Gallagher Bassett Services v. Phillips
Decision Date | 11 April 2008 |
Docket Number | 1070416. |
Citation | 991 So.2d 697 |
Parties | GALLAGHER BASSETT SERVICES, INC. v. Nelia D. PHILLIPS et al. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Mathew B. Richardson and Sidney W. Jackson III of Jackson, Foster & Graham, LLC, Mobile, for appellee Nelia D. Phillips.
Wesley Pipes and Ginger D. Johnson of Wesley Pipes, LLC, Mobile, for appellees John Patrick Couch, M.D., and Physician's Pain Specialist of Alabama, P.C. and John Patrick Couch, M.D.
Gallagher Bassett Services, Inc. ("Gallagher"), appeals from an order denying its motion for permission to intervene in an action by Nelia D. Phillips against Dr. John Patrick Couch and Physician's Pain Specialist of Alabama, P.C. ("PPSA"), alleging medical malpractice. We dismiss the appeal.
The dispositive facts are undisputed. On April 3, 2002, Phillips fell from a ladder and fractured her left wrist. The accident occurred while Phillips was in South Carolina engaged in her employment with RGIS Inventory Specialists ("RGIS"). She filed a claim with the South Carolina Workers' Compensation Commission against RGIS and its workers' compensation carrier, Gallagher, which began paying workers' compensation and medical benefits.
The medical benefits included payment for treatment by Dr. Couch for "complex regional pain syndrome of the left upper extremity and hand." That treatment included the surgical implantation on June 25, 2003, of a "spinal cord stimulation device" to alleviate pain. On June 23, 2005, however, after suffering a series of complications associated with the implantation, Phillips commenced a medical-malpractice action against Dr. Couch and PPSA.
Phillips did not apprise Gallagher or RGIS of the litigation in the manner prescribed by S.C.Code 1976, § 42-1-560(b). Nevertheless, RGIS learned of the action, and its attorney sent a letter dated April 12, 2006, to Phillips's attorney, stating:
(Emphasis added.)1
On July 13, 2006, the attorney for RGIS and Gallagher addressed another letter to Phillips's attorney, stating, in pertinent part:
Phillips's attorney responded with a letter dated July 18, 2006, stating, in pertinent part:
In September 2007, the parties in Phillips's medical-malpractice action agreed to a settlement and, on October 18, 2007, filed the following joint "stipulation of dismissal with prejudice": "Pursuant to Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1), all parties who have appeared in this action, Plaintiff, Nelia D. Phillips, and Defendants, [PPSA] and [Dr. Couch], stipulate to the dismissal on the merits, with prejudice, of Defendants, [PPSA] and [Dr. Couch]."
The next day, October 19, 2006, Gallagher filed a "motion for leave to intervene" and a proposed complaint in intervention. The complaint "demand[ed] satisfaction of its statutory workers' compensation subrogation lien." On October 26, 2007, the trial court denied Gallagher's motion, and Gallagher appealed.
On appeal, Gallagher contends that the trial court exceeded its discretion in denying its motion for permission to "intervene to protect its statutory lien following the settlement of the underlying medical-malpractice case." Gallagher's brief, at vii. According to Gallagher, its right to intervene arises under S.C.Code 1976, § 42-1-560(b), which provides, in pertinent part:
(Emphasis added.)
Dr. Couch, PPSA, and Phillips, on the other hand, insist that this appeal must be dismissed, because, they say, the stipulation of dismissal terminated the medical-malpractice action, rendering void the order challenged by Gallagher, from which no appeal may lie. For that proposition, they cite Greene v. Town of Cedar Bluff, 965 So.2d 773 (Ala.2007). We agree.
Greene stands for the proposition that...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Sturdivant v. BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP.
...at 321 ; and Cadle Co., 950 So.2d at 280. Additionally, because a void judgment will not support an appeal, Gallagher Bassett Servs., Inc. v. Phillips, 991 So.2d 697, 701 (Ala.2008), this appeal must be dismissed for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. Blevins, 51 So.3d at 323.For the reas......
-
Working v. Jefferson County Election Comm'n
...an appeal.'" Wehle v. Bradley, [Ms. 1081433, April 16, 2010]___So. 3d____, ____ (Ala. 2010) (quoting Gallagher Bassett Servs., Inc. v. Phillips, 991 So. 2d 697, 701 (Ala. 2008)). Accordingly, we must dismiss the Working plaintiffs' appeal insofar as it seeks payment of attorney fees and exp......
-
Bon Harbor Llc v. Bank
...As a result, the March 25, 2008, order was void and would not support an appeal. 20 So.3d at 1266 (citing Gallagher Bassett Servs., Inc. v. Phillips, 991 So.2d 697, 701 (Ala.2008)). Accordingly, this Court dismissed the appeals in both case no. 1070902 and case no. 1070994. After dismissal ......
-
Ex parte Scoggins
...et seq., such authority could not empower the circuit court to revive an action that had so long ago ceased to exist. In Gallagher Bassett Services, 991 So.2d at 700-01, this Court "After the stipulation of dismissal was filed in this case, there ceased to be a justiciable controversy over ......