Reynolds v. Reynolds, 124.
Citation | 181 S.E. 338,208 N. C. 428 |
Decision Date | 18 September 1935 |
Docket Number | No. 124.,124. |
Court | North Carolina Supreme Court |
Parties | REYNOLDS. v. REYNOLDS. |
Appeal from Superior Court, Buncombe County; Warlick, Judge.
Action for divorce by Robert A. Reynolds against Emma Reynolds. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
Reversed and remanded for new trial.
Civil action for divorce on the ground of two years' separation, tried upon the usual issues, resulting in verdict for the plaintiff.
In bar of plaintiff's right to maintain the action, the defendant alleges:
The court ruled that the defense pleaded was no bar to the plaintiff's right to prosecute the action, and excluded the evidence offered by the defendant to prove her allegations. Exception.
From a judgment on the verdict dissolving the bonds of matrimony existing between the parties, the defendant appeals, assigning errors.
James E. Rector, of Asheville, for appellant.
Worth McKinney, of Asheville, for appellee.
May a husband ground an action for divorce, under Code 1931, § 1659 (a), Pub. Laws 1933, c. 163, on his own criminal conduct towards his wife? The answer is, no. Teasley v. Teasley, 205 N. C. 604, 172 S. E. 197. Any other holding would be a reproach to the law. Bean v. Detective Co., 206 N. C. 125, 173 S. E. 5. The...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Cameron v. Cameron
...her. Taylor v. Taylor, supra; Pharr v. Pharr, 223 N.C. 115, 25 S.E.2d 471; Byers v. Byers, 223 N.C. 85, 25 S.E.2d 466; Reynolds v. Reynolds, 208 N.C. 428, 181 S.E. 338. It follows that a judgment on the merits in favor of Mrs. Cameron in the prior action in Sampson County will operate as a ......
-
Byers v. Byers
... ... an action for divorce on his own criminal conduct towards his ... wife. Reynolds v. Reynolds, 208 N.C. 428, 181 S.E ... 338; Brown v. Brown, 213 N.C. 347, 196 S.E. 333; ... ...
-
Taylor v. Taylor
...by his criminal conduct in wilfully abandoning his wife and children without providing adequate support for them. In Reynolds v. Reynolds, 208 N.C. 428, 181 S.E. 338, the defendant, as a bar to the plaintiff's action for absolute divorce on the ground of two years separation, pleaded the pl......
-
Hollingsworth v. Burns
... ... [ir] responsible, a question of fact for the jury." ... Rolin v. R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., 141 N.C. 300, ... 53 S.E. 891, 896, 7 L.R.A. (N.S.) 335, 8 Ann.Cas. 638; ... ...