Scott v. State
| Decision Date | 29 June 2017 |
| Docket Number | NO. 2015–KA–01623–SCT,2015–KA–01623–SCT |
| Court | Mississippi Supreme Court |
| Parties | Kale SCOTT a/k/a Kale Rashaud Scott v. STATE of Mississippi |
ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT: RODNEY A. RAY
ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE: OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, BY: KAYLYN HAVRILLA McCLINTON
BEFORE RANDOLPH, P.J., COLEMAN AND MAXWELL, JJ.
¶1. Kale Scott was indicted for one count of aggravated assault, in violation of Section 97–3–7 of the Mississippi Code, and one count of murder, in violation of Section 97–3–19. Scott appeals the verdict of a Lowndes County jury, which found him guilty on both counts. Finding no error, we affirm his convictions and sentences.
¶2. On the evening of May 22, 2014, Scott attended a high school graduation party at the Lowndes County fairgrounds in Columbus, Mississippi. Approximately two hundred guests were in attendance. During the party, Frederick Smith was shot in the leg, and Devin Montgomery, who was shot five times in the back to the posterior of his body, succumbed to his injuries and died. Scott admitted he was the shooter.
¶3. During the trial, Jomoco "Ken" Harriston testified that he was working as a security guard for Robinson Security the night of the graduation party. Harriston witnessed a fight break out near the stage between Scott and Montgomery. Harriston broke up the fight1 and then began escorting Scott toward the entrance of the building. Before he could get Scott out of the building, Harriston heard another fight break out behind him. Harriston let Scott go and went back to the same area where the original fight had occurred. Montgomery was involved in the second fight, so Harriston began to walk Montgomery to the entrance of the building. As Harriston was escorting Montgomery, Scott stepped out of a nearby crowd. Harriston estimated that Scott was about eight feet in front of Montgomery. Harriston testified that Montgomery was not attacking or threatening Scott in any way. Scott spoke to Montgomery, but Harriston testified that he and Montgomery continued walking, paying Scott no attention. Harriston then heard a "pow" and saw Montgomery jump, run away, and collide with a table. Harriston testified that it was extremely loud in the building because the speakers were still blaring. He heard only one shot. After Montgomery hit the table, Harriston saw him get up and run toward the exit, before Montgomery finally stopped, leaned against a wall, and slid down, leaving a trail of blood. Harriston ran out of the building to call 911.
¶4. Harriston testified that he never saw Scott with a gun, but he did see Scott tuck something into his front waistband after the shots were fired. Harriston never saw Montgomery or anyone else with a weapon.
¶5. Diesha Walker testified that she was on the staircase of the stage when the first fight broke out. Montgomery was standing on the floor, leaning up against the stage. Scott was standing on the stage behind Montgomery below. Scott accidentally spilled his beer on Montgomery while he was dancing on stage. Montgomery told Scott to "chill out." Scott spilled his beer again before Montgomery grabbed Scott off the stage. Walker saw Harriston break up the fight and walk off with Scott. Walker testified that another man, Deandra Buck, hit Montgomery, and the two started fighting. Walker testified that she saw Scott reappear and pull out a gun and shoot. Walker stated that Scott appeared to hesitate after the first shot, but he continued shooting. Walker testified that at the time of the shooting, Montgomery was not a threat to Scott. Walker never saw Montgomery or anyone else with a weapon.
¶6. Fredrick Smith, Montgomery's cousin, testified that he saw both fights involving Montgomery. When the security guard came to break up the second fight and take Montgomery away, Smith stayed behind and confronted the person who had been fighting Montgomery (Buck). As Smith was questioning Buck, he saw a man with a gun in his hand approaching him from the right. Smith then saw the man fire the gun. Smith testified that he heard four or five gunshots.
Smith testified that he was shot in the back of his right thigh. Smith identified Scott as the shooter.
¶7. Dr. Erin Barnhardt, deputy chief medical examiner at the Mississippi State medical Examiner's Office, was accepted as an expert in the field of forensic pathology. She testified that Montgomery had suffered five gunshot wounds2
and had died as a result of his injuries. Barnhardt testified that Montgomery had been at least three feet away from the shooter when he was shot.
