supreme judicial court, York county.

Trover and conversion by Charles T. Fox, administrator de bonis non, against John Bennett and another, executors. To the ruling of the court refusing them leave to plead anew, upon their demurrer being overruled, defendants except. Exceptions sustained.

Fox & Gentleman and G. F. Clifford, for plaintiff.

Fairfield & Moore, tor defendants.

EMERY, J. This was an action against two defendants as executors. The writ was served on only one defendant before entry, and was entered at the return terra, when that defendant appeared. At the return term the plaintiff obtained an order of notice upon the other defendant to appear at the then next term. This notice was served upon the other defendant, and he appeared at the then next term, as required by the order.

At this latter term, both defendants having appeared, their attorney desired to demur to the declaration, and claimed that under the above circumstances the then term was the first term for that purpose; and that he could plead anew if the demurrer should be overruled. But, to guard against the possibility that the court might rule otherwise, be stipulated "for leave to plead anew, upon payment of costs, if the demurrer should be overruled." The court granted such leave, as stipulated for, plaintiff's attorney being present and making no objection; and the attorney for the defendants filed a general demurrer to the declaration.

The demurrer was then joined and presented to the court, and overruled. The defendants' attorney thereupon paid into court the plaintiff's costs, and tendered a plea of the general issue, with a brief statement, under the stipulated leave to plead anew; and also moved for leave to file the same. The court ruled, as matter of law, that it had no discretionary power, under the circumstances, to allow the defendants to plead anew, and that it could not, if it would, receive the plea. The defendants excepted.

Without the stipulation at the time of filing the demurrer for such leave to plead anew, the court might have had no power to permit a plea to be filed after demurrer overruled, assuming that the term at which it was filed was the second term. Fryeburg v. Brownfield, 68 Me. 145. Without passing upon the question whether the demurrer was filed at the first term, we think that, under the stipulation, the court had the power to receive the plea in its discretion.

The attorney for the defendants was desirous of having the sufficiency of the declaration determined before going to trial, and yet was apprehensive that the court might not only overrule bis demurrer, but also rule...

To continue reading

Request your trial
3 cases
  • Hutchins v. Libby
    • United States
    • Maine Supreme Court
    • December 30, 1953
    ...party to withdraw it is not obtained, no such right exists. The judgment in such a case is final.' In the case of Fox v. Bennett, 1892, 84 Me. 338, 340, 24 A. 878, when a defendant at the time of the filing of a demurrer to the declaration subsequent to the first term, expressly stipulates ......
  • Clark v. Boyd
    • United States
    • Maine Supreme Court
    • January 31, 1921
    ...to plead over, the judgment should be final at the next term. Section 36, a 87, B. S.; Fryeburg v. Brownfield, 68 Me. 145; Fox v. Bennett, 84 Me. 338, 24 Atl. 878; Rollins v. Power Co., 112 Me. 175, 91 Atl. 837; Furbish v. Robertson, 67 Me. Exceptions overruled. Final judgment for the plain......
  • Tripp v. Park St. Motor Corp.
    • United States
    • Maine Supreme Court
    • December 1, 1922
    ...stipulation was made at the time of tiling and assented to by the court and plaintiff, that the defendant might plead anew. Pox v. Bennett, 84 Me. 338, 24 Atl. 878. Under chapter 219, § 4, P. L. 1823, sections 17 and 18, c. 96, R, S. 1841, and chapter 246, P. L. 1852, § 8, it may well be th......

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT