Pine v. Pine

• Decision Date: 28 December 1948
• Citation: 323 Mass. 524,83 N.E.2d 171
• Parties: ALICE PINE v. BEN PINE.
• Court: United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court

323 Mass. 524

83 N.E.2d 171

ALICE PINE v. BEN PINE.

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, Essex.

December 28, 1948

October 8, 1948.

Present: QUA, C.

J., LUMMUS, DOLAN WILKINS, & WILLIAMS, JJ.

Marriage and Divorce, Death of party, Decree, Appeal. Probate Court Decree, Appeal.

A decree nisi of divorce and for alimony entered in a Probate Court was prevented from becoming absolute at the expiration of six months after its entry by suspension of its operation under G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 215,

Sections 23, 24 pending decision by this court on an appeal therefrom.

Death of a party to a divorce proceeding before a decree nisi of divorce and for alimony had become absolute terminated the proceeding and required a decree dismissing the libel.

LIBEL for divorce filed in the Probate Court for the county of Essex on September 4, 1947.

The case was heard by Costello, J.

H. C. Thompson, (F.

H. Tarr with him,) for the libellee.

J. R. St.

Pierre, for the libellant.

LUMMUS, J. This is a libel for divorce on the ground of desertion, filed in the Probate Court on September 4, 1947. There was evidence that the libellee deserted the libellant in November, 1935, and that the parties have not lived together since. On April 8 1948, a decree nisi for desertion (G. L. [Ter. Ed.] c. 208, Section 21) was entered, and it was decreed that the libellee pay to the libellant for her support $10,000 and $60 a week, until the further order of the court. The libellee appealed on April 26, 1948, and on April 27,

1948, on motion of the libellee "the operation of said decree and entry of an absolute decree" were suspended until after the final determination of this court. G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 215, Sections 23, 24. See MacNevin v. MacNevin, 319 Mass. 719 , 722.

In view of the result that we have reached, we need not consider whether the award of alimony was proper or not. See Klar v Klar, 322 Mass. 59 . The decisive fact in this case is that Alice Pine, the libellant, died on November 17, 1948, after the arguments and while the case was before this court for decision. The case is governed by Diggs v. Diggs, 291 Mass. 399 . The suspension of the operation of the decree in the present case prevented the entry of an absolute decree by lapse of time on October 8, 1948, as effectively as would the pendency of objections to an absolute decree such as were pending in the Diggs case. In the present case the parties...