Long v. Dismer

• Court: Missouri Supreme Court
• Writing for the Court: SHERWOOD
• Citation: Long v. Dismer, 71 Mo. 452 (Mo. 1880)
• Decision Date: 30 April 1880
• Parties: LONG v. DISMER AND MCENTEE, Appellants.

71 Mo. 452

LONG

v.DISMER AND MCENTEE, Appellants.

Supreme Court of Missouri.

April Term, 1880.

Appeal from Phelps Circuit Court.--HON. V. B. HILL, Judge.

REVERSED.

The note sued on was for $132.87.

L. F. Parker for appellants.

C. C. Bland for respondent.

SHERWOOD, C. J.

McEntee was the payee and indorser of a negotiable promissory note. No demand of payment had been made of the makers. Several days after the note fell due, Richardson, the then holder, states that he called on the indorser and told him that the Dismer note had not been paid, and asked him how about it, when McEntee told him “to go and collect the note of the makers, that the note was good;” that, thereupon, Richardson informed him that payment had not been demanded of the makers, and he said “that made no difference, that did not release him.” Richardson further states that he told McEntee that Baker had said that he, McEntee, was released, and asked him if he would take advantage of it, if it hould turn out that he was released by failure to make demand of Dismer, when McEntee said: “I refuse to answer that question.” McEntee's testimony is in most respects like that of Richardson, but he says that at the time of the interview referred to, he did not know that he was released, and did not promise to pay the note. Long, the plaintiff, testified that McEntee offered to give him $100 for the note, payable in three months. This McEntee denied, but stated he had asked Long, by way of compromise, if he would take $75 for the note. This was all the evidence. The instructions for the plaintiff are not preserved, but defendant, McEntee, was refused an instruction in the nature of a demurrer to the evidence. This instruction was improperly refused.

The authorities agree that if the proper steps are not taken to fix the indorser, and...