Gay v. State
| Decision Date | 08 July 1941 |
| Citation | 3 So.2d 514,147 Fla. 690 |
| Parties | GAY v. STATE. |
| Court | Florida Supreme Court |
Rehearing Denied Aug. 1, 1941.
Appeal from Circuit Court, Taylor County; R. H. Rowe Judge.
Dickenson & Dickenson, of Tampa, and Ben Lindsey and J. F. McCall both of Perry, for appellant.
J. Tom Watson, Atty. Gen., and Nathan Cockrell, Asst. Atty. Gen for appellee.
We review on appeal a judgment of conviction under an indictment charging 'that Foster Gay, on the 7th day of December, A.D. 1939 in the County and State aforesaid, then and there unlawfully while Napoleon Wilson, a Deputy Sheriff of Taylor County Florida, and in and for Taylor County, Florida, was then and there in said County and State lawfully and by virtue of his said office as a Deputy Sheriff of said County proceeding to arrest the said Foster Gay for violating the law in the presence of him, the said Napoleon Wilson, by then and there maintaining and using, for the purpose of catching and taking commercial sponges from the Gulf of Mexico in waters within the territorial limits of the State of Florida, diving suits, helmets, and other apparatus used by deep sea divers, and he, the said Foster Gay, then and there well knowing that the said Napoleon Wilson to be a Deputy Sheriff of Taylor County, Florida, did knowingly, wilfully and unlawfully resist the said Napoleon Wilson in the discharge of his duty as such Deputy Sheriff, aforesaid, which said duty as a Deputy Sheriff he, the said Napoleon Wilson, was then and there attempting to perform, by then and there refusing to submit to arrest and by then and there assaulting, bruising, striking and ill treating the said Napoleon Wilson and by then and there doing violence to said Napoleon Wilson, as aforesaid, and thereby and thus did obstruct the said Napoleon Wilson as such deputy sheriff.'
It is noted that the indictment alleges as legal justification of the attempted arrest that,
'While Napoleon Wilson, a deputy sheriff, of Taylor County, Florida, and in and for Taylor County, Florida, was then and there in said County and State lawfully and by virtue of his said office as a Deputy Sheriff of said County, proceeding to arrest the said Foster Gay for violating the law in the presence of him, the said Napoleon Wilson, by then and there maintaining and using for the purpose of catching and taking commercial sponges from the Gulf of Mexico in waters within the territorial limits of the State of Florida, diving suits, helmets, and other apparatus used by deep sea divers.'
The record shows that the arrest was attempted without a warrant and was as for the commission of a misdemeanor in the presence of the officer attempting to make the arrest.
The record fails to show that the defendant in the presence of the officer was 'then and there maintaining and using for the purpose of catching and taking commercial sponges from the Gulf of Mexico * * * diving suits, helmets and other apparatus used by deep sea divers.'
Therefore, it follows that the attempted arrest was without authority of law. See Roberts v. Dean, 133 Fla. 47, 187 So. 571; Malone v. Howell, 140 Fla. 693, 192 So. 224.
The State's witnesses testified that neither of them saw the defendant using any equipment or apparatus in taking, or attempting to take, any sponges from the Gulf of Mexico at the time and place alleged or at any other time.
Aside from this the preponderance of the evidence, including that adduced from witnesses who were employees of the Conservation Commission of the State of Florida, shows that the defendant was at all times, on the stated occasion, when within sight of the officer, beyond the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
State v. Saunders
...that time, Florida law permitted citizens forcibly to resist unlawful arrests. Alday v. State, 57 So.2d 333 (Fla.1952); Gay v. State, 147 Fla. 690, 3 So.2d 514 (1941); Burgess v. State, 313 So.2d 479 (Fla.2d DCA 1975) Merits not reached 326 So.2d 441 (Fla.1976); English v. State, 293 So.2d ......
-
Phillips v. State, 74--670
...an unlawful arrest, and may use such force as is necessary to effect his escape. Alday v. State, 57 So.2d 333 (Fla.1952); Gay v. State, 147 Fla. 690, 3 So.2d 514 (1941); Cf., Wilbert v. State, 273 So.2d 769 (4th DCA Fla.1973); See 5 Am.Jur.2d Arrest § 94 (1962); 6 C.J.S. Arrest § 13 (1937),......
- State ex rel. Estep v. Richardson
-
Felton v. Hodges
...brief to support this proposition, United States v. Sands (S.D.Fla., No. 64-401-Cr-Cf, Jan. 11, 1965), and Gay v. Florida, 147 Fla. 690, 3 So.2d 514 (Fla.1941), are similarly 3 Among the numerous imprecise allegations of appellant's complaint pertaining to arrests is the following, to which......