Gibbes v. Planters' Fertilizer & Phosphate Co.
| Decision Date | 26 November 1912 |
| Citation | 76 S.E. 464,93 S.C. 193 |
| Parties | GIBBES v. PLANTERS' FERTILIZER & PHOSPHATE CO. |
| Court | South Carolina Supreme Court |
Appeal from Common Pleas Circuit Court of Charleston County; Ernest Gary, Judge.
"To be officially reported."
Action by John Gibbes against the Planters' Fertilizer & Phosphate Company. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals. Affirmed.
Miller, Whaley & Bissell, of Charleston, for respondent.
This is an appeal from an order of nonsuit in an action for damages for personal injuries. Plaintiff alleges that he was ordered to go on top of a pile of bags of fertilizer and pile other bags thereon; that while he was doing so the pile gave way, and he fell from the top of it into the kainit hole, a distance of some 25 feet, and some of the bags of fertilizer fell on him and injured him. The negligence alleged, upon which the action is based, is in ordering plaintiff into a dangerous place to work, made so because the bags in the pile were not "tied"--that is, laid crosswise in alternate layers--but were piled lengthwise on top of each other. The defense was a denial of the negligence alleged and the plea of assumption of risk.
Plaintiff testified that if the bags in the pile had been "tied" they would not have fallen; that he was sent on the pile by the colored foreman, who was also a common laborer. There was no testimony tending to show that the foreman was a vice principal, or that any representative of defendant had ordered the bags piled that way, or knew that they had been piled that way. There was therefore no evidence of negligence on the part of the defendant. The case is controlled by the principles announced in Martin v. Royster Guano Co., 72 S.C. 237, 51 S.E. 680, and Brabham v. Telephone & Telegraph Co., 71 S.C. 53, 50 S.E. 716.
Affirmed.
WATTS, J., did not sit.
To continue reading
Request your trial