Montalvo v. University of Miami, 97-491
| Decision Date | 11 February 1998 |
| Docket Number | No. 97-491,97-491 |
| Parties | 124 Ed. Law Rep. 474, 23 Fla. L. Weekly D456 Richard MONTALVO, Appellant, v. UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI, a Florida not-for-profit corporation, Vendulka Kubalkova, individually, Bruce Bagley, individually, and Ambler H. Moss, Jr., individually, Appellees. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
David T. Azrin and Dionne A. Wilson, Miami, for appellant.
Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson and Laura Thomas Rivero, Miami, for appellees.
Before NESBITT, GERSTEN and FLETCHER, JJ.
Richard Montalvo, a doctoral candidate in the Graduate School of International Studies at the University of Miami, failed by a unanimous vote, a comprehensive oral examination administered by an examining committee. Following the committee's decision, Montalvo was immediately notified of his failure and given cogent reasons for the committee's determination. He was formally advised he could retake the examination after the lapse of one year. Any reconstituted examining committee would have consisted of five professors, two of whom Montalvo would have been privileged to select, even from other institutions not connected with the university. Instead of exhausting this procedure, Montalvo filed an action seeking money damages. The trial court entered summary judgment in favor of the appellees.
Montalvo attempts to justify his failure to exhaust administrative remedies by arguing that his failure was due to bias and animosity directed toward him. He notes that earlier in his instruction there had been some confusion and disagreement within the faculty over the composition of his dissertation committee. However, Montalvo points to no direct evidence demonstrating any breach of fiduciary duty toward him. In fact, he admitted in deposition that he had no knowledge or basis to assert he failed the exam because of what he alleged to be an "internal war" within the Graduate School of International Studies. Consequently, there is nothing to support Montalvo's claims other than his subjective opinion that he did not deserve the failing grade he was given. See Benson v. Trustees of Columbia University, 215 A.D.2d 255, 626 N.Y.S.2d 495 (1995) ()...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
SIRPAL v. University of Miami
...1998) (holding fraternity must exhaust its administrative remedies as provided in the University's Handbook); Montalvo v. Univ. of Miami, 705 So.2d 1042, 1043 (Fla. 3d DCA 1998) (affirming summary judgment against plaintiff for failure to exhaust administrative remedies because plaintiff di......
-
Sharick v. Southeastern University of Health Sciences, Inc.
...but it must be shown that he acted in the matter complained of wantonly, willfully or maliciously."); Montalvo v. University of Miami, 705 So.2d 1042, 1043 (Fla. 3d DCA 1998); Militana, 236 So.2d at In this case, the jury found that the university's decision to dismiss Sharick was arbitrary......
-
Stroop v. University of Miami
...(Fla.2000); Gamma Phi Chapter of Sigma Chi Fraternity v. University of Miami, 718 So.2d 910 (Fla. 3d DCA 1998); Montalvo v. University of Miami, 705 So.2d 1042 (Fla. 3d DCA 1998); Pushkin v. Lombard, 279 So.2d 79 (Fla. 3d DCA 1973), cert. denied, 284 So.2d 396 ...
-
SIERROS v. NOVA SOUTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY, INC., 4D04-305.
...record reflects that appellant failed to exhaust his administrative remedies in challenging his dismissal. See Montalvo v. Univ.of Miami, 705 So.2d 1042, 1043 (Fla. 3rd DCA 1988) (holding that action for money damages by doctoral candidate who failed his oral examination was barred by his f......