Spears v. McCoy
Decision Date | 30 September 1913 |
Citation | 159 S.W. 610,155 Ky. 1 |
Parties | SPEARS v. McCOY. |
Court | Kentucky Court of Appeals |
Appeal from Circuit Court, Pike County.
Action by Rediford Spears against Mont McCoy. From a judgment dismissing the petition, plaintiff appeals. Reversed and remanded.
Childers & Childers, of Pikeville, for appellant.
J. S Cline, of Pikeville, for appellee.
Plaintiff Rediford Spears, brought this action against Mont McCoy to recover damages for slander. A demurrer was sustained to the petition, and the petition dismissed. Plaintiff appeals.
The petition is as follows:
While there is an attempt on the part of plaintiff to give a very strained construction to the words which it is alleged that the defendant spoke of him, it is well settled that an innuendo cannot extend the meaning of words beyond their natural import. It is only explanatory of some matter already expressed. It may show the application but cannot add to or enlarge or change the sense of the words. Watson v. Hampton, 2 Bibb, 319; Moore v. Johnson, 147 Ky. 584, 144 S.W. 765.
The question, therefore, turns on whether or not the words are actionable per se. Words are slanderous or actionable per se only in cases where they are falsely spoken and (1) impute the commission of a crime involving moral turpitude, for which the party might be indicted and punished; or (2) impute an infectious disease likely to exclude him from society; or (3) impute unfitness to perform the duties of an...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Interstate Co. v. Garnett
... ... Tucker, 220 Ky. 363, 295 S.W ... 138; 53 A. L. R. 547; 17 R. C. L. 264; Baker v ... Clark, 186 Ky. 816, 218 S.W. 280; Apears v ... McCoy, 155 Ky. 1, 50 L. R. A. (N. S.) 1033, 159 S.W ... 610; 36 C. J. 1170; Maxwell v. Allison, 11 Serg. & ... R. 343; Hoar v. Ward, 47 Vt. 657; ... ...
-
Shields v. Booles
... ... acts which might tend to disinherit him. Walker v ... Tucker, 220 Ky. 363, 295 S.W. 138, 53 A.L.R. 547; ... Spears v. McCoy, 155 Ky. 1, 159 S.W. 610, 49 L.R.A ... (N. S.) 1033; Williams v. Riddle, 145 Ky. 459, 140 ... S.W. 661, 36 L.R.A. (N. S.) 974, ... ...
-
Duncan v. Record Pub. Co
...72, 123 P. 725; Curtis v. Iseman, 137 Ky. 796, 127 S. W. 150; Moore v. Johnson, 147 Ky. 584, 144 S. W. 765; Spears v. McCoy, 155 Ky. 1, 159 S. W. 610, 49 L. R. A. (N. S.) 1033; Bishop v. Smith, 198 Ky. 230, 248 S. W. 538; Vinson v. O'Malley, 25 Ariz. 552, 220 P. 393, 37 A. L. R. 877; Med. C......
-
Duncan v. Record Pub. Co.
... ... Bristow, 87 Kan. 72, 123 P. 725; Curtis v ... Iseman, 137 Ky. 796, 127 S.W. 150; Moore v ... Johnson, 147 Ky. 584, 144 S.W. 765; Spears v ... McCoy, 155 Ky. 1, 159 S.W. 610, 49 L. R. A. (N. S.) ... 1033; Bishop v. Smith, 198 Ky. 230, 248 S.W. 538; ... Vinson v. O'Malley, 25 ... ...