Graybar Electric Co., Inc. v. Industrial Commission of Utah
Decision Date | 07 March 1929 |
Docket Number | 4773 |
Citation | 73 Utah 568,276 P. 161 |
Court | Utah Supreme Court |
Parties | GRAYBAR ELECTRIC CO., Inc., v. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION OF UTAH et al |
Proceeding under the Industrial Commission Act by Walter C Frendt, employee, opposed by the Graybar Electric Company Inc., employer and self-insurer, to review an award of the Industrial Commission allowing compensation.
AFFIRMED.
Badger, Rich & Rich, of Salt Lake City, for plaintiff.
George P. Parker, Atty. Gen., and M. Logan Rich, Asst. Atty. Gen., for defendant commission.
Romney, Nelson & Eccles, of Salt Lake City, for defendant Frendt.
This is a proceeding to review an award of compensation by the Industrial Commission in favor of Walter C. Frendt and against the Graybar Electric Company, a self-insurer. The only question presented by this review is whether or not, under the facts, the employe was injured by an accident arising out of or in the course of his employment. The plaintiff denies there was any accident within the meaning of the Industrial Act (Laws 1917, c. 100, as amended). It does not deny the employe was injured while in the course of the employment, but does contend that the injury was not the result of an accident. The findings of the commission, material to the question before us, are:
3. "That on the 19th day of April, 1927, Walter C. Frendt, the applicant herein named, while regularly employed by the Graybar Electric Company, and while engaged in moving heavy reels and coils of wire, sustained a severe strain causing a left incomplete traumatic hernia and sacro iliac strain. That he was operated for inguinal hernia on May 3rd, 1927, and made an uneventful recovery from said operation.
4. "That the applicant on the date of said injury wherein he received a sacro iliac strain, was afflicted with sinus trouble, which, as a result of said injury, became localized in his back. That he was totally disabled from the 1st day of April, 1928, to the date of the hearing (May 14th, 1928) and will, in all probability, continue to be totally disabled until such time as he receives proper medical treatment for the chronic infection in the sinus.
Conclusion. "In view of the foregoing findings, the Commission concludes that Walter C. Frendt was injured by reason of an accident arising out of or in the course of his employment while regularly employed by the Graybar Electric Company, as alleged in his application." The employe worked for plaintiff regularly for about 15 months prior to his injury without missing a day, and received $ 25 per week. On April 19, 1927, in the course of his regular employment, while putting into stock some heavy coils of wire, and while "heaving on the rolls," he experienced a sharp pain in his left side in the region of the groin, felt sick to his stomach, and, finding the pain did not subside, left work and reported the matter to his foreman. A few days later he undertook to load a truck with coils of galvanized iron wire, each coil weighing approximately 150 pounds. The coils were in a stack three or four feet high. He lifted one of the coils from the stack, and, upon turning around for the purpose of putting it on the truck, he felt a pain in his back and another pain in the left side above the groin. The pain was so sharp he had to drop the coil and stand a while. This condition was reported to the manager who sent the employe to a doctor. It was found he had suffered a left incomplete hernia and a sacroiliac strain. He was operated on for the hernia, and made an uneventful recovery. We are not concerned here with the hernia. The sacroiliac condition did not respond to treatment. The employe now wears a brace or corset, still complains of pain and soreness in the back, and is unable to work.
Upon a thorough examination by a nose and throat specialist it was found that the employe had a chronic sinus infection with polypus in the nose. While in the army an operation had been performed on his nose and some of the bone taken out. It is the opinion of one physician that the pain in the back "may be arthritis of the lumbar sacro or sacro iliac joint," and that it was the result of the injury, plus infection from the nasal condition. Another physician examined him and gave as his diagnosis that this was "chronic infective arthritis of left sacro iliac joint, possibly super-imposed upon an injury."
There seems to be no dispute with regard to the facts, but it is earnestly contended by plaintiff that there was no accident which either caused or contributed to the condition from which Frendt is now suffering. Its position is stated as follows:
In support of this position the plaintiff quotes the definition of the word "accident" from Webster's New International Dictionary and 1 Honnold on Workmen's Compensation, pp. 274-278; cites the following Utah cases; Pinyon Queen Mining Co. et al. v. Industrial Commission, 59 Utah 402, 204 323, 204 P. 323; Tintic Milling Co. v. Industrial Commission, 60...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Jones v. California Packing Corporation
...defect of the body, when aggravated or lighted up by an industrial accident, is compensable under the act, Graybar Electric Co., Inc., v. Industrial Comm., 73 Utah 568, 276 P. 161; Thomas D. Dee Memorial Hospital Ass'n v. Industrial Comm., 104 Utah 61, 138 P.2d 233. And also that an interna......
-
Purity Biscuit Co. v. Industrial Commission
... 201 P.2d 961 115 Utah 1 PURITY BISCUIT CO. et al. v. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION et al No. 7096 ... 424, 123 A. 421, 60 A. L. R. 1293; ... Northwest Metal Products , Inc. v ... Department of Labor , 12 Wash.2d 155, 120 P. 2d 855; ... McEwan v. Ind. Comm. , 61 Utah 585, 217 P ... 690; Graybar Electric Co. v. Ind. Comm. , 73 ... Utah 568, 276 P. 161; Dee Memorial ... ...
-
Aranguena v. Triumph Mining Company
... ... 1. The ... findings of the Industrial Accident Board adverse to ... appellant upon ... (Carroll v. Industrial ... Accident Commission, 195 P. 1097 (Colo.) (2); ... Nicholson v. -Up Coal Mining Co., 257 P. 270 ... (Mont.) (10); Knock v ... 911; Taggart v. Ind. Com'n. (Utah), 12 P.2d 356.) ... Where ... there is ... Simpkins, 61 ... Utah 493, 214 P. 593; Graybar Electric Co. v. Industrial ... Commission, 73 ... ...
-
Robertson v. Industrial Commission
... 163 P.2d 331 109 Utah 25 ROBERTSON et al. v. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION et al ... Lumberm $@e$! n's Mutual Casualty ... Co. v. Griggs , 190 Ga. 277, 9 S.E.2d 84; ... Brown's ... L. R. 1293; ... Northwest Metal Products , Inc. v ... Department of Labor , 12 Wash.2d 155, 120 P. 2d ... Industrial Comm. , 83 ... Utah 94, 27 P. 2d 31; Graybar Electric Inc. v ... Industrial Comm. , 73 Utah 568, 276 ... ...