ST. ANDREW'S EPISCOPAL DAY SCHOOL v. MTC, 2000-IA-01303-SCT.
Decision Date | 07 February 2002 |
Docket Number | No. 2000-IA-01303-SCT.,2000-IA-01303-SCT. |
Citation | 806 So.2d 1105 |
Parties | ST. ANDREW'S EPISCOPAL DAY SCHOOL v. MISSISSIPPI TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION. |
Court | Mississippi Supreme Court |
Steven Timothy Gray, Crane D. Kipp, Jackson, for Appellant.
Alan M. Purdie, Jan F. Gadow, Dion Jeffery Shanley, John L. Gadow, Grenada, for Appellee.
Before SMITH, P.J., COBB and DIAZ, JJ.
DIAZ, Justice, for the Court.
¶ 1. On August 31, 1998, the Madison County Special Court of Eminent Domain issued its order granting the Mississippi Transportation Commission (MTC) the right of immediate title and possession to a tract of land owned by St. Andrew's Episcopal Day School (St. Andrew's). On May 18, 1999, St. Andrew's filed a motion to set aside the order and a motion to dismiss the complaint, the amended complaint, and the second amended complaint, and objected to MTC's resort to pretrial acquisition of title and possession. The lower court overruled St. Andrew's motion to dismiss, but granted its motion to set aside the order granting immediate title and possession. MTC then amended its complaint, and St. Andrew's renewed all previous objections and motions regarding the exercise of eminent domain powers by MTC. On July 24, 2000, the lower court denied St. Andrew's renewed motion to dismiss and entered an order granting right of immediate title and possession.
¶ 2. St. Andrew's then filed a motion for interlocutory appeal of the special court of eminent domain's denial of its motion to dismiss and grant of immediate title and possession, which was granted by this Court along with St. Andrew's motion to stay proceedings pending resolution of this appeal.
¶ 3. St. Andrew's cites the following issues on appeal:
FACTS
¶ 4. The MTC acquired the subject land through its power of eminent domain for the purpose of completing a project to reconstruct the obsolete interchange on I-55 at Jackson Street in Ridgeland, a part of the state highway system in Madison County. MTC found the subject property to be necessary to this project in order to expand I-55.
¶ 5. The property in the case at hand is located in the northwest quadrant of the Old Agency Road and Highland Colony Parkway intersection in Madison County. Old Agency Road lies to the south, and Highland Colony Parkway lies to the east. This project also includes construction of a round-about at this intersection, and MTC claims that the proposed right-of-way site flares on the subject property are necessary to complete the project.
¶ 6. The Mississippi Department of Transportation (MDOT) assistant chief engineer of preconstruction testified, at a hearing on another eminent domain case arising out of the same project, as an expert in the field of traffic engineering and engineering administration. He explained that once the commission approves a state highway project and determines necessity, it is not necessary to return to the commission for approval of each step of the project. The subject project was approved on the "three-year plan" beginning in 1992. The three-year plan begins with location studies which investigate and narrow down potential property which will be used to complete the project.
¶ 7. A roadway design division engineer with MDOT also testified that the project was approved although it affects other roads. An MDOT assistant maintenance engineer testified that the state highway system is being extended on the west side of the I-55/Jackson Street/ Old Agency Road interchange to include the site flares on the St. Andrew's property. The state highway department will be responsible for maintenance of this property. The executive director of the MDOT testified that it is sometimes necessary to take property outside the existing right-of-way in order to improve the safety of the state highway system.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
¶ 8. An eminent domain judge is the finder of facts in determining whether to grant a motion to dismiss a petition for eminent domain. American Tel. & Tel. Co. v. Purcell Co., 606 So.2d 93, 95-96 (Miss.1990). The standard of review is whether the trial judge had a sufficient basis for his or her decision. Mayor v. Thomas, 645 So.2d 940, 941-42 (Miss. 1994).
I. WHETHER MTC EXCEEDED IT STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO CONDEMN LAND UNDER THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN.
¶ 9. St. Andrew's argues that MTC cannot acquire the piece of its property that is located at the northwest quadrant of the intersection of two city streets because it is not contiguous to the property currently within the right of way of MTC. The lower court denied St. Andrew's motion based on its finding that MTC's purpose for acquiring St. Andrew's property was reasonable and necessary to relieve congestion from the intersection. However, the lower court also opined:
Defendant also argues that MTC has exceeded its statutory authority to regulate, design and construct the interstate highway system in Mississippi by authorizing condemnation of land for an intersection of a city-county parkway and a city street. The intersection of Highland Colony Parkway and Old Agency Road lies approximately 350 feet from the western right of way of Interstate 55 where it intersects with Jackson Avenue/ Old Agency Road in Ridgeland. This issue is more problematic for the court to resolve. Statutes and case law refer to the authority of MTC "to regulate, design and construct" in terms of jurisdiction, the power to act. MTC asserts that it has the power to take control as far west on Old Agency Road as it wishes, even if Old Agency Road is a city street inside of Ridgeland City limits and a county road outside the city limits. Case law and statutes would seem to refute plaintiffs argument. See Quin v. Mississippi State Highway Comm'n, 194 Miss. 411, 11 So.2d 810 (1945 [1943]); State Highway Comm'n v. McGowen, 198 Miss. 853, 23 S[o].2d 893 (1945); Stigall v. Sharkey County, 207 Miss. 188, 42 So.2d 116 (1949); and Hamilton v. Mississippi State Highway Comm'n, 220 Miss. 340, 70 So.2d 856 (1959 [1954]). See also Miss Code Ann. 65-1-61, 65-1-75(1) and (3), 65-1-147 and 65-7-1.
¶ 10. The power of eminent domain is the power of the sovereign to take private property for its own use. The government's exercise of this power is limited by procedural due process, which requires that the property be taken for a public use and that the owner be paid just compensation. U.S. Const. amend. V. This constitutional right to condemn property may be granted to designated public agencies by statute. Culley v. Pearl River Industrial Com'n, 234 Miss. 788, 814-15, 108 So.2d 390, 399-400 (1959).
¶ 11. Miss.Code Ann. § 65-1-8(2)(a) provides:
(emphasis added). Miss.Code Ann. § 65-1-47 provides:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Htk Management v. Seattle Monorail Auth.
...be taken'") (quoting City of Atlanta v. Heirs of Champion, 244 Ga. 620, 621, 261 S.E.2d 343 (1979)); St. Andrew's Episcopal Day Sch. v. Miss. Transp. Comm'n, 806 So.2d 1105, 1111 (2002) (selection of the particular land to condemn as well as the amount of land necessary are legislative ques......
-
Wiggins v. City of Clinton Miss.
...of abuse of discretion or fraud, the judiciary will not interfere with this determination. St. Andrew's Episcopal Day School v. Miss. Transp. Comm'n , 806 So. 2d 1105, 1111 (Miss. 2002) (quoting Jackson Redevelopment Auth. v. King, Inc. , 364 So. 2d 1104, 1110 (Miss. 1978) ); Paulk v. Housi......
-
Knight v. South Miss. Elec. Power Ass'n, 2004-CA-02082-COA.
...determined by the condemning authority exercising its power of eminent domain conferred by the legislature. St. Andrew's Episcopal Day Sch. v. Miss. Transp. Comm'n, 806 So.2d 1105, 1111(¶ 18) (Miss. 2002) (citing Jackson Redevelopment Auth. v. King, Inc., 364 So.2d 1104, 1110 (Miss. 1978)).......