Popovich v. Ram Pipe & Supply Co., Inc.

• Court: Supreme Court of Illinois
• Citation: 412 N.E.2d 518,82 Ill.2d 203,45 Ill.Dec. 167
• Decision Date: 17 October 1980
• Docket Number: No. 52479,52479
• Parties: , 45 Ill.Dec. 167 John T. POPOVICH, Indiv. and as Adm'r, Appellee, v. RAM PIPE & SUPPLY COMPANY, INC., et al. Appeal of RELIANCE INSURANCE CO. et al.

Page 518

412 N.E.2d 518 82 Ill.2d 203, 45 Ill.Dec. 167 John T. POPOVICH, Indiv. and as Adm'r, Appellee,
v.
RAM PIPE & SUPPLY COMPANY, INC., et al.
Appeal of RELIANCE INSURANCE CO. et al. No. 52479. Supreme Court of Illinois. Oct. 17, 1980.
Rehearing Denied Nov. 26, 1980.

[82 Ill.2d 204] Judge, Drew, Cipolla & Kurnick Ltd., Park Ridge (Timothy T. McLaughlin, Park Ridge, of counsel), for appellants.

Joseph P. Condon of Joslyn & Green, Crystal Lake, for appellee.

Page 519

[45 Ill.Dec. 168] KLUCZYNSKI, Justice:

This is an appeal by Reliance Insurance Company, Northwestern Garage, Inc., A. Curtis Dufield, and Sandra M. Newman (intervenors) from a judgment of the circuit court of McHenry County denying their petition to intervene in a wrongful death action. Intervenors, with the exception of Reliance, had been named defendants in the suit but were dismissed by plaintiff after execution of a document captioned "loan agreement" under which Reliance, liability insurer for Northwestern Garage, advanced $20,000 to plaintiff. The agreement requires repayment of the money advanced only in the event plaintiff recovers judgment in excess of $20,000 from remaining defendants and only then in the amount of such excess, up to and including the amount advanced. The circuit court ruled that the agreement was, in effect, a covenant not to sue rather than a loan agreement, and it reduced [82 Ill.2d 205] the jury's verdict by the amount paid under the agreement and entered judgment in that reduced amount. Intervenors sought to intervene and argued that the court erred in its construction of the agreement. The circuit court denied the petition to intervene, and intervenors appealed. The appellate court reversed the circuit court's ruling that intervention was improper, but it affirmed the circuit court's determination that the agreement is not a true loan agreement. The court remanded the cause to the circuit court with directions to reinstate the jury's verdict but to set off the amount received under the agreement as a partial satisfaction of judgment. (74 Ill.App.3d 343, 30 Ill.Dec. 189, 392 N.E.2d 954.) We granted intervenors leave to appeal.

On May 22, 1973, David G. Popovich, 7 years old, was hit by a truck as he alighted from a school bus in or near Crystal Lake, McHenry County. The truck was driven by defendant Gregory D. Winans and was owned by defendant Ram Pipe & Supply Company. The bus from which the Popovich boy alighted was driven by intervenor Sandra M. Newman and was owned by intervenor Northwestern Garage. Intervenor A. Curtis Dufield is vice-president of Northwestern Garage, and intervenor Reliance Insurance Company is its liability insurer. Plaintiff's complaint also named Crystal Lake School District No. 47 as a defendant, alleging that the district is responsible for the school bus program in which the Popovich boy was participating.

As a result of injuries sustained, the Popovich boy died one week later. His father, John T. Popovich, filed this wrongful death action in the circuit court of Cook County. On motion of the defendant school district, the cause was transferred to McHenry County. Plaintiff thereafter filed an amended complaint and sought leave to add K & K Well Drilling, Inc., as a defendant, alleging that K & K was the employer of Winans, driver of the truck which struck the Popovich boy. The circuit court's [82 Ill.2d 206] disposition of plaintiff's motion to add K & K does not appear in the record, but it would appear from K & K's participation in later proceedings that the motion was allowed and that K & K remained in the suit for at least some time. Shortly after plaintiff sought leave to add K & K, the defendant school district filed a third-party complaint for indemnification from K & K and Winans on an active-passive negligence theory.

While the case was still in its pretrial stages, plaintiff, Reliance Insurance Company, Northwestern Garage, and Sandra M. Newman executed a document entitled "loan agreement." The agreement provides:

"I, John T. Popovich, as Administrator of the Estate of David G. Popovich, hereby acknowledge receipt from the Northwestern Garage, Inc., a corporation, and Sandra Newman, by and through their insurance company, Reliance Insurance Company, a corporation, the sum of Twenty Thousand and no/100 ($20,000.00) Dollars, as a loan, without interest.

It being understood by all parties hereto, that I am discussing and will possibly be accepting a similar loan, without interest from the Crystal Lake Community School District No. 47, a municipal corporation, by and through their insurance

Page 520

[45 Ill.Dec. 169] company, the Western Insurance Companies, a corporation, in the sum of Ten Thousand and no/100 ($10,000.00) Dollars.

I hereby agree and promise to repay this loan, from any judgment I am...