Graff v. Lemp Brewing Co.
Decision Date | 06 April 1908 |
Citation | 130 Mo. App. 618,109 S.W. 1044 |
Parties | GRAFF v. LEMP BREWING CO. |
Court | Missouri Court of Appeals |
Appeal from Circuit Court, Jackson County; Hon. H. L. McCune, Judge.
Action by John Graff against the Lemp Brewing Company. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals. Reversed and remanded.
John I. Williamson, for appellant. F. V. Kander, for respondent.
Action by a tenant against his landlord to recover damages for personal injuries alleged to have been caused by the negligent failure of the landlord to repair. It is alleged in the petition that defendant, the lessee of a business house in Kansas City, sublet the storeroom on the first floor to plaintiff for use as a dramshop; "that at said time the floor of said storeroom was broken and decayed in various places and at the places hereinafter mentioned, and at the time plaintiff rented said storeroom, and as part of the contract of renting, and as part of the consideration for the payment by this plaintiff to defendant of said sum per month, defendant promised and agreed with plaintiff that it would put said storeroom in a good state of repair, and in particular would repair said hereinafter mentioned broken and decayed places in said floor; that, relying upon said agreement and contract on the part of defendant, plaintiff took possession of said storeroom on or about the 10th day of April, 1905, under said contract, and thereafter remained in possession thereof at all times hereinafter mentioned and duly fulfilled and performed all the conditions of said contract on his part; that defendant negligently and carelessly failed to repair said decayed and broken places in said floor, though often requested by plaintiff so to do, but whenever the matter was brought to defendant's attention by plaintiff defendant promised and agreed to make said repairs immediately and to put the same in a fit and proper condition for use, and for this reason plaintiff, relying upon said promises of defendant, did not make said repairs himself; that defendant at all times herein mentioned had notice of the existence, character, and extent of said defects in said floor, and had also...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Wood v. Gabler
...134 Mo. App. 1. (4) Damages arising in tort are not counterclaimable in a suit for rent on a month to month tenancy. Graff v. Lemp Brew. Co., 109 S.W. 1044, 130 Mo. App. 618; Dimmock v. Daly, 9 Mo. App. 354; Medelet v. Wales, 16 Mo. 214; Roberts v. Cotty, 74 S.W. 886, 100 Mo. App. 500; Gree......
-
Wood v. Gabler
... ... counterclaimable in a suit for rent on a month to month ... tenancy. Graff v. Lemp Brew. Co., 109 S.W. 1044, 130 ... Mo.App. 618; Dimmock v. Daly, 9 Mo.App. 354; ... ...
-
Combow v. Kansas City Ground Inv. Co.
...estate will create such a duty. No case cited by appellant involved a suit by a purchaser against a seller of real estate. In Graff v. Lemp Brewing Co., supra, a was permitted to recover in tort for personal injuries allegedly due to a breach by the landlord of a covenant to repair. That ca......
-
State ex rel. Fletcher v. Blair
... ... Ellison v. Power Co., 59 S.W.2d 714; Trout v ... Watkins, 148 Mo.App. 621; Graff v. Brewing Co., ... 130 Mo.App. 618. (6) It is no concern of the Supreme Court in ... certiorari ... ...