Kennoy v. Graves
Citation | 300 S.W.2d 568 |
Parties | J. S. KENNOY, d/b/a Kennoy & Company, Appellant, v. Charles M. GRAVES, Appellee. |
Decision Date | 29 March 1957 |
Court | United States State Supreme Court (Kentucky) |
Welden Shouse, Fred J. Coplin, Lexington, for appellant.
McDonald, Alford & Roszell, Lexington, for appellee.
CLAY, Commissioner.
This suit was instituted by appellee Graves to recover approximately $900 for services rendered as a consulting engineer to appellant. Appellant denied liability and counterclaimed for $7,500. On motion for summary judgment the trial court allowed appellee's claim and dismissed appellant's counterclaim.
Appellant's denial of liability and his counterclaim for damages is based on a single admitted fact: Appellant was not licensed as required by KRS 322.020.
It has long been recognized in Kentucky, as elsewhere, that when a statute requires a license to practice a particular profession (the statute being enacted for the protection of the public), a contract for those professional services entered into with one not licensed is void and unenforceable. Board of Education of Ferguson Independent Graded School District v. Elliott, 276 Ky. 790, 125 S.W.2d 733. Appellee concedes the existence of this general rule, but claims there is an important exception when the contract is between a licensed and an unlicensed member of the same profession or trade. Whether or not this exception should be recognized is a new question in Kentucky.
A leading case from another jurisdiction is Dow v. United States, 10 Cir., 154 F.2d 707. The plaintiff was an unlicensed subcontractor on a construction project. The controlling Utah statute was similar to ours with respect to requiring a contractor's license. The court recognized the general rule that a contract for services cannot be enforced by an unlicensed person. The court stated, however, at page 710:
This exception seems to have been recognized in Oklahoma, Washington, New York, Colorado, and California. In addition to the cases cited in the quotation, see Benham v. Heyde, 122 Colo. 233, 221 P.2d 1078, and Matchett v. Gould, 131 Cal.App.2d 821, 281 P.2d 524. Appellant contends that there were distinguishing facts in those cases (some of them involved contracts between attorneys) and also contends that no sound reasons are shown for this exception to the general rule. It is our opinion that the principle recognized in those cases is applicable under the facts here presented and that sound reasons justify...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
In the Matter of Application for Water Rights of Park County Sportsmen's Ranch, LLP, Case No. 01SA412 (CO 2/14/2005)
...same business field who have contracted with knowledge of each other's respective professional qualifications.'")(quoting Kennoy v. Graves, 300 S.W.2d 568 (Ky. 1957)); see also Pac. Chromalux Div., Emerson Elec. Co. v. Irey, 787 P.2d 1319, 1326-27 (Utah App. 1990)(in awarding compensation t......
-
Food Management, Inc. v. Blue Ribbon Beef Pack, Inc.
...licensed and unlicensed members of the same profession, as in Costello v. Schmidlin, 3 Cir., 1968, 404 F.2d 87, and Kennoy v. Graves, 1957, Ky.App., 300 S.W.2d 568. Nor is this a situation where the architect or engineer approving the work or drawings was in the defendant's employ, as in Di......
-
City of Aurora v. Colorado State Engineer
...same business field who have contracted with knowledge of each other's respective professional qualifications.' ")(quoting Kennoy v. Graves, 300 S.W.2d 568 (Ky.1957)); see also Pac. Chromalux Div., Emerson Elec. Co. v. Irey, 787 P.2d 1319, 1326-27 (Utah App.1990) (in awarding compensation t......
-
In the Matter of Application for Water Rights of Park County Sportsmen's Ranch, Case No. 01SA412 (CO 1/18/2005)
...same business field who have contracted with knowledge of each other's respective professional qualifications.'") (quoting Kennoy v. Graves, 300 S.W.2d 568 (Ky. 1957)); see also Pac. Chromalux Div., Emerson Elec. Co. v. Irey, 787 P.2d 1319, 1326-27 (Utah App. 1990)(in awarding compensation ......