State v. Weyerhaeuser Steamship Company
Decision Date | 07 May 1959 |
Docket Number | Civ. No. 10415. |
Citation | 176 F. Supp. 664 |
Parties | STATE of Maryland, to the use of Lillie Mae GLADDEN, individually and in her own right, as surviving widow of Thomas Gladden, Deceased, and Lillie Mae Gladden, as Mother and Next Friend of Linwood M. Gladden, Marlean C. Gladden, Barbara J. Gladden, Gwendolyn Gladden, Raymond Gladden, Reginald Gladden, Zelda Gladden, Hazela Gladden, and Adell Gladden, infants, surviving children of Thomas Gladden, deceased, and Morton Guth, Administrator of the Estate of Thomas Gladden, deceased. v. WEYERHAEUSER STEAMSHIP COMPANY, a body corporate. |
Court | U.S. District Court — District of Maryland |
Harold Buchman, Lawrence B. Coshnear and Morton Guth, of Baltimore, Md., for plaintiffs.
Robert H. Williams, Jr., and Niles, Barton, Yost & Dankmeyer, Baltimore, Md., for defendant.
Jerome B. Monfred, Baltimore, Md., amicus curiae.
The principal question raised by defendant's motion to dismiss is whether the Maryland "Lord Campbell's Act", which gives a right of action where death is caused "by wrongful act, neglect or default", encompasses a civil action for death caused by the unseaworthiness of a vessel.
Art. 67, sec. 1, Ann.Code of Md., 1957 ed., provides:
"Whenever the death of a person shall be caused by wrongful act, neglect or default, and the act, neglect or default is such as would (if death had not ensued) have entitled the party injured to maintain an action and recover damages in respect thereof, the vessel or person who would have been liable if death had not ensued, or the executor or administrator of the said person who would have been liable in case of the death of the said person who would have been liable, shall be liable to an action for damages, notwithstanding the death of the person injured, and although the death shall have been caused under such circumstances as amount in law to felony and if death ensues as a result of wrongful act, neglect or default of a vessel, suit may be brought in rem against said vessel in any court of competent jurisdiction * * *".
The history of the Maryland law is fully discussed by Judge Chesnut in State, to Use of Maines v. A/S Nye Kristianborg, D.C.D.Md., 84 F.Supp. 775. Aside from the provision with respect to vessels, added by amendment in 1949, the Maryland statute is similar to the New Jersey statute involved in The Tungus v. Skovgaard, 358 U.S. 588, 79 S.Ct. 503, 508, 3 L.Ed.2d 524, and United New York and New Jersey Sandy Hook Pilots Assn. v. Halecki, 358 U.S. 613, 79 S.Ct. 517, 3 L.Ed.2d 541. In Skovgaard, a suit in admiralty, a majority of the Court held that it was , and affirmed the four to three decision of the Third Circuit which had concluded that a claim for unseaworthiness is encompassed by the New Jersey Wrongful Death Act, N.J.S.A. 2A:31- 1 et seq., as a matter of state law. 358 U.S. at page 595, 79 S.Ct. at page 508. The Supreme Court said: 358 U.S. at page 596, 79 S.Ct. at page 509. In Halecki, a civil action, the Court approved the holding of the Second Circuit "that the New Jersey Wrongful Death Act incorporates liability for unseaworthiness as developed by federal law," and said: "For the reasons stated in The Tungus v. Skovgaard, 358 U.S. at page 588, 79 S.Ct. at page 503, we hold that the Court of Appeals was correct in viewing its basic task as one of interpreting the law of New Jersey." 358 U.S. at page 614, 615, 79 S.Ct. 518. It is therefore the duty of this court to interpret the law of Maryland.
There is no Maryland decision in point. In 1948 a suit in admiralty was filed in the United States District Court for the District of Maryland, claiming damages under the Maryland statute for the death of a longshoreman due to the unseaworthiness of a government vessel. The propriety of such a suit seems not to have been questioned by counsel, by Judge Chesnut at the trial, or by the Fourth Circuit on appeal. State of Maryland for Use of Johnson v. United States, 165 F.2d 911.1
The majority and dissenting opinions of the Third Circuit in Skovgaard v. The M/V Tungus, 252 F.2d 14, argue fully the reasons for an affirmative and a negative answer, respectively, to the question at issue in the instant case. We must note, however, two distinctions between the New Jersey law and the Maryland law.
1. The New Jersey courts have held that the Wrongful Death Act of that State Skovgaard v. The M/V Tungus, 252 F.2d at page 17. On the other hand, the Court of Appeals of Maryland has held that the Maryland "Lord Campbell's Act" is in derogation of the common law, and therefore should be strictly construed. Demczuk v. Jenifer, 138 Md. 488, 114 A. 471; State, to Use of Dunnigan v. Cobourn, 171 Md. 23, 187 A. 881, 107 A.L.R. 1045. However, in the most recent case, McKeon v. State, to Use of Conrad, 211 Md. 437, 127 A.2d 635, 638, the Maryland Court said:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Portland Pipe Line Corp. v. Environmental Imp. Com'n
...to be unconstitutional as violating substantive due process. The same statute was applied, ten years later, in State v. Weyerhaeuser Steamship Company, 176 F.Supp. 664 (D.C.1959) and State v. A/S Nabella, 176 F.Supp. 668 (D.C.1959) without meeting any due process arguments.30 Pipe Line does......
-
Hornsby v. Fishmeal Company
...Maryland: State of Maryland for Use of Smith v. A/S Nabella, 176 F.Supp. 668 (D.C.Md. 1959); State of Maryland to Use of Gladden v. Weyerhaeuser S. S. Co., 176 F.Supp. 664 (D.C.Md.1959); and Metzger v. S. S. Kirsten Torm, 245 F.Supp. 227 (D.C.Md.1956); New Jersey: United New York and New Je......
-
Metzger v. SS Kirsten Torm
...that the death of a longshoreman was caused by the unseaworthiness of the vessel on which he was working. State v. Weyerhaeuser Steamship Co., D.Md., 176 F.Supp. 664 (1959); State v. Nabella, D.Md., 176 F.Supp. 668 (1959). The discussions in those opinions will not be repeated here; they sh......
-
Emerson v. Holloway Concrete Products Company, 17839.
...such circumstances, as amount in law to a felony. * * *" (Emphasis supplied.) 14 This statute is set out in State v. Weyerhaeuser S.S. Co., D.C.Md.1959, 176 F.Supp. 664, at page 665, see also note 18, infra. This statue allows recovery if death is "caused by wrongful act, neglect or default......
-
Coming to terms with strict and liberal construction.
...to obtain statutes and cases utilizing the terms strict and/or liberal construction). (274) Maryland v. Weyerhaeuser Steamship Co., 176 F. Supp. 664, 666 (I). Md. 1959) (emphasis added) (citation omitted). See also McKeon v. Maryland, 127 A.2d 635, 638 (Md. 1956) (discussing the relative im......