Osborne v. State of Florida, 87
Decision Date | 04 January 1897 |
Docket Number | No. 87,87 |
Citation | 41 L.Ed. 586,17 S.Ct. 214,164 U.S. 650 |
Parties | OSBORNE v. STATE OF FLORIDA |
Court | U.S. Supreme Court |
From the order committing plaintiff in error to the custody of the sheriff, and appeal was taken to the supreme court of the state of Florida, and that court affirmed the order. Osborne v. State, 33 Fla. 162, 14 South. 588. The plaintiff in error then sued out a writ of error from this court.
John E. Hartridge, for plaintiff in error.
W. B. Lamar, for defendant in error.
Mr. Justice PECKHAM, after stating the facts in the foregoing language, delivered the opinion of the court.
The criminal proceedings against the plaintiff in error were taken by virtue of a statute of Florida, known as 'Chapter 4115,' approved June 2, 1893. The ninth section of that chapter provides that:
There are various subdivisions to this section not herein set forth, and they enumerate divers occupations and professions, the members of which are required to procure a license, and to pay annually therefor the amounts stated in those subdivisions.
The twelfth subdivision provides, among other things, that
In addition to the criminal penalty above set forth, section 10 provides that the payment of all licenses taxed may be enforced by the seizure and sale of property by the collector.
The plaintiff in error assigns two grounds upon which he seeks for a reversal of the judgment of the state court. One is based upon the allegation that the statute, so far as regards the Southern Express Company or himself as its agent, violates the commerce clause of the federal constitution, in that it assumes to regulate interstate commerce. The second ground is that the statute is not sufficiently determinate, definite, and certain in its character upon which to ascertain the amount to be paid for licenses.
It may be here assumed that, if the statute applied to the express company in relation to its interstate business, it would be void as an attempted interference with, or regulation of, interstate commerce.
The particular construction to be given to this state statute is a question for the state court to deal with, and in such a case as this we follow the construction given by the state court to the statutes of its own state. Leffingwell v. Warren, 2 Black, 599; People v. Weaver, 100 U. S. 539, 541; Noble v. Mitchell, 164 U. S. 367, 372, 17 Sup. Ct. 110, and cases there cited.
The supreme court of Florida has construed the ninth section of this act, and has held in express terms that it does not apply to, or affect in any manner, the business of...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Chassanoil v. City of Greenwood
...and transported in interstate commerce. Bacon v. Illinois, 227 U.S. 502, 57 L.Ed. 227; Harrison v. Mayor, etc., of Vicksburg, 3 S. & M. 581; Osborne, Agent Southern Express Co. v. Mayor, etc., of Mobile, U.S. 479, 21 L.Ed. 470; Nathan v. State of Louisiana, (U. S.), 8 Howard 70, 12 L.Ed. 99......
-
In Re Seven Barrels of Wine, in Re
... 83 So. 627 79 Fla. 1 In re SEVEN BARRELS OF WINE. Florida Supreme Court January 14, 1920 ... Appeal ... from Circuit ... rights secured by the state Constitution ... While ... the amendment to article 19 of the ... vested rights. 36 Cyc. 1210; Graves v. Dunlap, 87 ... Wash. 648, 152 P. 532, L. R. A. 1916C, 338, Ann. Cas. 1917B, ... v ... Priest, 67 Fla. 370, 65 So. 282; Osborne v ... State, 33 Fla. 162, 14 So. 588, 25 L. R. A. 120, 39 Am ... St ... ...
-
Shepard v. Northern Pac. Ry. Co.
... ... 2007-- 1 to ... 2007-- 2)), reducing passenger fares within the state about ... 33 1/3 per cent., and of April 18, 1907 (Gen. Laws 1907, c ... 47, 57, 58, 59, 11 ... Sup.Ct. 851, 35 L.Ed. 649; Osborne v. Florida, 164 ... U.S. 650, 655, 17 Sup.Ct. 214, 41 L.Ed. 586; ... ...
-
Haskell v. Cowham
... ... highways of that state to transport such gas out of the ... state, violates the Constitution of ... U.S. 305, 315, 12 Sup.Ct. 403, 36 L.Ed. 164; Osborne v ... Florida, 164 U.S. 650, 655, 17 Sup.Ct. 214, 41 L.Ed ... 586; ... ...