State v. Proctor

Decision Date23 March 1938
Docket Number146.
Citation195 S.E. 816,213 N.C. 221
PartiesSTATE v. PROCTOR et al.
CourtNorth Carolina Supreme Court

Appeal from Superior Court, Halifax County; W. H. S. Burgwyn Special Judge.

Anton Proctor and others were charged with offenses and Walter "Doodle" Wells was convicted of assault and robbery with firearms and of conspiring to commit an assault and robbery with firearms, and he appeals.

No error.

Where accused's brief presented only one exception and assignment of error, other exceptions not set out in brief or in support of which no reason or argument was stated or authority cited were abandoned. Rules of Practice in the Supreme Court, rule 28.

The bills of indictment against the defendants charged them (1) assault and robbery with firearms, N.C.Code 1935 (Michie), § 4267(a); and (2) conspiring together to commit an assault and robbery with firearms. The defendants Anton Proctor and Fritz Brinkley pleaded guilty to the charges and were duly sentenced. Frank Faulk and Walter "Doodle" Wells pleaded not guilty. The court, at the conclusion of the state's evidence, ordered a verdict of not guilty as to Frank Faulk. The jury convicted Wells, who was duly sentenced. The defendant Wells excepted, assigned errors, and appealed to the Supreme Court. The necessary facts will be set forth in the opinion.

Allsbrook & Benton, of Roanoke Rapids, for appellant.

A. A F. Seawell, Atty. Gen., and Harry McMullan and Emmett C Willis, Asst. Attys. Gen., for the State.

CLARKSON Justice.

Rules of Practice in the Supreme Court, 200 N.C. 831, rule 28. Appellant's brief, in part: "Exceptions in the record not set out in appellant's brief, or in support of which no reason or argument is stated or authority cited will be taken as abandoned by him."

In defendant's brief there is only one exception and assignment of error, which we think cannot be sustained, viz.: "The state contends that you ought to be convinced of the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The state contends that while the accomplices, Brinkley and Proctor are men who have engaged in the bad things of life; that Brinkley is a bad man and has been to the penitentiary on more than one occasion, and that Proctor, while a young man, has also been engaged in things which he should not have done, and that he served sentences either on the roads or in jail, but the state contends Walter Wells is a man of similar character. The state contends that Wells associated with these men and well knew the men; that he lived in the same community with them, knows their reputation and knows they have been to the penitentiary and to the roads, if they have, and knows for what they were sent, and the state contends he would not associate and be riding around, if you find beyond a reasonable doubt he was associating and riding around with them, unless they were of similar character, and the state contends 'birds of a feather flock together' applies in this case. That while up to this time Wells may have escaped punishment for anything he may have done or been connected with, the state contends on this occasion he was with these men."

Fritz Brinkley, who entered a plea of guilty, testified in part that he had known Wells some eighteen years. They were both reared in and near Rocky Mount, N.C. "Anton Proctor and 'Doodle' Wells were with me the night I held up the Texaco Filling Station at Enfield and robbed Jack Hearne. 'Doodle' Wells drove the automobile. At the time Anton Proctor and I were in the filling station Wells was sitting under the wheel of the automobile. The automobile was a Ford, 1936 black coach. * * * We were drinking. When we left Rocky Mount we went out the Battleboro Highway toward Enfield. I think Enfield is 19 or 20 miles from Rocky Mount. When we saw this filling station open at that time of morning is when Wells, Proctor and I made the agreement to hold up the filling station. We made the agreement as we were passing by the filling station. We rode on about a mile or a mile and a half and then turned and came back to the filling station. At the time Walter Wells and Anton Proctor each had guns in the car. Walter Wells drove the car right to the front door as you go into the filling station. I got out, went into the filling station and called for a Coca-Cola, and as soon as he reached for the Coca-Cola and before he handed it to me he was in the back of the filling station, and I drew the gun on him and said, 'Stick 'em up.' I had the gun with me that I got off of Walter Wells when I left the car. After I put the gun on the men in the filling station, Anton Proctor is the one that carried out the cash register and shotgun. They are all I know that he carried out. He put them in the back of the black Ford. * * * When I got back in the car Walter Wells was under the steering wheel, Anton Proctor was in the back seat, the cash register and gun were in the back seat. After we got in the car we did not stay any longer than it took us to get away. On the way back to Rocky Mount from Enfield we stopped near the train station at Battleboro on the highway and split what was in the cash register. * * * Proctor got out of the car, and they put me out about 5 1/2 miles from Rocky Mount, and 'Doodle' Wells left in the car. The last time I saw the car 'Doodle' Wells was driving it and going toward Rocky Mount. Proctor and I stayed there until daybreak and then went back to town. That is all I know about it."

Brinkley was corroborated by Anton Proctor. Corroborative evidence was given also by K. M. Sutton, E. M....

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT