State v. Murray

Decision Date15 December 1936
Docket Number42882.
Citation270 N.W. 355,222 Iowa 925
PartiesSTATE v. MURRAY.
CourtIowa Supreme Court

Appeal from District Court, Pottawattamie County; H. J. Mantz Judge.

Defendant was indicted under section 13001 of the Code for breaking and entering. He was convicted by a jury, and on answers to special interrogatories it was found that he had been previously convicted on two charges of felony and he was sentenced to 40 years in the penitentiary. Defendant appeals.

Affirmed.

Robertson & Robertson, of Council Bluffs, for appellant.

Edward L. O'Connor, Atty. Gen., Walter F. Maley, Asst. Atty Gen., and Robert B. Organ, Co. Atty., of Council Bluffs, for the State.

ALBERT, Justice.

The following facts are satisfactorily shown by the record, and most of them were testified to by the defendant as a witness:

On the 6th of May, 1934, the defendant, together with one McKay and one Ball, left Des Moines for Omaha in a Ford touring car. They reached Omaha about 12:30 or 1 o'clock. They had been drinking liquor. They started back to Des Moines about 4:30 or 5 o'clock on the 7th of May, and reached Avoca about 8 or 8:30 p. m. They went to a restaurant there and had some lunch, and spent all the money they had in the crowd, and then started north out of Avoca on highway No. 7. At the edge of town there was a warehouse belonging to the Iowa State Highway Commission, where materials were kept for storage. This building faced east on the said highway. Just across the highway and opposite the front of said building one Harry Bailey resided. From his front porch to the highway commission building was about 200 feet.

The defendant testifies: " Well, as we got out there by that building, Roy Ball, he noticed that the gasoline was low in the car, and he says, ‘ I don't believe we have enough gasoline to go anywhere." Ball was driving. " Ball says, ‘ There is an old tractor over there, maybe we can get enough gasoline from that tractor to get home on." The tractor was about 100 feet the other side of the building. " It was his suggestion we should go over and get gasoline from the tractor, so we went over to the tractor and went to examining the tractor. There was no gasoline in the tractor, so when we were going back we got up to this state maintenance garage that had been broken in, and the door of the garage was open that far (indicating); but I pulled the door open farther and there was a gasoline pump there, so we took this old can we took from the car, that is, down to the tractor, and I began to pump gas from the pump in the shed; so I filled one small can and handed it to McKay. Then there was a milk can there that set up on a kind of a bench in the garage, so I took that down and was pumping gas into the can when this car drove up, that is, Mr. Nieman and Mr. Graham. My intent when I went into the building was just for gasoline. That was the only thing we had in mind was just to get a little gasoline. Didn't intend to do anything else except get a little gas, that was all. That was our purpose, to get a little gas to go home. We got, I should judge, around maybe two or two and a half gallons there. It was ordinary gas. After I got some gas in the little can I handed it to McKay; he was standing by the doorway; he took the can in his hand and took it out; and then I was filling up the other can, pumping gas in the other can; I couldn't see how much gas I had in the other can when Mr. Graham and Mr. Nieman came to the building; didn't get the can full. I left it in the building. McKay did not have anything to do with the lock. We had a searchlight that we took from the car down with us. We never had any intention of breaking into any building. Ball stayed in the car. That was all he did. When we came around the front of the building there were no lights on the building, and no light was broken by us. I had plenty of liquor in Avoca and before we got to Avoca. I have never said I was so drunk I didn't know what I was doing. I wasn't so drunk but what I know I didn't break the lock on that maintenance garage door. I wouldn't call that stealing. Yes, sir, I knew that was stealing that gasoline and that was committing some sort of crime then. When I seen the door was open I pulled the door open and looked in, and there was a gasoline pump, and McKay said, ‘ There is all the gasoline we want,’ so we started to pump. When I opened that door and went in the building, gasoline was what we wanted and had the intention of stealing the gasoline when I pushed the door open. Our intention was to get some gasoline when we went into that building. That is what we wanted. I knew that gasoline was not my property when I continued to operate that pump."

In addition to this testimony, the principal part of which was given by the defendant himself, Harry Bailey, who lives just across the highway, testifies that he could see the lock, or padlock, on the door from his porch where he was sitting. " It was fairly dark that evening about 9 o'clock. The noise I heard was a loud noise, hammering. I saw the padlock there that evening after it was broken off. I saw Graham pick it up. The clasp was there, the padlock was on the hasp. The light over the garage door was busted, but there was a light from the street corner over there, shining directly on that garage. I saw two men around there. I saw them break the garage door, and when they broke it, it made a noise. After they broke the door they went in the garage. I called Jack Graham on the telephone. He was the foreman for the highway commission at Avoca. He came at once in response to the call. Ted Nieman accompanied him in his car. I went over to the garage with Nieman and Graham. When I got over to the garage I saw that Graham and Nieman had one man." (The witness identified the defendant as the one that Graham and Nieman had there at that time.) " They afterward turned him over to Harry Eckhart, deputy sheriff. The other man ran away. When I heard these two men hammering on the door the light (over the door) was not burning. When I first saw them the light was lit. When these two men first came up to the garage the door was closed. I saw the door open. The hammering stopped before the door opened."

Graham testifies that he came by the Highway Commission building about 8 o'clock and all the doors were closed. He responded to Bailey's call, and he and Ted Nieman, in his car, went to the garage. The lights on his car were burning and focused on the door of the garage, and as he drove there one man came running out and ran north. He had a can in his hand. As he went over the fence he dropped the can and ran across the pasture, running north. " Just about that time another man came out of the door and I grabbed him. That man was the defendant. He came running out of the door." They had a scuffle with him, and finally turned him over to the deputy sheriff, Eckhart. Graham also testifies...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT