State v. Canady

• Decision Date: 27 May 1970
• Docket Number: No. 7019SC159,7019SC159
• Citation: 174 S.E.2d 140,8 N.C.App. 320
• Parties: STATE of North Carolina v. Hurley CANADY.
• Court: North Carolina Court of Appeals

Page 140

174 S.E.2d 140

8 N.C.App. 320

STATE of North Carolina v. Hurley CANADY.

No. 7019SC159.

Court of Appeals of North Carolina.

May 27, 1970.

Atty. Gen. Robert Morgan, and Deputy Atty. Gen. Harrison Lewis, for the State.

Webster S. Medlin, Concord, for defendant appellant.

BRITT, Judge.

The only question presented in defendant's brief is stated as follows: 'Was the State's evidence sufficient to warrant its submission to the jury and upon which to base a verdict of guilty?'

Although the record reveals that defendant did not challenge the sufficiency of the State's evidence at trial, he contends that such evidence is reviewable on appeal under G.S. § 15--173.1 which provides as follows: 'The sufficiency of the evidence of the State in a criminal case is reviewable upon appeal without regard to whether a motion has been made pursuant to G.S. 15--173 in the trial court.' Pursuant to this statute, enacted in 1967, we have reviewed the evidence to test its sufficiency to support the verdict of guilty. State v. Davis, 273 N.C. 349, 160 S.E.2d 75 (1968).

The testimony of William Junior Hodges (Hodges), the victim of the armed robbery and the State's key witness, is summarized as follows: Around 5:00 a.m. on 30 July 1969, Hodges was sole attendant at the U-Save Service Station in Cabarrus County. He had just finished waiting on a customer, put the money from the sale in a box, and walked out to the side of the service station lot near his car when defendant and another man ran up behind him. The other man was wearing a stocking over his face and Hodges could not identify him. Defendant had a sawed-off shotgun and held it on Hodges. Defendant's accomplice ordered Hodges to 'hand over the money' after which Hodges told him the money was in a box in the station building. While defendant with his shotgun stayed with Hodges, the other man went into the building, got the money (approximately $350) and returned to where Hodges and defendant were. Defendant and the other person then forced Hodges to go with them back of a building some 200 yards from the station where they took a wallet, some cigarettes, a cigarette lighter, a wristwatch, a pocket knife, a 32-caliber pistol and $200.00 from Hodges' person. They then told Hodges to run up the road. Defendant was in Hodges' presence some ten or fifteen minutes and the service station lot was very well lighted. As soon as defendant and his accomplice left Hodges, he returned to the station and called the...