National Bank of South Carolina v. Ship Ahoy Marina, LLC

• Decision Date: 29 March 2011
• Docket Number: 2011-UP-129
• Parties: The National Bank of South Carolina Respondent, v. Ship Ahoy Marina, LLC; Bhupedra Patel; Pradipkumar Patel; Jeffrey T. Shoup; David T. Hix; Baldwin Construction Co.; Carter Architecture, Inc.; Ocean Front Real Estate Company; Victor Cardinali; Ellen Cardinali; Roger Carlsen; Michael Nortung; Gulfstream Holdings, LLC; Michael McCarthy; Gary F. Ownbey; Brian A. Murdoch; Joseph Foley; Patricia Foley; Kurt Peins; Robert Peins; Derek Peins; Danny Quinn; Patricia Quinn; Barbara Kellner; George Van Woeart; Stanley Forman; Joyce Forman; Kenneth Tallmadge; Michael Clark; Harold Braswell; Steve Mendenhall; Clement Samaritano; Dawn Samaritano; Jean Keamy; Jon Hill; Equity Trust FBO Martha S. Williams, IRA; Gerald Pirozek; Richard Iacovelli; Doug Steinbrunner; Martin McGarvey; Nancy McGarvey; Patti Krukoff; Benjamin Bunce; Beverly Mandell; Eric Lapin; Rita Shane; and Nancy Mackillop, Defendants, of whom Gary F. Ownbey; Brian A. Murdoch; Joseph Foley; Patricia Foley; Kurt Peins; Robert Peins; Derek Peins; Danny Quinn; Patricia Quinn; Barbara Kellner; George Van Woeart; Stanley Forman; Joyce Forman; Kenneth Tallmadge; Michael Clark; Harold Braswell; Steve Mendenhall; Clement Samaritano; Dawn Samaritano; Jean Keamy; Jon Hill; Equity Trust FBO Martha S. Williams, IRA; Gerald Pirozek; Richard Iacovelli; Doug Steinbrunner; Martin McGarvey; Nancy McGarvey; Patti Krukoff; Benjamin Bunce; Beverly Mandell; Eric Lapin; Rita Shane; and Nancy Mackillop are Appellants.
• Court: South Carolina Court of Appeals

The National Bank of South Carolina Respondent,
v.
Ship Ahoy Marina, LLC; Bhupedra Patel; Pradipkumar Patel; Jeffrey T. Shoup; David T. Hix; Baldwin Construction Co.; Carter Architecture, Inc.; Ocean Front Real Estate Company; Victor Cardinali; Ellen Cardinali; Roger Carlsen; Michael Nortung; Gulfstream Holdings, LLC; Michael McCarthy; Gary F. Ownbey; Brian A. Murdoch; Joseph Foley; Patricia Foley; Kurt Peins; Robert Peins; Derek Peins; Danny Quinn; Patricia Quinn; Barbara Kellner; George Van Woeart; Stanley Forman; Joyce Forman; Kenneth Tallmadge; Michael Clark; Harold Braswell; Steve Mendenhall; Clement Samaritano; Dawn Samaritano; Jean Keamy; Jon Hill; Equity Trust FBO Martha S. Williams, IRA; Gerald Pirozek; Richard Iacovelli; Doug Steinbrunner; Martin McGarvey; Nancy McGarvey; Patti Krukoff; Benjamin Bunce; Beverly Mandell; Eric Lapin; Rita Shane; and Nancy Mackillop, Defendants,

of whom Gary F. Ownbey; Brian A. Murdoch; Joseph Foley; Patricia Foley; Kurt Peins; Robert Peins; Derek Peins; Danny Quinn; Patricia Quinn; Barbara Kellner; George Van Woeart; Stanley Forman; Joyce Forman; Kenneth Tallmadge; Michael Clark; Harold Braswell; Steve Mendenhall; Clement Samaritano; Dawn Samaritano; Jean Keamy; Jon Hill; Equity Trust FBO Martha S. Williams, IRA; Gerald Pirozek; Richard Iacovelli; Doug Steinbrunner; Martin McGarvey; Nancy McGarvey; Patti Krukoff; Benjamin Bunce; Beverly Mandell; Eric Lapin; Rita Shane; and Nancy Mackillop are Appellants.

No. 2011-UP-129

Court of Appeals of South Carolina

March 29, 2011

UNPUBLISHED OPINION

Submitted March 1, 2011

Appeal From Horry County Ralph Stroman, Special Referee

Randall K. Mullins and Jarrod E. Ownbey, both of N. Myrtle Beach, for Appellants.

Tara E. Nauful, Sarah P. Spruill, and Lindsey C. Livingston, all of Columbia, for Respondent.

PER CURIAM.

This appeal arises out of two orders granting summary judgment in favor of Respondent The National Bank of South Carolina (NBSC), one order dismissing Appellants' counterclaims, and one order denying a motion to compel discovery. We affirm in part, reverse in part, and remand ^[1] pursuant to Rule 220(b), SCACR, and the following authorities:

1. As to the order granting summary judgment to NBSC based on lien priority, we affirm the finding that NBSC is entitled to lien priority as to all of the Appellants' claims for an equitable lien except for the claim made by Appellant Eric Lapin. See S.C. Code Ann. § 30-7-10 (2007) ("[A]ll...