Kansas City S. Ry. Co. v. Embrey
Decision Date | 21 October 1905 |
Citation | 90 S.W. 15 |
Parties | KANSAS CITY S. RY. CO. v. EMBREY. |
Court | Arkansas Supreme Court |
Appeal from Circuit Court, Miller County; Joel D. Conway, Judge.
Action by Eva Embrey against the Kansas City Southern Railway Company. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendant appeals. Affirmed.
This is an action brought by appellee in the Miller circuit court against appellant, the Kansas City Southern Railway Company, to recover damages to a piano and sewing machine shipped by plaintiff over defendant's road. The complaint alleges in substance that on September 13, 1901, plaintiff shipped a piano and sewing machine from South McAlester, Ind. T., to Texarkana, Ark., bill of lading being issued for it at South McAlester, Ind. T., to be delivered at Texarkana, Ark., in good condition and with the proper care, but at Howe Junction, a station on said defendant's railway, said piano and sewing machine were put on the railway platform, and by the willful negligence of the defendant, its agents and employés, were exposed to a severe rain for a period of several hours without protection of any kind, and the piano was thereby damaged in the sum of $250, and said sewing machine was damaged in the sum of $20. Defendant in its answer denies each and every allegation of the complaint. The cause was tried before a jury, and a verdict returned in favor of the plaintiff, fixing damages at $185 on the piano and $15 on the sewing machine. The articles in question were shipped from South McAlester, Ind. T., to Texarkana, Ark., over the Choctaw, Oklahoma & Gulf Railroad from the initial point of shipment to Howe Junction, at which point the two roads cross, thence to Texarkana over appellant's road, and the bill of lading was issued by the agent of the first-named railroad company at South McAlester. The bill of lading contains a stipulation limiting the liability of the connecting carriers to the damages accruing on their respective lines. The two companies maintained a joint station at Howe Junction, with joint agents in charge thereof. Mrs. C. D. Payne, the mother of the plaintiff, testified that the piano and sewing machine were shipped from South McAlester to Texarkana by her on the 12th of September, 1901, and that she obtained the bill of lading; the piano and sewing machine being the property of her daughter, Mrs. Embrey, who was ill at the time. Continuing, this witness said: Witness further testified that the piano and machine had been wet and badly damaged, that the piano cost $525, and that the machine cost $65. C. D. Payne testified that he examined the piano and sewing machine after they arrived at Texarkana and found that they were in a bad condition, having been wet. The machine was rusted from dampness and the parts of the piano were all damp or wet. The defendant, to maintain the issues upon its part, introduced the deposition of W. C. Charles, who testified in substance: That he was the joint agent at Howe for both roads, that he was there in their employ in September and October, 1901, and that he remembered very distinctly the piano. It was received from the West some time during the night, over the Choctaw, Oklahoma & Gulf Railroad, and was unloaded by the trainmen on the platform and remained some time after it was unloaded. On his arrival in the morning at the office, he saw the piano setting on the platform, and was told by the night operator that it was unloaded from an east-bound train. ...
To continue reading
Request your trial