Tabolsky v. Crandon
| Decision Date | 24 March 1927 |
| Parties | EVA TABOLSKY v. L. R. G. CRANDON. SAMUEL TABOLSKY v. SAME. |
| Court | United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court |
March 18, 1927.
Present: RUGG, C.
J., CROSBY, PIERCE WAIT, & SANDERSON, JJ.
Physician and Surgeon. Limitations, Statute of. Statute, Construction.
The special statute of limitations, St. 1921, c. 319, was effective to bar actions, begun after it took effect on January 1, 1922 although based upon causes of action described therein which existed at the time it took effect.
A defendant cannot be found to have been guilty of any fraudulent concealment whereby the effect of the statute of limitations can be avoided, where it appears that the plaintiff had a personal knowledge of the facts which created the cause of the action.
TWO ACTIONS OF TORT, the first for damages alleged to have resulted from negligence of the defendant, a surgeon; and the second by the husband of the plaintiff in the first action for consequential damages. Writs dated April 6, 1923.
In the Superior Court, the actions were tried together before Freeman, J., by whose order verdicts were entered for the defendant. The plaintiffs alleged exceptions, which, after the death of Freeman, J., were allowed by Weed, J.
The cases were submitted on briefs. W.J. Patron, F.D. McCarthy, & J.L Barron, for the plaintiffs.
R.G. Dodge & W.A. Barrows, for the defendant.
BY THE COURT. These are actions of tort to recover compensation for alleged malpractice of the defendant, a surgeon, who admittedly performed an operation upon the female plaintiff.
It was provided by St. 1921, c. 319, that "actions of contract or tort for malpractice, error or mistake, against physicians, surgeons . . shall be commenced only within two years next after the cause of action accrues." This act took effect on January 1, 1922. It was operative upon all causes of action then existing as well as those thereafter arising.
Mulvey v Boston, 197 Mass. 178 . The present action was not begun until more than two years after the wrongful conduct of which complaint is made. There is no ground in the evidence for finding that the defendant was guilty of any fraudulent concealment whereby the effect of the statute of limitations can be avoided. "A cause of action cannot be said to be concealed from one who has a personal knowledge of the facts which create it." Sanborn v. Gale, 162 Mass. 412 , 414. See Ogg v. Robb, 181 Iowa, 145....
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Schnebly v. Baker
...v. Rahn, 46 Cal.App.2d 694, 116 P.2d 640; Buck v. Mouradian, 100 So.2d 70 (Fla.app.); Mills v. Warner, 201 Ill.App. 258; Tabolsky v. Crandon, 259 Mass. 32, 155 N.E. 657; Kroll v Vanden Berg, 336 Mich. 306, 57 N.W.2d 897; Wilder v. St. Joseph Hospital, 225 Miss. 42, 82 So.2d 651; Hays v. Hal......
-
E.S. Parks Shellac Co. v. Jones
...371,14 Ann. Cas. 574;Lewis v. Crowell, 205 Mass. 497, 91 N. E. 910;Colby v. Shute, 219 Mass. 211, 215, 106 N. E. 1006;Tabolsky v. Crandon, 259 Mass. 32, 155 N. E. 657; Barry v. Bay State Street Railway, 222 Mass. 336, 370,110 N. E. 1031. See, also, to the same effect, Rex v. Chandra Dharma,......
-
Cioffi v. Guenther
...statute of limitations for medical malpractice actions. Maloney v. Brackett, 275 Mass. 479, 481, 176 N.E. 604 (1931). Tabolsky v. Crandon, 259 Mass. 32, 155 N.E. 657 (1927). A shortened statute of limitations may be applied to causes of action already accrued "if sufficient time be allowed,......
-
Stetson v. French
... ... It is true that a ... cause of action is not concealed from one who has knowledge ... of the facts that create it. Tabolsky v. Crandon, ... 259 Mass. 32 ... Maloney v. Brackett, 275 Mass. 479 , ... 484. But though Jabez and Charles had knowledge that wages ... were ... ...