Guion Jennings v. Philadelphia, Baltimore Washington Railway Company
Decision Date | 31 October 1910 |
Docket Number | No. 10,10 |
Citation | 54 L.Ed. 1031,218 U.S. 255,31 S.Ct. 1 |
Parties | A. GUION JENNINGS, Piff. in Err., v. PHILADELPHIA, BALTIMORE, & WASHINGTON RAILWAY COMPANY |
Court | U.S. Supreme Court |
Messrs. E. Hilton Jackson and Henry E. Davis for plaintiff in error.
Messrs. Frederic D. McKenney, John Spalding Flannery, and William Hitz for defendant in error.
This case turns primarily upon the question of whether the supreme court of the District exceeded its jurisdic- tion in allowing a bill of exceptions after the close of the term at which the judgment sought to be reversed had become final. The judgment was rendered on December 20, 1907. The term closed December 31st, and a new term began on January 1, 1908. On January 10, 1908 an appeal bond was approved and filed. On January 14th the appellant, having given eight days' notice, under rule 55 of the court, presented a bill of exceptions to the court for allowance. The stipulation in respect of this recites:
Common-law rule 55, under which the appellant claimed the right to have his bill of exceptions filed within thirty-eight days after the rendition of the judgment, was applicable only so long as the judgment term was running, and did not operate to extend the power of the trial judge over the record beyond the term. No order had been made in term time for the filing of such a delayed bill. Not only had the term closed, but an appeal had been allowed and perfected. The trial court had thereby lost control of the cause, and had no authority to add to or take from the record.
In Michigan Ins. Co. v. Eldred, 143 U. S. 293, 298, 36 L. ed. 162, 163, 12 Sup. Ct. Rep. 450, 452, this court said:
See also Morse v. Anderson, 150 U. S. 156, 37...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Moore v. State
... ... 213, per Mr. Justice WASHINGTON; Sinking ... Fund Cases (1878), 99 U.S. 700, per ... of Quarter Sessions of Philadelphia County in ... Commonwealth v. Street, District ... Chair Company at Grand Rapids, Mich., which was a deliberate ... ...
-
Freeman v. United States
... ... 443, 32 L.Ed. 872 (1888); ... Credit Company v. Arkansas Central Ry. Co., 128 U.S ... 258, ... 230, 37 L.Ed. 1195 (1893). And in Jennings v ... Philadelphia, Baltimore & Washington R.R ... ...
-
City of Harper, Kan. v. Daniels
... ... Russell, 9 C.C.A. 108, 60 F. 501; ... Jennings v. Phil., Balt. & Wash. Ry. Co., 218 U.S ... ...
-
Sims v. Douglass
...149 U.S. 262, 13 S.Ct. 840, 37 L.Ed. 726; Morse v. Anderson, 150 U.S. 156, 14 S.Ct. 43, 37 L.Ed. 1037; Jennings v. Philadelphia, B. & W. R. Co., 218 U.S. 255, 31 S.Ct. 1, 54 L.Ed. 1031; O'Connell v. U. S., 253 U.S. 142, 40 S.Ct. 444, 64 L.Ed. 827; Exporters of Mfrs.' Products v. Butterworth......