State ex rel. Butler's Inc. v. Gay
| Decision Date | 18 February 1947 |
| Citation | 158 Fla. 500,29 So.2d 246 |
| Court | Florida Supreme Court |
| Parties | STATE ex rel. BUTLER'S Inc. v. GAY, Comptroller. |
Rehearing Denied March 6, 1947.
H. O. Pemberton, of Tallahassee, for relator.
J. Tom Watson, Atty. Gen., Fred M. Burns and T. Paine Kelly, Asst. Attys. Gen., for respondent.
Relator has moved for a peremptory writ notwithstanding respondent's return.
Relator recites that it filed returns and paid taxes under Chapter 20977, Acts 1941, F.S.A. § 204.01 et seq., for five years from 1941 to 1945 but respondent denied that true returns were filed and alleged that same were illegal and insufficient.
Relator alleged that on September 27, 1945 respondent examined relator's books and demanded additional taxes in the sum of $1,170 and that under threat of enforcement said demand was paid. To this respondent replies that said payment was made by relator with full knowledge of its rights and without objection.
Relator alleged that respondent having annually for two or more years received the taxes and fees tendered by relator, that the exaction of additional taxes by respondent was in violation of 205.12, F.S.A.; and respondent is entitled to a refund thereof. To this respondent replied that relator having paid taxes legally payable for the years in question that relator is 'estopped by waiver' to claim the advantages asserted.
Relator alleges that it made a verbal claim in August 1946, and filed a written claim on October 28, 1946, which written claim was denied in writing on October 29, 1946, and respondent answers, that no claim was filed within a year from the effective date of Chapter 20977 (July 1, 1941) for refund of prior payments, nor were any claims filed with the Comptroller 'within one year after the right to such refund shall have accrued' for subsequent payments as provided by Sec. 215.26, F.S.A. (Chapter 22008, Acts 1943).
It does not appear that relator's claim is for (a) an overpayment of any tax, license or account due; (b) a payment where no tax, license or account was due; or (c) any payment made into the state treasury in error; and it appears that the relator's rights have been barred by the limitations provided by Section 215.26, F.S.A.
Relator's motion for a peremptory writ is denied and respondent is discharged.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
State ex rel. Victor Chemical Works v. Gay
...shall be 'void'.' The two Butler cases (State ex rel. Butler's, Inc., v. Gay, 158 Fla. 164, 27 So.2d 907, and State ex rel. Butler's, Inc., v. Gay, 158 Fla. 500, 29 So.2d 246, 247) appear to have settled the question by holding that failure to file written claim, sworn to on a form to be pr......
-
Reynolds Fasteners, Inc. v. Wright
...1942, 151 Fla. 301, 9 So.2d 705; State ex rel. Butler's, Inc. v. Gay, 1946, 158 Fla. 164, 27 So.2d 937; State ex rel. Butler's, Inc. v. Gay, 1947, 158 Fla. 500, 29 So.2d 246; City of Orlando v. Gill, 1937, 128 Fla. 139, 174 So. 224; 51 Am.Jur. 1012, 84 C.J.S. Taxation § 631, p. 1263, 31 Fla......
-
Florida Livestock Bd. v. Hygrade Food Products Corp.
...case it was said: 'The two Butler cases (State ex rel. Butler's, Inc. v. Gay, 158 Fla. 164, 27 So.2d 907, and State ex rel. Butler's, Inc. v. Gay, 158 Fla. 500, 29 So.2d 246, 247) appear to have settled the question by holding that failure to file written claim, sworn to on a form to be pre......
-
Getting your fair share back: recovering money paid pursuant to unconstitutional taxes and fees.
...state's refund statute as barrier to recovery of funds when the "non-claim" deadline had passed. In State, ex rel. Butlers Inc. v. Gay, 29 So. 2d 246 (1947), a claim for refund was denied relating to five previous years' payments under a one-year statute of repose. Two years later, in State......