Old Colony Trust Co. v. Rhodes
Decision Date | 04 February 1938 |
Citation | 12 N.E.2d 809,299 Mass. 390 |
Parties | OLD COLONY TRUST CO. v. RHODES. |
Court | United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
Proceeding by the Old Colony Trust Company, as trustee under the will of John C. Rhodes, deceased, against Florence Cryer Rhodes, individually and as executrix of the estate of John B. Rhodes, deceased, and others, for instructions as to distribution of trust property under the will. From a decree instructing petitioner, named respondent appeals.
Affirmed.Appeal from Probate Court, Plymouth County; Poland, Judge.
John M. Bullard, of New Bedford, stated the case.
R. Wait, of Boston, for respondent Florence Cryer Rhodes.
C. P. Warren, of Boston, for respondents Marcus Arnold Rhodes and another.
This is a petition for instructions as to the distribution of certain property held in trust by the petitioner, as it is trustee under the seventh clause of the will of John C. Rhodes, who died July 15, 1916, leaving as his only heirs at law a widow, Caroline M. Rhodes, and a son, John B. Rhodes. He was also survived by a grandnephew, Marcus Arnold Rhodes, who is a respondent in the proceeding, and a grand-niece, Nancy Bassett Rhodes Barker, who has since deceased and whose executor is also a respondent. By the seventh clause of his will the testator gave one third of certain described personal property in trust to pay the net income to his wife for life, and upon her death to pay over three fourths of the trust fund then in the hands of the trustee ‘as provided in the Ninth Clause of this will.’
By the eighth clause of the will the testator gave his son John $50,000 out of the remainder of his estate. In the ninth clause he gave all the rest, residue and remainder of his estate in trust to pay the income to ‘John’ for life, and therein provided as follows:
Other provisions of the ninth clause are as follows: By the twelfth clause the testator subjects the interest of each beneficiary ‘under the trusts created’ by the will to stringent spendthrift provisions as to both income and principal, going so far as to authorize the trustee in the absence of personal receipt from a beneficiary to make payments for the benefit of such beneficiary or for his or her family; with similar power in case of attempted attachment, sequestration, assignment or anticipation by any beneficiary; and also, in such case, if the condition exists at the termination of the trust, to pay over the portion to which the beneficiary affected would otherwise be entitled to some member of the family of such beneficiary.
Oliver Prescott was duly appointed and qualified as trustee under the ninth clause of the will, and, on July 16, 1923, he paid over and delivered to the testator's son the trust estate actually in his possession and executed an instrument which was filed in the ‘Plymouth County Probate Court.’ The instrument reads as follows: ‘Whereas by the Seventh Clause of the will of John C. Rhodes, late of Marion, Mass., deceased, a certain Trust Fund was created for the benefit of Caroline M. Rhodes for life, and Whereas it is provided that upon the death of the said Caroline M. Rhodes three-fourths of the Trust Fund created by said Seventh Clause of said will shall be paid over as provided in the Ninth Clause of the said will, and Whereas the said Ninth Clause of said will provided a Trust Fund for the benefit of John B. Rhodes for and during his life, with the provision that the Trustee, after the expiration of a period of seven years from the date of the death of the testator, should have the right, in his discretion, to terminate the Trust created by said Ninth Clause and pay over and deliver a part or the whole of said Trust Fund to the said John B. Rhodes free and discharged of all trusts, and Whereas in accordance with the provisions for termination of the Trust contained in said Clause the Trust was terminated on July 16th, 1923, I, Oliver Prescott, Trustee under the said Ninth Clause of the will of John C. Rhodes, do hereby assign, transfer and set over unto the said John B. Rhodes as part of the said Trust Fund all the right, title and interest which I have as Trustee under the Ninth Clause of the said will in and to the Trust Fund created by the Seventh Clause of said will, the purpose of this document being to vest in the said John B. Rhodes individually the right to receive three-fourths of the Trust Fund created by the said Seventh Clause of said will upon the death of the said Caroline M. Rhodes, and I do hereby authorize and empower the said John B. Rhodes to receive directly in his own name from the Trustee of said Seventh Clause...
To continue reading
Request your trial