Hoffman v. Kroger Co.
| Decision Date | 15 November 1960 |
| Docket Number | No. 30553,30553 |
| Parties | Frances HOFFMAN (Plaintiff), Respondent, v. THE KROGER COMPANY, a Corporation (Defendant), Appellant. |
| Court | Missouri Court of Appeals |
Vernon Riehl, St. Louis, for appellant.
Willson, Cunningham, McClellan & Gunn, J. H. Cunningham, Jr., Richard D. Gunn, St. Louis, for respondent.
This is an action for damages arising out of personal injuries sustained by the plaintiff when she fell on the parking lot of the Kroger Company store in DeSoto, Missouri. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of $7,500. In due time after the entry of the judgment upon the verdict, the defendant filed its motion for a new trial and a motion for judgment in accordance with its motion for a directed verdict previously made. Both motions were overruled, and the defendant has appealed from the judgment.
The parking lot where the occurrence took place was a blacktop paved area that rose with a very gradual slope toward a concrete sidewalk. Where it abutted the sidewalk there was a curb about three inches in height. The opposite side of the sidewalk abutted a wall of the store building and paralleled it up to an entrance and exit. The entrance and exit were recessed and the walk widened to continue to the depth of the recess and at the same level to the doors. In front of the exit and entrance the paving of the parking lot rose to a level with the edge of the sidewalk, so that wheeled shopping baskets could be pushed onto the parking lot without going over an abrupt change of level at the edge of the walk. The roof of the building was drained by a pipe that ran down the side of the wall paralleled by the sidewalk and under the sidewalk. This drain came out into the parking area immediately adjoining that portion of the area which was level with the sidewalk.
In order to permit drainage and accommodate the pipe, there was a depression to a depth of six inches in the surface of the parking lot at the sidewalk where the pipe came through. This depression was rounded and was about two and a half feet in width, with its sides curving up to the level of the lot on either side of it. It extended lengthwise for about the length of an automobile, getting more shallow and narrow until it ended level with the surface of the lot where it drained. The vertical surface of the curb next to the parking area was painted yellow, and this was also true of the curb where the drain came through. Parking spaces were designated by yellow lines painted on the blacktop parking area. There was evidence that there was also a yellow line about two inches wide painted on top of the curb, and there was testimony to the contrary by the plaintiff. The photographs in evidence indicate that the indentation in the lot through which the pipe drains was the same color as the concrete sidewalk.
Mrs. Hoffman, the plaintiff, was a housewife 39 years of age. She lived with her husband and son at Imperial, Missouri. Her mother lived in DeSoto. On September 18, 1958, Mrs. Hoffman took her four-year old son and drove to DeSoto to visit her mother. Her mother's residence was a short distance from the Kroger Store, and the plaintiff desired to help her mother do her shopping. She had never been to the Kroger Store before. She drove there with her son in the rear seat of her car and her mother to her right in the front seat. She drove into the parking lot and up to the edge of the sidewalk leading to the entrance. There she parked, with the right side of her car next to the drain mentioned and the front wheels by the curb of the sidewalk, with the car facing the store wall. She did not see the drain, which was to the right of the car. She got out on the left, or driver's side, and her mother got out on the right side with the plaintiff's son. The plaintiff went to the front of her automobile, stepped up the curb, and walked along the sidewalk to the entrance. She waited in the vestibule for her mother and son, who walked up the parking area directly in front of the area where its surface is flush with that of the sidewalk. The three then entered the store and were in there, according to the plaintiff, for 'a long time'. At the checkout counter Mrs. Hoffman paid for the groceries and she carried from the store a large paper sack of canned goods, while her mother carried a small sack of eggs. Mrs. Hoffman was carrying the large sack in front of her, but not in front of her face. Her son was at her side, and he walked down the slope. Mrs. Hoffman did not see the drain immediately adjoining the level area and stepped off of the walk into it, twisting her ankle under her and landing on her right knee. She said that she was looking where she was going, but that the drain was not noticeable until 'you were right on top of it'.
A woman clerk and the store manager helped her to her car and directed her to a doctor. Mrs. Hoffman stated without objection that sometime later she returned to the store and the manager told her that the drain was 'very hazardous and that he had reported it * * *'. This was denied by the manager in testifying for the defendant.
The defendant maintains that the plaintiff was guilty of negligence as a matter of law in that she either did not look to see where she was going or, having looked, failed to see an open and obvious condition. It is contended that the court erred in not...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Haire v. Stagner
...Dye and Meyer cases, supra, see Schmoll v. National Shirt Shops of Missouri, 354 Mo. 1164, 193 S.W.2d 605, 607, and Hoffman v. Kroger Co., Mo.App., 340 S.W.2d 152 155(5).8 Contrast Behnke v. City of Moberly, Mo.App., 243 S.W.2d 549 (the only case cited in instant plaintiff's brief on the du......
-
Crain v. Webster Elec. Co-op.
...v. Brozovich, 429 S.W.2d 330, 333(4) (Mo.App.1968); Cupp v. Montgomery, 408 S.W.2d 353, 360(7) (Mo.App.1966); Hoffman v. The Kroger Company, 340 S.W.2d 152, 155(6) (Mo.App.1960); Daggs v. Patsos, 260 S.W.2d 794, 798(5) (Mo.App.1953); Schwartz v. S. S. Kresge Co., 238 Mo.App. 1165, 185 S.W.2......
-
Grissom v. Handley
...Stafford v. Fred Wolferman, Inc., Mo., 307 S.W.2d 468, 478(14); Tucker v. Taksel, Mo.App., 345 S.W.2d 385, 389(6); Hoffman v. Kroger Company, Mo.App., 340 S.W.2d 152, 155(7); Beckwith v. Standard Oil Co., Mo., 281 S.W.2d 852, ...
-
Moss v. National Super Markets, Inc.
...Bell Tel. Co., 573 S.W.2d 386 (Mo.App.1978) (duty to maintain private sidewalk in reasonably safe condition); Hoffman v. Kroger Co., 340 S.W.2d 152 (Mo.App.1960).3 Carraway v. National Super Markets, Inc., 741 S.W.2d 895 (Mo.App.1987); Grant v. National Super Markets, Inc., 611 S.W.2d 357 (......