Simon v. Health-Tex, Inc.
| Decision Date | 04 April 1985 |
| Docket Number | HEALTH-TE,INC,No. 82-466-A,82-466-A |
| Citation | 490 A.2d 50 |
| Parties | Nicholas C. SIMON, Jr. v.ppeal. |
| Court | Rhode Island Supreme Court |
This is an employee's appeal from the denial and dismissal of his petition for benefits payable pursuant to the terms of the Workers' Compensation Act. In his petition the employee alleged that he had incurred a "bilateral inguinal hernia" as a result of an injury he sustained on August 17, 1978, as he was stacking pallets one on top of the other. Hereinafter we shall refer to the employee as Simon and his employer as Health-Tex.
Nobody disputes the fact that Simon, while working at Health-Tex's plant, received an injury to the groin on August 17, 1978, as he was stacking pallets, each of which weighed between twenty and twenty-five pounds, or that he subsequently underwent surgery at the Pawtucket Memorial Hospital.
Simon's surgeon, Dr. Khalil Shekarchi, testified before the trial commissioner by way of a deposition. Simon underwent surgery on May 9, 1979, at which time the surgeon repaired a right inguinal hernia; a month or so later, on June 18, 1979, the surgeon advised the patient to return to work. However, on June 28, 1979, Simon returned to his surgeon, complaining of pain in his left groin.
The trial commissioner awarded Simon benefits for the right inguinal hernia but refused to award any benefits for the left hernia. The denial was based upon Dr. Shekarchi's testimony, and the denial was affirmed by an appellate commission.
In reviewing the appellate commission's actions, we are obligated to review the record and determine whether there is any competent evidence that supported the appellate commission's affirmance of the trial commissioner's denial of benefits for the left inguinal hernia. Mulcahey v. New England Newspapers, Inc., R.I., 488 A.2d 681 (1985). In direct examination, the surgeon attributed his failure to detect the left hernia to the "huge" size of the right hernia, but he was of the opinion that both hernias were causally related to the stacking episode. However, in cross-examination, the surgeon explained that before June 28, 1979, his patient never complained of pain in the left inguinal area, admitted that medically there was no way of telling how long the left hernia had...
To continue reading
Request your trial
- Benner v. J.H. Lynch & Sons, Inc.
-
Vann v. Women & Infants Hospital
... ... Ballard , 914 A.2d 487, 489 (R.I ... 2007) (citing Eleazer v. Ted Reed Thermal, Inc. , 576 ... A.2d 1217, 1221 (R.I. 1990)). This rule prohibiting fee ... shifting, ... in terms of probability and not possibility." (citing ... Simon v. Health-Tex, Inc. , 490 A.2d 50, 51 (R.I ... 1985); Montouri v. Narragansett Electric Co ... ...
-
Quintana v. Worcester Textile Co.
...Co., 504 A.2d 1015 (R.I. 1986); Monticelli v. Trifari, Krussman & Fishel, Inc., 495 A.2d 994, 996 (R.I. 1985); Simon v. Health-Tex, Inc., 490 A.2d 50, 51 (R.I. 1985). Thus, our duty today is to determine whether there is competent legal evidence to support the finding of the commission that......
-
Leyden v. Employees' Retirement System of State
... ... an amount more than a scintilla but less than a ... preponderance.'" R.I. Temps, Inc. v. Dep't ... of Labor and Training, Bd. of Review , 749 A.2d 1121, ... 1125 (R.I ... equivocal, it lacks the requisite degree of precision ... See Simon v. Health-Tex, Inc. 490 A.2d 50, 51-52 ... (R.I. 1985) ... While ... ...