State v. Fees, 49519
| Decision Date | 18 November 1958 |
| Docket Number | No. 49519,49519 |
| Citation | 250 Iowa 163,93 N.W.2d 103 |
| Parties | STATE of Iowa, Appellee, v. Richard William FEES, Appellant. |
| Court | Iowa Supreme Court |
Holliday, Miller, Myers & Stewart, Des Moines, for appellant.
Norman A. Erbe, Atty. Gen., Freeman H. Forrest, Asst. Atty. Gen., and Ray Hanrahan, County Attorney, Des Moines, for appellee.
Defendant was indicted, tried by court and jury and convicted of the crime of breaking and entering, in violation of section 708.8, Code 1954, I.C.A. He undertook to appeal to us by filing with the clerk of the district court a notice of appeal containing the caption of the case and reciting, 'Comes now the defendant and appeals from each and every adverse ruling in the above entitled cause.' The notice was signed by defendant's attorneys but was not addressed to the state nor anyone else. The notice evidently was not served upon anyone but merely bears the notation, 'County Atty office rec'd copy 15 April 1958 by Donald Daughton, Ass't co. atty.'
We are agreed we have no jurisdiction to entertain this appeal and it must be dismissed.
I. Code, section 793.2, I.C.A., provides that in a criminal case 'An appeal can only be taken from the final judgment, * * *.' See State v. Anderson, 245 Iowa 99, 60 N.W.2d 794. The notice here does not describe or identify the final judgment. The rule is that a notice of appeal must sufficiently describe or specify the judgment or order appealed from. Pilkington v. Potwin, 163 Iowa 86, 94-95, 144 N.W. 39, 42; 4 A C.J.S. Appeal and Error § 593(6); 3 Am.Jur., Appeal and Error, section 472. This, however, is not the principal basis for dismissing the appeal.
II. The statute that governs taking an appeal in a criminal case, Code, section 793.4, I.C.A., provides: 'An appeal is taken and perfected by the party or his attorney serving on the adverse party or his attorney of record * * * a notice in writing of the taking of the appeal, and filing the same with such clerk, with evidence of service thereof indorsed thereon or annexed thereto.'
So far as applicable here this statute is like section 12837, Code 1939, which governed appeals in civil cases before it was superseded by rule 336, Rules of Civil Procedure. We held several times that a notice of appeal, under 12837, must be addressed to the adverse party (his agent) or attorney in order to confer jurisdiction upon this court. Pilkington v. Potwin, supra, 163 Iowa 86, 93, 144 N.W. 42, and citations; Snyder v. Incorporated Town of Spirit Lake, 218 Iowa 774, 254 N.W. 14, and citations.
We see no reason why the same rule should not apply to a notice of appeal in a criminal case under section 793.4. Failure to address this notice of appeal to the adverse party or its attorney renders it fatally defective.
III. There is still another ground upon which our decision rests.
It is apparent defendant attempted to appeal by filing notice thereof with the clerk of the district court in the manner provided by rule 336, Rules of Civil Procedure, governing appeals in civil cases, rather than by serving notice on the adverse party as required by section 793.4, applicable to criminal cases. This from State v. Thomas, 238 Iowa 998, 999, 29 N.W.2d 198-199, is controlling here
See also State v. Wills, 236 Iowa 196, 18 N.W.2d 81....
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
State v. McCollom
...of appeal is fatally defective in that it is not addressed to the adverse party (the state) or its attorney of record. State v. Fees, 250 Iowa 163, 165, 93 N.W.2d 103, 104, and citations. We have adhered to this decision in dismissing several attempted appeals in criminal cases for failure ......
-
Blanchard v. Bennett
...v. Spillane, Iowa, 150 N.W.2d 595; State v. Birchall, Iowa, 150 N.W.2d 715; State v. McCune, 259 Iowa 386, 144 N.W.2d 401; State v. Fees, 250 Iowa 163, 93 N.W.2d 103; State v. Thomas, 238 Iowa 998, 29 N.W.2d We do not understand plaintiff contends we erred in refusing to entertain his defec......
-
State v. Addison
...we have held other rules inapplicable thereto. State v. Anderson, supra, 245 Iowa 99, 102, 60 N.W.2d 794, 796, and citation; State v. Fees, Iowa, 93 N.W.2d 103. The same logic applies The Rules of Civil Procedure were prescribed by us pursuant to what is now Code section 684.18, I.C.A., whi......
-
Hawkeye Sec. Ins. Co. v. Ford Motor Co.
... ... that the Defendant and Cross-Petitioner herein has appealed to the Supreme Court of the State of Iowa from each and every ruling adverse to the Defendant, and Cross-Petitioner during the ... In the Rosmann opinion this court, quoting from State v. Fees, 250 Iowa 163, 164, 93 N.W.2d ... Page 378 ... 103, 104, said, 'The Fees opinion holds: 'The ... ...