Norwood v. State
| Decision Date | 29 September 1924 |
| Docket Number | 23971 |
| Citation | 101 So. 366,136 Miss. 272 |
| Court | Mississippi Supreme Court |
| Parties | NORWOOD v. STATE. [*] |
CRIMINAL LAW. Conviction on void statute reversed.
When a statute has been declared unconstitutional, a conviction thereunder, though on a plea of guilty, will be reversed on appeal.
APPEAL from circuit court of Simpson county, HON. W. L. CRANFORD Judge.
Guysell Norwood was convicted of wife desertion, and he appeals. Reversed, and appellant discharged.
Judgment reversed, and appellant discharged.
A. W. Dent, for appellant.
I. Appellant was indicted under chapter 212, Laws 1920, for deserting his wife without just cause. The court was without authority to try appellant since the statute under which he was indicted is unconstitutional. State v. Sansome, 97 So. 753.
II. Courts should be liberal in granting trials to the end that all cases may be heard on their merits. Morris v. City of Tupelo, 129 Miss. 887; Judon v. State, 131 Miss. 560.
E. C. Sharp, Assistant Attorney-General, for the State.
In the case of State v. Sansome, 97 So. 753, this court passed upon the chapter under which the appellant was indicted. Under this holding of the court, since the entire chapter is unconstitutional, appellant should not be forced to pay the penalty imposed by the court even though he enter a plea of guilty.
We therefore submit the case without argument.
The appellant was indicted under chapter 212, Laws 1920, for deserting his wife without just cause, and willfully and feloniously failing and refusing to provide for the support and maintenance of her, the said Madie Norwood, who was then and there and now is in necessitous circumstances.
The appellant was arrested in Madison county during the term of court at which he was convicted, and entered a peal of guilty. Thereafter a motion was filed to set aside the plea of guilty and permit him to stand his trial under said charge stating that he had a good defense, and did not desert his wife leaving her in destitute circumstances, and that his wife was not prosecuting the suit, and had not appeared against him; that he had no particular friends who would take any interest in him, and that he was an ignorant negro and did not know the law. The motion was overruled, and the sentence to the penitentiary remained in force, from which this appeal is prosecuted.
Without passing upon the sufficiency of the showing to withdraw the plea of guilty and the facts shown in the record, the judgment must be reversed because chapter 212, Laws 1920, was declared unconstitutional by this court in the case of State v. Sansome...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Rush v. North American Van Lines, Inc.
...391, 83 S.Ct. 822, 9 L.Ed.2d 837 (1963); Stubbs v. Capital Paint & Glass Co., 160 Miss. 832, 135 So. 495 (1931); and Norwood v. State, 136 Miss. 272, 101 So. 366 (1924). In Underwood v. Foremost Financial Services Corp., 563 So.2d 1387 (Miss.1990), this Court held not only that § 11-37-101 ......
-
Bank of Commerce & Trust Co. v. Commissioners of Tallhatchie Drainage Dist. No. 1
...United States; Section 33, Constitution of the State of Miss.; Pearl River County v. Lacy Lumber Co., 86 So. 755, 124 Miss. 85; Norwood v. State, 136 Miss. 272; State v. Grenada County, 105 So. 541; State Wheatley, 113 Miss. 555; Toombs v. Sharkey, 140 Miss. 676. Section 1, chapter 159, Mis......
-
Senter v. City of Tupelo
... ... Judgment affirmed ... James ... A. Finley, for appellants ... Appellants ... claim exemption from all state, county and municipal taxes ... under section 6883 of Hemingway's Code (Sec. 4252, Code ... of 1906). Appellee bases its claim of right to tax this ... ...