Patterson v. Citizens' Nat. Bank of Lubbock
Decision Date | 21 December 1921 |
Docket Number | (No. 1877.) |
Citation | 236 S.W. 130 |
Parties | PATTERSON v. CITIZENS' NAT. BANK OF LUBBOCK. |
Court | Texas Court of Appeals |
Appeal from Lubbock County Court; P. F. Brown, Judge.
Suit by G. D. Patterson against the Citizens' National Bank of Lubbock. Judgment for defendant, and plaintiff appeals. Reversed and rendered.
R. A. Sowder, of Lubbock, for appellant.
Bean & Klett, of Lubbock, for appellee.
This suit was brought by appellant, G. D. Patterson, against appellee bank to recover the sum of $303.10 deposited to plaintiff's credit in the bank and wrongfully, it is alleged, appropriated by the bank and applied to the payment of a certain note executed by Patterson and payable to the bank. The plaintiff alleged that prior to such act of the bank he was adjudged a bankrupt and subsequently received his discharge in bankruptcy; that said debt was thereby discharged, and the bank, in applying such deposit as a credit on such debt, acted wrongfully. The bank claimed, and this claim raises the real controversy in the case, that it had an equitable lien on or an assignment of the fund represented by this deposit, which lien or assignment was not dischargeable by the adjudication of bankruptcy.
On November 8, 1918, G. D. Patterson executed and delivered to the bank his note for $275.24. The following testimony of the bank's cashier is relied on by the bank to establish the equitable assignment or lien claimed by it:
Patterson filed his petition in bankruptcy on September 29, 1919, and on March 31, 1920, was discharged from all his debts, dischargeable in bankruptcy, "which existed on September 29, 1919." The note to the bank was listed among the liabilities in the bankruptcy proceeding, and the bank filed its claim therein, but later withdrew it. On October 17th and later during that month and November, 1919, Patterson's tenant on the 160 acres of land referred to, deposited rentals therefrom with the bank, to the credit of an account entitled "G. D. Patterson Rent Account." The deposits were made upon direction of Patterson. On November 12, 1919, the bank, without Patterson's knowledge or consent, charged said account with $303.10, and credited said note with such amount. This suit was brought by the said Patterson to recover said sum of money. The trial court held as a matter of law "that the agreement between said Patterson and said bank created an equitable lien, mortgage, and assignment of the proceeds so deposited in said bank as security for said debt, owing by said Patterson to said bank," and entered judgment for the defendant.
It seems to be the well-settled law that a mere promise to pay a debt out of a particular fund will not operate as an equitable assignment pro tanta of the fund.
...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
First Nat. Bank v. Commercial Union Assur. Co., Ltd.
... ... A. 513; Capen v. Garrison, 193 Mo. 335, 92 S.W. 368, ... 5 L. R. A., N. S., 838; Patterson v. Citizens Bank of ... Lubbock (Tex. Civ.), 236 S.W. 130; Lindberg v ... Humphrey, 289 F ... ...
-
Peck v. Powell
...equitable lien upon any fund, because at that time no fund was in existence. As said by Boyce, Justice in Patterson v. Citizens' National Bank of Lubbock (Tex. Civ. App.) 236 S. W. 130: "It seems to be the well-settled law that a mere promise to pay a debt out of a particular fund will not ......
-
Central Nat. Bank v. Latham & Co.
...thereof. Davis & Goggin v. State National Bank (Tex. Civ. App.) 156 S. W. 321, 327, par. 1 (writ refused); Patterson v. Citizens' National Bank (Tex. Civ. App.) 236 S. W. 130, 131; Southern Surety Co. v. Bering Mfg. Co. (Tex. Civ. App.) 295 S. W. 337, 340, 341, par. 3; American Cotton Co. v......
-
Strickland v. Sellers
...Wheeler v. Fronhoff, Tex.Civ.App., 270 S.W. 887; American Cotton Co. v. Simmons, 39 Tex.Civ.App. 189, 87 S.W. 842; Patterson v. Citizens' Nat. Bank, Tex.Civ.App., 236 S.W. 130; Central Nat. Bank v. Latham & Co., Tex.Civ.App., 22 S.W.2d 13 Galveston, H. & S. A. R. Co. v. Ginther, 96 Tex. 295......