Ne. Ohio Reg'l Sewer Dist. v. Bath Twp.
| Decision Date | 26 September 2013 |
| Docket Number | Nos. 98728,98729.,s. 98728 |
| Parties | NORTHEAST OHIO REGIONAL SEWER DISTRICT, Plaintiff–Appellee Cross–Appellant v. BATH TOWNSHIP, Ohio, et al., Defendants–Appellants Cross–Appellees. |
| Court | Ohio Court of Appeals |
John H. Gibbon, City of Cleveland Heights Director of Law, Cleveland Heights, OH, Christopher L. Gibbon, Heather R. Baldwin Vlasuk, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellants/cross-appellees, city of Beachwood, city of Bedford Heights, city of Cleveland Heights, village of Glenwillow, city of Independence, city of Lyndhurst, city of North Royalton, village of Oakwood, city of Olmsted Falls, and city of Strongsville.
David J. Matty, City of Brecksville Director of Law, Shana A. Samson, Justin Whelan, Matty, Henrikson & Greve, Cleveland, OH, for appellants/cross-appellee, city of Brecksville.
Paul T. Murphy, City of Lyndhurst Director of Law, Paul T. Murphy Co., L.P.A., Mayfield Heights, OH, for appellants/cross-appellee, city of Lyndhurst.
Mark I. Wallach, Thacker Martinsek L.P.A., James F. Lang, Molly A. Drake, Matthew J. Kucharson, Calfee, Halter & Griswold L.L.P., Marlene Sundheimer, Director of Law, N.E.O.R.S.D., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, N.E.O.R.S.D.
Sherri Bevan Walsh, Summit County Prosecutor, Mary Ann Kovach, Michael D. Todd, Marvin D. Evans, Summit County Assistant Prosecuting Attorneys, Akron, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, Bath Township, Ohio, et al.
Stephen M. O'Bryan, Taft, Stettinius & Hollister L.L.P., Rebecca K. Schaltenbrand, Ice Miller L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, city of Beachwood, et al.
Kenneth A. Schuman, City of Bedford Director of Law, Garfield Heights, OH, Charles A. Bakula, Solon, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Bedford.
Ross S. Cirincione, Law Director, City of Bedford Heights, Garfield Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Bedford Heights.
Gregory M. Sponseller, Berea, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Berea.
Constance A. Hesske, Akron, OH, Charles T. Riehl, Walter & Haverfield, L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Boston Heights.
David J. Matty, City of Brecksville Director of Law, Justin Whelan, Erin Hooper, Shana A. Samson, Matty, Henrikson & Greve, Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, city of Brecksville, et al.
Vince Ruffa, City of Broadview Heights Director of Law, Ann C. Oakar, Oakar & Ruffa, Broadview Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Broadview Heights.
Neal M. Jamison, City of Brook Park Director of Law, Largent, Berry, Preston & Jamison Co., Berea, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Brook Park.
Scott Claussen, Director of Law, City of Brooklyn, Brooklyn, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Brooklyn.
Jerome E. Dowling, Brooklyn Heights Director of Law, Rocky River, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Brooklyn Heights.
Barbara A. Langhenry, Director of Law, Catherine Ma, Shirley A. Tomasello, Assistant Directors of Law, Julianne Kurdila, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Cleveland.
William R. Hanna, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Cleveland Heights.
Dennis Will, Lorain County Prosecutor, Gerald A. Innes, Assistant County Prosecutor, Elyria, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Columbia Township.
Jonathan D. Greenberg, Cuyahoga Heights Director of Law, Aimee W. Lane, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, Village of Cuyahoga Heights, et al.
Ronald K. Riley, Director of Law, City of East Cleveland, East Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of East Cleveland.
L. Christopher Frey, Director of Law, City of Euclid, Euclid, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Euclid.
Tim Riley, City of Garfield Heights Director of Law, Cleveland, OH, Kevin P. Weiler, Assistant Law Director, City of Garfield Heights, Brecksville, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Garfield Heights.
Stephen M. Klonowski, Village of Glenwillow Director of Law, Reddy, Grau & Meek, Garfield Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Glenwillow.
Timothy G. Paluf, Highland Heights Director of Law, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Highland Heights.
Thomas P. O'Donnell, Village of Highland Hills Law Director, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Highland Hills.
R. Todd Hunt, City of Hudson City Solicitor, Walter & Haverfield, Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, city of Hudson, et al.
Gregory J. O'Brien, City of Independence Director of Law, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Independence.
Kevin M. Butler, Director of Law, City of Lakewood, Lakewood, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Lakewood.
George T. Simon, Grendell & Simon Co., L.P.A., Broadview Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Linndale.
