Garrison v. Board of Trustees of Memorial Hosp. of Laramie County, Wyo.
Decision Date | 19 July 1990 |
Docket Number | No. 89-200,89-200 |
Citation | 795 P.2d 190 |
Parties | Richard L. GARRISON, M.D., Appellant (Plaintiff), v. BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF MEMORIAL HOSPITAL OF LARAMIE COUNTY, WYOMING, Appellee (Defendant). |
Court | Wyoming Supreme Court |
Daniel E. White of Vines, Gusea & White, P.C., Cheyenne, for appellant.
Gregory C. Dyekman of Dray, Madison & Thomson, P.C., Cheyenne, for appellee.
Before CARDINE, C.J. * , and THOMAS, URBIGKIT, MACY and GOLDEN, JJ.
This appeal addresses the propriety of the appellee's, Board of Trustees of Memorial Hospital of Laramie County (Trustees), denial of appellant's, Richard L. Garrison, M.D., application for appointment to the medical staff at Memorial Hospital (Hospital). The Trustees denied Dr. Garrison's application on November 4, 1988. On December 5, 1988, Dr. Garrison filed a complaint in the district court seeking declaratory, monetary and injunctive relief. The district court upheld the decision of the Trustees and, on appeal, Dr. Garrison challenges that order.
We affirm.
Dr. Garrison states the issues to be:
The Trustees summarize the case in one issue:
On May 26, 1988, Dr. Garrison submitted an application for appointment to the medical staff of the Hospital. He used a form supplied by the Hospital which provides:
Dr. Garrison completed the application form. In answer to the question: he answered "no." 1 In response to a routine inquiry to former sites of medical practice, the Hospital received a letter from the medical director of Thomas Memorial Hospital, South Charleston, West Virginia. The letter contained the following passage:
The record also contains a letter from Dr. Garrison to Thomas Memorial Hospital, dated December 13, 1985, in which he resigned from the medical staff of that hospital.
At the hearing before the Medical Staff Joint Hearing Committee of Memorial Hospital, Dr. Garrison explained at length his reasons for answering "no" to the question at issue. He explained that he felt any questions about his competence had been decided in his favor and that he understood that his settlement of the issue with Thomas Memorial Hospital included an agreement that the action against his privileges By letter dated August 23, 1988, the Executive Committee of the Hospital (as well as the Credentials Committee) informed Dr. Garrison that it would recommend to the Trustees that his application be denied because of his answer of "no" to item D, supra. Dr. Garrison was also informed of his right to a hearing before the Joint Hearing Committee. A hearing was conducted at Dr. Garrison's request on September 13, 1988. By letter dated September 23, 1988, Dr. Garrison was informed that the Joint Hearing Committee would recommend denial of Dr. Garrison's application to the Trustees. Dr. Garrison was given notice by letter dated October 18, 1988, that the Trustees would provide an appellate review of the Joint Hearing Committee's decision. That hearing was conducted on October 31, 1988, and by letter dated November 4, 1988, the Trustees informed Dr. Garrison that they affirmed the decision of the Joint Hearing Committee saying:
We note also that the record contains an application for medical staff privileges at Putnam General Hospital, Hurricane, West Virginia, which is dated July 22, 1987. In that application, Dr. Garrison answered a similar question "yes." At the hearing before the district court, Dr. Garrison explained that he had answered that way even though he had been advised by Putnam General Hospital personnel that he Dr. Garrison filed his civil action in the district court seeking declaratory,...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Egan v. St. Anthony's Medical Center
...404 S.E.2d 750, 755 (1991); Seitzinger v. Cmty. Health Network, 270 Wis.2d 1, 676 N.W.2d 426 (2004); Garrison v. Bd. of Trs. of Mem'l Hosp. of Laramie County, 795 P.2d 190, 193 (Wyo.1990); Balkissoon v. Capitol Hill Hosp., 558 A.2d 304, 307 ...
-
Garrison v. Herbert J. Thomas Memorial Hosp. Ass'n
...to a question on the application as to whether he had ever been suspended, Dr. Garrison answered "no." Garrison v. Board of Trustees of Memorial Hospital, 795 P.2d 190, 191 (Wyo.1990). As part of its consideration of Dr. Garrison's application, Memorial Hospital requested information from T......
-
Devous v. Wyoming State Bd. of Medical Examiners, s. 91-212
...of constitutional principles with respect to licensure is consistent with our law in Wyoming. In Garrison v. Bd. of Trustees of Memorial Hospital of Laramie County, 795 P.2d 190 (Wyo.1990), we acknowledged that the right to practice medicine is a conditional property right subject to the po......
-
Guier v. Teton County Hosp. Dist.
...in accordance with reasonable hospital bylaws, and was not discriminatory, arbitrary, or capricious.Garrison v. Board of Trustees of Memorial Hospital, 795 P.2d 190, 193 (Wyo.1990).Standard & Burden of Proof [¶ 15] In his first issue, Dr. Guier asserts that the burden of proof in his contes......