¶8. Kevin McCrary, a law enforcement officer with the Columbus Police Department, testified that the weapon used in the shooting was never recovered. After interviewing Harriston and Walker, who both identified Scott as the shooter, McCrary began looking for Scott but was unsuccessful. Two days after the shooting, Scott turned himself in to the police. McCrary testified that Scott neither had any noticeable injuries nor complained of any injuries and was not in need of medical attention.
¶9. After the State rested, Scott moved for a directed verdict, which was denied.
¶10. Bernice Willis, Scott's grandmother, testified that she had noticed several knots and bruises on Scott's head immediately before he turned himself in to the police. She testified she did not notice these bruises on the afternoon of the graduation party. Willis agreed that she had not seen him between the party and when he turned himself in and that she did not know when he may have received the knots and bruises.
¶11. Shareka Tillman, a chaperone at the party, testified that when she first saw Scott at the party he appeared normal and she did not see him with a gun. After she heard commotion from the fight and then gunshots, she saw Scott standing in the middle of the floor. When she approached him, she saw he had knots on his head and appeared in a daze. He would not answer any of her questions about what had happened.
¶12. Scott testified on his own behalf. He said he was at the graduation party with Buck and another friend. After Scott had entered the party, a friend of his told him he needed to get his cigarettes out of Scott's car. Scott left the party, got the cigarettes, and came back inside. Scott testified that, while he was on the stage with two girls, Montgomery grabbed his leg and wanted to talk to him. Scott pushed away from Montgomery, but Montgomery pulled him off the stage, and the two began fighting. Montgomery then hit Scott on the shoulder, grabbed him by the pockets, and started going through his pockets. Scott testified that Montgomery pulled his shirt over his head and was hitting him in the head. Other people also started hitting Scott in the head. Scott said at that point "[he] lost it" and started shooting.
Scott testified that, after the shooting, one of his friends had to drive him to his cousin's house, because he "wasn't 100 percent able to drive." Buck gave the gun to Scott's cousin. Scott did not call any of his family to let them know where he was until Sunday, when his family told him to meet them at the police station.
¶13. Scott testified that he brought a gun to the party because he had been picked on for many years, but he did not intend to harm anyone. He testified that he never intentionally aimed the gun at either Montgomery or Smith. Scott said that he was scared of Montgomery because he had experienced several bad encounters with Montgomery.
¶14. On cross-examination, Scott testified that he did not know why the two girls on the stage with him the night of the shooting were not at the trial to corroborate his story. He agreed that it was irresponsible to shoot a gun in a crowded room. Scott testified that he did not remember being removed from the fight by Harriston or that there was a subsequent fight between Buck and Montgomery.
¶15. The State also introduced a number of tweets that had originated from Scott's account. Most of the tweets were about shooting people and homicide. Scott testified that many of the tweets were song lyrics but that he did mean some of them.
¶16. The State called several rebuttal witnesses. Buck testified that when he heard gunshots, he ran to Scott's car. Buck testified that Scott drove and that he was acting normally and was not dazed. Scott dropped Buck off at his house, and then Scott drove away.
¶17. Angela Williams testified that both Scott and Montgomery were at her house almost every day. However, she said, Montgomery never picked on Scott while at Williams's house.
¶18. Cortney Williams, Montgomery's best friend and Scott's cousin, testified that he did not see the fights, but he talked to Montgomery immediately after they occurred. Williams recalled that he was approximately five feet away from Montgomery when he first heard the gunshots. Both men started running to exit.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Turner v. State
...element of aggravated assault under Mississippi Code Section 97-3-7(2)(b) was proved beyond a reasonable doubt. See Scott v. State , 220 So. 3d 957, 962 (Miss. 2017) (quoting Hardy v. State , 137 So. 3d 289, 303-04 (Miss. 2014) ). Specifically, the testimony before the jury established that......
-
Bernard v. State
...prove Bernard killed Johnson without authority of law and did so with the deliberate design to effect Johnson's death. Scott v. State , 220 So. 3d 957, 962 (Miss. 2017) ; Miss. Code Ann. § 97-3-19(1)(a) (Rev. 2006).1 The firearm enhancement required the State to prove Bernard used or displa......
-
Ross v. State
...men in the exercise of impartial judgment might reach different conclusions on every element of the offense ....’ " Scott v. State , 220 So. 3d 957, 962 (Miss. 2017) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Hardy v. State , 137 So. 3d 289, 304 (Miss. 2014) ).¶16. Ross's four-count indict......