Prime v. Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha
Decision Date | 31 May 2002 |
Docket Number | No. 85,861.,85,861. |
Citation | 47 P.3d 402,273 Kan. 828 |
Parties | MATTHEW J. PRIME, Appellant, v. BETA GAMMA CHAPTER OF PI KAPPA ALPHA, a Kansas Voluntary Association, PI KAPPA ALPHA FRATERNITY, a Tennessee Mutual Organization, TODD GUERRIERI, JEFF FAY, BRIAN HARPER, CORY AUBUCHON, JOHN KOSCIULUK, AARON HARPER, and THE MOUNT OREAD HOUSE CORPORATION, a Kansas Corporation, Appellees. |
Court | Kansas Supreme Court |
Theodore J. Lickteig, of Law Offices of Theodore J. Lickteig, of Overland Park, argued the cause and was on the brief for appellant.
Brian G. Boos, of Gehrt & Roberts, Chartered, of Topeka, argued the cause for individual appellees, and Craig C. Blumreich, of the same firm, for appellee Brian Harper; John E. Bordeau and Jana V. Richards, of Sanders Conkright & Warren LLP, of Kansas City, Missouri, for appellee Jeffrey Fay; and Wayne E. Smith, of Dougherty, Modin & Holloway, of Kansas City, Missouri, for appellees Cory Aubuchon, John Kosciuluk, and Todd Guerrieri, and were on the briefs of individual appellees.
Michael K. Seek, of Fisher, Patterson, Sayler & Smith, L.L.P., of Overland Park, argued the cause and was on the brief for appellees Mount Oread House Corporation and Pi Kappa Alpha Fraternity.
Rod L. Eisenhauer, of Seigfreid, Bingham, Levy, Selzer & Gee, P.C., of Kansas City, Missouri, argued the cause and was on the brief for appellee Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha.
The opinion of the court was delivered by
This personal injury action arose out of a fraternity initiation event where Matthew Prime excessively consumed alcoholic beverages, which led to his hospitalization. Prime sued the local chapter and the national organization of the fraternity, the corporate owner of the real property where the fraternity chapter is housed, five individual fraternity members, the University of Kansas, and the Board of Regents. The university and regents were dismissed by Prime. Prime appeals from the trial court's order dismissing the local chapter and the trial court's order granting summary judgment to the remaining defendants. This court transferred the case from the Court of Appeals. K.S.A. 20-3018(c).
Matthew Prime was a 19-year-old pledge of the Beta Gamma chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity at the University of Kansas when he attended Pledge Dad Night at the fraternity house. Prime was provided alcoholic beverages in large quantities and encouraged but not required to drink them during the occasion. Prime drank excessively and lost consciousness. Fraternity members took Prime to the hospital. Prime was hospitalized with a blood alcohol concentration of .294. He alleged that he incurred medical expenses but no permanent injuries. The district court's findings of fact specific to the various defendants will be set out where necessary to the discussion of the issues.
Prime raises four issues on appeal: (1) Is Beta Gamma chapter, an unincorporated association, a legal entity that can be sued; (2) did the district court erroneously enter summary judgment in favor of the individual fraternity member defendants; (3) did the district court erroneously enter summary judgment in favor of Pi Kappa Alpha; and (4) did the district court erroneously enter summary judgment in favor of Mount Oread House Corporation?
The district court granted Beta Gamma Chapter's motion to dismiss on the ground that the chapter is an unincorporated association, which cannot be sued in the name of the association. The district court's decision involved only a question of law, and this court's review is unlimited.
In Kansas Private Club Assn. v. Londerholm, 196 Kan. 1, 408 P.2d 891 (1965), the court stated: 196 Kan. at 3. Prime contends that after the decision in Kansas Private Club Assn. was issued, a statute was enacted that superseded the general rule stated in the case.
The statute cited by Prime is K.S.A. 60-223b, which became effective on publication in the Kansas Reports and in K.S.A. 1969 Supp. It provides:
K.S.A. 60-223b plainly applies only to class actions.
Prime recognizes that a decision issued by the Court of Appeals long after K.S.A. 60-223b became effective cites Kansas Private Club Assn. and follows the general rule stated in that case. See Frey, Inc. v. City of Wichita, 11 Kan. App.2d 116, 715 P.2d 417 (1986). In Frey, now-Justice Abbott wrote for the Court of Appeals that a homeowners association "was never incorporated; therefore, it is not a legal entity and can neither sue nor be sued in the name of the Association." 11 Kan. App.2d at 117.
The rule in Kansas is that an unincorporated association can neither sue nor be sued, and K.S.A. 60-223b does not affect application of the rule in this nonclass action. The district court properly dismissed Prime's claims against the Beta Gamma Chapter of the Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity.
Prime next contends that Fay, Guerrieri, Aubuchon, Kosciuluk, and Harper owed him a duty not to haze him and a duty not to provide beer and liquor in harmful quantities. The district court entertained three motions for summary judgment from the individual defendants and granted each of the motions.
With regard to Fay, the district court wrote:
With regard to Guerrieri, Aubuchon, and Kosciuluk, the district court repeated that Kansas courts do not recognize a cause of action for furnishing alcoholic beverages to a minor and cited Mills. The district court further stated that Prime voluntarily consumed alcoholic beverages to the levels that made him ill and that Guerrieri, Aubuchon, and Kosciuluk owed Prime no duty.
In ruling for Harper, the district court made the following findings of fact and conclusions of law:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Canaan v. Bartee
...in Kansas. This issue presents an issue of law over which this court's review is unlimited. See Prime v. Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha, 273 Kan. 828, 830, 47 P.3d 402 (2002). Kansas Law Regarding Legal Malpractice Our appellate courts have stated the following requirements in regard ......
-
Pinsky v. Pikesville Recreation Council, 0052
...(2008) (unincorporated associations may not sue or be sued unless authorized by statute); Prime v. Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha, 273 Kan. 828, 47 P.3d 402, 405 (2002) (“The rule in Kansas is that an unincorporated association can neither sue nor be sued....”). At the beginning of th......
-
Canaan v. Bartee, 89,023.
...in Kansas. This issue presents an issue of law over which this court's review is unlimited. See Prime v. Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha, 273 Kan. ___, ___, 47 P.3d 402 (2002). Kansas Law Regarding Legal Malpractice Our appellate courts have stated the following requirements in regard ......
-
Kudlacik v. Johnny's Shawnee, Inc.
...... who killed plaintiff while driving drunk); Prime v. Beta Gamma Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha , 273 ......