Oradell Village v. Wayne Tp.
| Decision Date | 17 June 1968 |
| Docket Number | No. A--690,A--690 |
| Citation | 244 A.2d 513,101 N.J.Super. 403 |
| Parties | ORADELL VILLAGE, Esquire Estates, Inc., Povershon Construction Co., Inc., Southfield Homes, Inc., Brooklawn Gardens Inc., New Jersey corporations, and Richard Geiger and Wilson Kaplan, t/a Wayne Village, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. TOWNSHIP OF WAYNE, a municipal corporation, Defendant-Respondent. |
| Court | New Jersey Superior Court — Appellate Division |
Oscar R. Wilensky, Passaic, for appellants (Cole & Geany, Paterson, attorneys).
Jerome A. Vogel, Pompton Lakes, for respondent (Salvatore J. Ruggiero, Wayne, attorney).
Before Judges SULLIVAN, FOLEY and LEONARD.
The judgment is affirmed for the reasons expressed in the opinion of Judge Mountain reported at 98 N.J.Super. 8, 235 A.2d 905 (Ch.Div.1967).
On this appeal, in addition to the argument that the separate classification of multi-tenant dwellings for rate making purposes as embodied in the amended ordinance is arbitrary, discriminatory and unreasonable, plaintiffs contend that the rates imposed by the amended ordinance were discriminatory as to them inasmuch as they were charged a greater amount per gallon for allowable gallonage than the rate imposed upon an owner of a single dwelling. This issue was not raised by the complaint, nor presented to Judge Mountain, and consequently was not decided by him. We therefore do not pass upon it.
Affirmed.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Deerfield Estates, Inc. v. East Brunswick Tp.
... ... v. Trenton, supra, 66 N.J.Super. at 61, 168 A.2d 429, 435. See also Oradell Village, et al. v. Tp. of Wayne, 98 N.J.Super. 8, 235 A.2d 905 (Ch.Div.1967), aff'd 101 N.J.Super ... ...
-
Colchester Fire Dist. No. 2 v. Sharrow, 83-427
... ... Village of Swanton, 113 Vt. 424, 427-28, 35 A.2d 381, 384 (1944): ... The fact that a public service system ... Oradell Village v. Township of Wayne, 98 N.J.Super. 8, 235 A.2d 905 (Ch.Div.1967), aff'd., 101 N.J.Super ... ...
-
Luv Condominium Ass'n v. Borough of Stanhope
... ... 192 N.J.Super. 159 ... 469 A.2d 502 ... LUV CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION and Stonegate Village ... Condominium Association, Plaintiffs-Appellants, ... BOROUGH OF STANHOPE, ... 79 [259 A.2d 229] (1969). This feature of the instant ordinance is not unreasonable. See Oradell Village et als. v. Tp. of Wayne, 98 N.J.Super. 8, 13 [235 A.2d 905] (Ch.Div.1967), aff'd o.b. 101 ... ...
-
Phoenix Associates, Inc. v. Edgewater Park Sewerage Authority
... ... 79 (259 A.2d 229) (1969). This feature of the instant ordinance is not unreasonable. See Oradell Village et als. v. Tp. of Wayne, 98 N.J.Super. 8, 13 (235 A.2d 905) (Ch.Div.1967), aff'd o. b. 101 ... ...