Stutzman v. Younkerman
Decision Date | 13 December 1927 |
Docket Number | 38533 |
Citation | 216 N.W. 627,204 Iowa 1162 |
Parties | ROSLEY STUTZMAN, Appellee, v. CLARA R. YOUNKERMAN, Appellant |
Court | Iowa Supreme Court |
Appeal from Pottawattamie District Court.--O. D. WHEELER, Judge.
Action for personal injuries sustained from being struck by defendant's automobile. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendant appeals.
Affirmed.
Kimball Peterson, Smith & Peterson, for appellant.
John J Hess, for appellee.
MORLING J. EVANS, C. J., and DE GRAFF, ALBERT, and WAGNER, JJ., concur.
The plaintiff, a girl then eight years of age, while crossing southwardly along the east side of a street intersection, was struck by defendant's automobile, coming from the west along the south side of the intersection. Plaintiff's contention is that defendant failed to keep proper lookout, and did not have her car under control. Defendant's is that plaintiff suddenly emerged from behind an automobile which was traveling westwardly, and ran into her car. Plaintiff's claim is that she was struck by defendant's right fender, just as she was ready to step on the south curb. Defendant's is that the left fender struck the plaintiff when plaintiff was about six feet from the curb. Defendant's car swerved into the curb. She contends that she swerved it, to avoid striking the plaintiff.
When plaintiff arrived at the northeast corner of the intersection, a team and wagon and an automobile were passing west. Plaintiff testifies that she
Her companion testifies:
She further testifies that plaintiff walked defendant's car hit her. This witness says that plaintiff walked slowly, at an ordinary gait. At that time, to the rear of the wagon previously mentioned, Drake was driving a team west. He says:
He says:
He says, "I didn't take my eyes off of her from the time she stepped onto the street until she got across the street." Also, that the car, after it struck her, ran 100 to 105 feet; that the right fender and wheel struck the child. He says that one of the wheels of the automobile scraped the curb when they first hit her; that the body was rolled right along the curb between the wheels on the right side of the car and the curbing; that he examined the tracks at that time, and noticed them afterwards; that they were right along the curb. He thought there was a white tire mark on the curb where the tire hit it. Drake's companion, Fox, says:
He says that, when he saw the little girl's body whirling, it was "right along against the curb, as near as she could be." Defendant and her companion (a niece) testified, in substance, that, as they approached the intersection, they looked in each direction; that there was another car approaching from the east, and the first they saw of the plaintiff was when she came from behind the other car on the other side of the street. The niece says:
Defendant did not see her until her companion spoke. Defendant says that plaintiff ...
To continue reading
Request your trial