Smiley v. Thomas

• Decision Date: 25 February 1952
• Docket Number: No. 4-9703,4-9703
• Parties: SMILEY v. THOMAS et al.
• Court: Arkansas Supreme Court

Page 419

246 S.W.2d 419

220 Ark. 116

SMILEY v. THOMAS et al.

No. 4-9703.

Supreme Court of Arkansas.

Feb. 25, 1952.

L. Jean Cook and Frank S. Quinn, Texarkana, for appellant.

T. B. Vance, Willis B. Smith and A. G. Sanderson, Jr., all of Texarkana, for appellees.

HOLT, Justice.

Prior to April 1, 1925, O. K. Kendrick was the owner of a forty acre tract of land in Miller County and on that date executed a deed to J. W. Koonce, denominated 'Warranty Deed, Oil, Gas and Mineral Royalty,' containing these recitals: 'That we, O. L. Kendrick, a single man, for and in consideration of the sum of $100.00, One Hundred and No/100 Dollars, to us cash in hand paid by J. W. Koonce, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, do hereby grant, bargain, sell and convey unto the said J. W. Koonce and to his heirs and assigns forever, the undivided one-half interest in and to all of the oil, gas and other minerals, in, under and upon the following described lands lying within the County of Miller and State of Arkansas, to-wit:

'The West Half of Northwest Quarter (W 1/2 of NW 1/4) of Section 23, Township 16 South, Range 28 West, containing 80 acres, more or less; subject, however, to any valid oil and gas lease now upon said land and recorded in the office of the Clerk and Recorder of Miller County, Arkansas. And for said consideration we do hereby grant and convey unto the said J. W. Koonce and unto his heirs and assigns the right to collect and receive under the aforesaid lease such undivided one-half (1/2) part and interest of all oil royalties and gas rentals due us or that may become due us under the aforementioned lease. To Have and to Hold, etc.'

Following the recording of the Koonce deed, the land on March 18, 1929 was conveyed, without exceptions, to Brice Williams. On July 10, 1929, Williams conveyed the land by warranty deed (without exceptions and without reference to the Koonce deed) to appellees, Mr. and Mrs. Thomas, who have held possession since.

In 1936, Brice Williams died intestate, leaving his mother, Mrs. Kate Williams, and appellant, Mrs. Jodie Smiley, his sole survivors and distributees. Brice Williams' estate was administrated and closed in 1938, and in 1940 his mother died intestate, leaving Mrs. Smiley her sole heir.

On December 4, 1950, appellees (Thomases) filed the present suit to quiet their title to the forty acre tract, in effect, alleging that by reason of the above outstanding 1/2 mineral interest conveyed by Kendrick to Koonce in 1925 and later to O'Brien Bros., Inc., the warranty in the deed of Brice Williams to them had been breached, that there had been a constructive eviction of appellees, that Mrs. Jodie Smiley, appellant, though called upon to defend appellees' title, has refused to do so, 'that that portion of the title thereto which has failed and been breached is of the value of $1250.00, together with items of expense, court costs and attorney's fee herein incurred;' that O'Brien Bros., Inc. acquired no valid title to the 1/2 mineral interest which they claim and by way of cross-complaint against O'Brien Bros., appellees (Thomases) assert claim to the 1/2 interest claimed by O'Brien Bros. through certain tax sales. Appellees (Thomases) prayed that title to the O'Brien Bros.' mineral interest be quieted in them but that should the court hold that O'Brien Bros. held a valid title to the 1/2 interest, then that they (Thomases) have judgment against Mrs. Smiley 'for the sum of $1250.00, for $_____ expenses incurred in attempting to remove such incumbrances against said land including $250.00 attorney's fee herein and for cost and other proper relief.'

Mrs. Smiley answered with a general denial and pleaded laches, limitations, statute of nonclaims, and that the suit was premature because there had been no eviction.

Appellee, O'Brien Bros., Inc., filed answer asserting title to the said 1/2 mineral interest by mesne conveyances from Kendrick, (being the common source of title), grantor in the first said mineral deed above, denied the validity of the tax deed under which the Thomases claimed title to the said 1/2 mineral interest and prayed that title to same be quieted in it.

The trial court found (in effect, quoting from appellant's brief) that the Thomases 'are the owners by the entirety of the lands involved in the suit, except one-half (1/2) of the oil, gas and minerals; that O. L. Kendrick is a common source of title and that he conveyed an undivided one-half (1/2) interest in the oil, gas and minerals to J. W. Koonce. That the defendant, O'Brien Bros., Inc., is the successor in title to this one-half (1/2) mineral interest; * * * that Mrs. Jodie Smiley, as heir at law of Brice Williams, received and now holds in title and possession, lands and other property in excess of the amount of plaintiffs' claim and that she is liable to respond to plaintiffs by reason of the breach of warranty in said Williams' deed.

'The court then finds that O'Brien Bros., Inc., is the owner of the Koonce undivided one-half (1/2) interest, and that all tax proceedings and sales of the interest should be cancelled and annulled and title quieted in O'Brien Bros., Inc., as to said one-half (1/2) mineral interest, and quiets the title in and to said one-half (1/2) interest in O'Brien Bros., Inc.

'The court further finds that plaintiffs' title in and to the lands has failed to the extent of the one-half (1/2) interest owned by O'Brien Bros., Inc.; that by reason of breach of warranty in said Williams' deed to plaintiffs, they have been damaged in the sum of $600.00, for which sum judgment should be rendered against the defendant, Mrs. Jodie Smiley, as heir at law of Brice Williams, deceased. It is therefore considered, ordered and decreed that title to the Koonce one-half (1/2) mineral interest be quieted in O'Brien Bros., Inc.; that plaintiffs have and recover of and from Mrs. Jodie Smiley the sum of $600.00, and all costs herein accrued.'

This appeal followed.

As to the interest of O'Brien Bros., Inc., which we first consider, we hold that they had title to a 1/2 interest in the oil, gas and mineral, and that the Chancellor was correct in so holding. Under the terms of the above deed from Kendrick to Koonce, Kendrick conveyed a 1/2 mineral interest to Koonce in fee (subject to the royalty lease, which has expired). O'Brien Bros. later obtained all the interest of Koonce. The above...