Greis v. Harjo
Decision Date | 03 October 1939 |
Docket Number | Case Number: 29845 |
Citation | 1939 OK 353,185 Okla. 474,94 P.2d 539 |
Parties | GREIS, Trustee v. HARJO |
Court | Oklahoma Supreme Court |
¶0 1. DAMAGES--Measure of Damages Where Damage to Land Is Permanent.
The measure of damage for the permanent injury of real property is the difference between the fair market value of the real property immediately prior to the injury and the fair market value thereof immediately after such injury.
2. SAME--Insufficiency of Evidence to Submit to Jury Question of Amount of Damages Sustained.
Before the question of the amount of damages alleged to have been sustained by the injury to real estate may be submitted to the jury there must be some evidence tending to show a difference between the fair market value just before and just after the injury, and where plaintiff relies on a showing of the destruction of trees growmg upon the land, and there is no evidence as to the number of trees destroyed, there is no evidence upon which to base the amount of damages.
Appeal from District Court, Okfuskee County; Arthur Cochran, Judge.
Action by Israel Harjo against H. N. Greis as Trustee for Deep Rock Oil Corporation. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals. Reversed and remanded, with directions.
W. F. Semple, H. F. Aby, H. L. Fitzgerald, Jr., and Phillips & Long, for plaintiff in error.
Harry Stephenson and Clem H. Stephenson, for defendant in error.
¶1 This is an appeal from a judgment in favor of defendant in error in an action for damages to real property alleged to have been caused by the pollution of a stream running through the land and casting salt water thereon from an oil or gas well.
¶2 The parties will be referred to as plaintiff and defendant, as in the trial court.
¶3 Plaintiff's amended petition upon which the cause was tried alleged:
¶4 It was stipulated at the trial that H. N. Greis was appointed trustee for the Deep Rock Oil Corporation on June 19, 1934.
¶5 This action was commenced July 17, 1937. Trial was had March 4, 1938. Evidence was restricted to injuries alleged to have occurred after June 19, 1934, upon the theory that Greis, as trustee, would not be answerable for wrongful acts, if any, of the Deep Rock Oil Corporation committed prior to said date.
¶6 Trial was had to a jury, resulting in a verdict and judgment for plaintiff in the sum of $325.
¶7 Defendant contends that there was no evidence whatever upon which to base the instruction given by the trial court on the measure of damages.
¶8 Instruction No. 7 told the jury:
¶9 Again, in No. 11, the court instructed the jury:
"You are instructed that in the event you find for the plaintiff, you will in your verdict assess the amount of his damages, if any, and the measure of his damages, if any you find from the evidence, will be the difference, if any, in the fair and reasonable market value of plaintiff's said lands immediately prior to the injuries thereto and their fair and reasonable market value immediately after said injuries thereto, in no event, however, to exceed the total sum sued for on account thereof, to wit: $2,950."
¶10 There was no evidence whatever placing a value upon ...
To continue reading
Request your trial- Purcell v. Santa Fe Minerals, Inc.
-
City of Okmulgee v. Wall
......Hatmaker, 189 Okla. 317, 116 P. 2d 973; Greis v. Harjo, 185 Okla. 474, 94 P. 2d 539; Mid-Continent Petroleum Corporation v. Fisher, 183 Okla. 638, 84 P. 2d 22); and, in order to establish the ......
-
City of Okmulgee v. Wall
...... property immediately before the injury and its value. immediately thereafter; Gripe v. Hatmaker, 189 Okl. 317, 116 P.2d 973; Greis v. Harjo, 185 Okl. 474, 94. P.2d 539; Mid-Continent Petroleum Corporation v. Fisher, 183 Okl. 638, 84 P.2d 22; and, in order to. establish the ......
- Greis v. Harjo