Johnson v. Bentley, 84-738
| Decision Date | 07 September 1984 |
| Docket Number | No. 84-738,84-738 |
| Citation | 457 So.2d 507 |
| Parties | 10 Media L. Rep. 2526 Paul JOHNSON, Petitioner, v. The Honorable E. Randolph BENTLEY, Circuit Judge in the Tenth Judicial Circuit, in and for Polk County, State of Florida, and Bonnie Anita Petty and James Petty, her husband, Respondents. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
George K. Rahdert of Rahdert, Anderson & Richardson, St. Petersburg, for petitioner.
Jim Smith, Atty. Gen., and James W. Sloan, Asst. Atty. Gen., Tallahassee, for respondent E. Randolph Bentley.
R. Kent Lilly of Frost, Purcell and Lilly, Bartow, for respondents Bonnie Petty and James Petty.
In a case of first impression in Florida, a newspaper photographer asks this court to quash a discovery order in a civil action requiring him, a nonparty, to produce unpublished photographs of an automobile accident. We grant his petition for certiorari and quash the order.
The petitioner describes himself as a professional photojournalist employed by the Lakeland Ledger, a newspaper of daily circulation in Polk County, Florida. The respondents Petty are the plaintiffs in this action to recover damages for injuries received in an automobile accident. The petitioner took pictures of that accident, some of which were published in the Ledger and some of which were not.
The respondents served a subpoena on the petitioner and his employer to require them to produce "copies of any and all photographs and proof sheets regarding the subject accident." The petitioner filed a motion to quash the subpoena based on his First Amendment rights under the United States Constitution and Article I, sections 4 and 12, of the Florida Constitution, specifically relying on this court's decision in Tribune Co. v. Green, 440 So.2d 484 (Fla. 2d DCA 1983). The trial judge denied the petitioner's motion to quash, stating his view that Tribune Co. v. Green does not apply to this case. We hold that the trial judge erred in so ruling.
In Tribune Co. v. Green this court adopted a three-part test announced in Gadsden County Times, Inc. v. Horne, 426 So.2d 1234 (Fla. 1st DCA 1983), and held that it applies to the compelled disclosure of nonconfidential as well as confidential matters involved in news-gathering. In Gadsden County, the First District Court of Appeal came to the conclusion that a qualified privilege based on the First Amendment protects against the compelled disclosure of a reporter's confidential sources. The court went on to say that this qualified privilege must give way "where the competing constitutional issues of the plaintiff in pursuing his claim and in seeking a fair administration of justice evidence a compelling need for such disclosure." Id. at 1240. Accordingly, the court adopted a three-part test: (1) Is the information relevant, (2) can the information be obtained by alternative means, and (3) is there a compelling interest in the information?
The respondents vigorously argue that the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Marketos v. American Employers Ins. Co., Docket No. 112388
...Inc., supra at 954, quoting with approval People v. Dupree, 88 Misc.2d 791, 794, 388 N.Y.S.2d 1000, 1002 (1976). Cf. Johnson v. Bentley, 457 So.2d 507 (Fla.App.1984), and Tribune Co. v. Green, 440 So.2d 484 (Fla.App.1983), rev. den. 447 So.2d 886 In Bartlett v. Superior Court, 150 Ariz. 178......
-
Miami Herald Pub. Co. v. Morejon
...test adopted by several of Florida's district courts. 3 See CBS, Inc. v. Cobb, 536 So.2d 1067 (Fla. 2d DCA 1988); Johnson v. Bentley, 457 So.2d 507 (Fla. 2d DCA 1984); Tribune Co. v. Green, 440 So.2d 484 (Fla. 2d DCA 1983), review denied, 447 So.2d 886 (Fla.1984); Gadsden County Times, Inc.......
-
CBS, Inc. v. Cobb
...taken by a newspaper photographer stand on the same footing as any other information acquired by a news-gatherer." Johnson v. Bentley, 457 So.2d 507, 509 (Fla. 2d DCA 1984). "The autonomy of the press would be jeopardized if resort to its resource materials, by litigants seeking to utilize ......
-
Patterson v. State
... ... Lancaster, 457 So.2d at 507 (citing State v. Counce, 392 So.2d 1029 (Fla. 4th DCA 1981) ; Johnson v. State, 249 So.2d 470 (Fla. 3d DCA 1971) ); see also Lancaster, 457 So.2d at 507 (It would be ... ...