Paul T. Murphy, City of Lyndhurst Director of Law, Paul T. Murphy Co., L.P.A., Mayfield Heights, OH, David M. Maistros, Chagrin Falls, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Lyndhurst.
Joseph W. Diemert, Jr., City of Macedonia Law Director, Mark V. Guidetti, Thomas M. Hanculak, Joseph W. Diemert, Jr. & Assoc., Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, city of Macedonia, et al.
John J. Montello, City of Maple Heights Law Director, Blair N. Melling, Melling, Melling & Bell, Bedford, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, city of Maple Heights, et al.
L. Bryan Carr, The Carr Law Firm, Mayfield Hts., OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Mayfield Heights.
Joseph W. Diemert, Jr., Mayfield Village Director of Law, Diane A. Calta, Assistant Law Director, Joseph W. Diemert, Jr. & Assoc., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Mayfield Village.
Peter H. Hull, Law Director, Middleburg Hts., OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Middleburg Heights.
Margaret A. Cannon, Village of Moreland Hills Director of Law, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Rebecca K. Schaltenbrand, Ice Miller L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, village of Moreland Hills, et al.
Luke F. McConville, Village of Newburgh Heights Director of Law, Waldheger–Coyne, Westlake, OH, appellee/cross-appellant, village of Newburgh Heights.
Leonard A. Spremulli, Village of North Randall Director of Law, Pepper Pike, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of North Randall.
Thomas A. Kelly, City of North Royalton Law Director, Donna M. Vozar, Assistant Law Director, City of North Royalton, North Royalton, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of North Royalton.
Bradric T. Bryan, Village of Northfield Law Director, Goodwin, Bryan & Schill, Fairview Park, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Northfield.
Stephen M. Klonowski, Village of Oakwood Law Director, Reddy, Grau & Meek, Garfield Heights, OH, for appellee/cross–appellant, village of Oakwood.
Olmsted Township, c/o Jim Carr, Trustee, Olmsted Township, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Olmsted Township.
Stephen L. Byron, Orange Village Director of Law, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Willoughby, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Orange Village.
Timothy G. Dobeck, Director of Law, City of Parma, Parma, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Parma.
Marcia E. Hurt, C. Anthony Stavole, Stavole & Miller, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Parma Heights.
Stephen L. Byron, Law Director, City of Pepper Pike, Pepper Pike, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Pepper Pike.
William R. Hanna, Village of Richfield Director of Law, Charles T. Riehl, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellees/cross-appellants, village of Richfield, et al.
R. Todd Hunt, City of Richmond Heights Director of Law, Walter & Haverfield L.L.P., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Richmond Heights.
Jeffrey J. Snell, Sagamore Hills Township Director of Law, Sagamore Hills, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Sagamore Hills Township.
Richard Pignatiello, Law Director, City of Seven Hills, Seven Hills, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Seven Hills.
William M. Ondrey Gruber, City of Shaker Heights Director of Law, Margaret Anne Cannon, City of Shaker Heights, Shaker Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Shaker Heights.
David J. Matty, Erin Hooper, Shana A. Samson, Matty, Henrikson & Greve, Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Solon.
Michael P. Lograsso, Law Director, City of South Euclid, South Euclid, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of South Euclid.
Kenneth Kraus, Law Director, City of Strongsville, Strongsville, OH, Daniel J. Kolick, Kolick & Kondzer, Westlake, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Strongsville.
David M. Maistros, Law Director, City of Twinsburg, Twinsburg, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Twinsburg.
Anthony Coyne, Director of Law, Kenneth J. Fisher, University Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of University Heights.
David A. Lambros, Village of Valley View Prosecutor, Largent, Berry, Preston & Jamison Co., Berea, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Valley View.
Blair N. Melling, Village of Walton Hills Solicitor, Melling, Melling & Bell, Bedford, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, village of Walton Hills.
Theresa Beasley, Law Director, Sean P. Ruffin, City of Warrensville Heights, Warrensville Heights, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Warrensville Heights.
Thomas G. Lobe, City of Willoughby Hills Law Director, Thomas G. Lobe Co., L.P.A., Cleveland, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, city of Willoughby Hills.
Jordan B. Berns, Sheldon Berns, Timothy J. Duff, Benjamin J. Ockner, Gary F. Werner, Berns, Ockner & Greenberger, Beachwood, OH, for appellee/cross-appellant, Intervening Property Owners.
Brian E. Ambrosia, Adrian D. Thompson, Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, Cleveland, OH, for Intervenor the Cleveland Metropolitan School District Board of Education.
Michael E. Cicero, Matthew T. Fitzsimmons, III, L. James Juliano, Jr., Nicola, Gudbranson & Cooper, Cleveland, OH, for Intervenors Bishop Richard G....
To continue reading
Request your trial