Tanksley v. Daniels
| Decision Date | 28 August 2018 |
| Docket Number | No. 17-2023,17-2023 |
| Citation | 902 F.3d 165 |
| Parties | Clayton Prince TANKSLEY, Appellant v. Lee DANIELS; Lee Daniels Entertainment; Danny Strong; Danny Strong Productions; Twenty-First Century Fox, Inc., Parent Company of Fox Entertainment Group, Inc., 20th Century Fox Film Corp, 20th Century Fox Television Inc, 20th Century TV Inc., 20th Century Fox International, 20th Century Fox International Television LLC and 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment LLC; Fox Network Group Inc, Parent Company of Fox Broadcasting Company, Fox Television Stations, Inc., Fox Digital Media, Fox International Channels, Inc.; Does 1 through 10; Sharon Pinkenson, Executive Director; Greater Philadelphia Film Office ; Leah Daniels-Butler |
| Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Third Circuit |
Mary E. Bogan [ARGUED], 1650 Market Street, Suite 3600, Philadelphia, PA 19103, Predrag Filipovic [ARGUED], 1735 Market Street, Mellon Bank Center, Philadelphia, PA 19103, Counsel for Appellant
Richard L. Stone [ARGUED], Andrew J. Thomas, Andrew G. Sullivan, Jenner & Block 633 West 5th Street, Suite 3600, Los Angeles, CA 90071, Michael K. Twersky, Fox Rothschild, 2000 Market Street, 20th Floor, Philadelphia, PA 19103, Counsel for Lee Daniels, Lee Daniels Entertainment, Danny Strong, Danny Strong Productions, Twenty First Century Fox Inc., Fox Network Group Inc. and Leah Daniels-Butler
Rigel C. Farr, Esq., Charles M. Golden, Esq., Mathieu Shapiro, Esq. [ARGUED], Obermayer Rebmann Maxwell & Hippel, 1500 Market Street, Suite 3400, Philadelphia, PA 19102, Counsel for Sharon Pinkenson and Greater Philadelphia Film Office
Before: CHAGARES, VANASKIE and FISHER, Circuit Judges.
Clayton Prince Tanksley is an actor and producer who lives in Philadelphia. In 2005, he created a three-episode television pilot, Cream , for which he received a copyright. In 2015, Fox Television debuted a new series, Empire , from award-winning producer and director Lee Daniels. Shortly thereafter, Tanksley filed suit, claiming that Empire infringed on his copyright of Cream . The District Court found no substantial similarity between the two shows and dismissed Tanksley's complaint. For the reasons stated below, we will affirm.
In 2005, Tanksley wrote, produced, directed, filmed, starred in, and copyrighted three episodes of Cream , a show about an African-American record executive who runs his own hip-hop label. In 2008, Tanksley participated in an event called the Philly Pitch hosted by the Greater Philadelphia Film Office. The Philly Pitch provided an opportunity for aspiring local writers to pitch movie concepts to a panel of entertainment professionals. Lee Daniels served as a panel member.
During his presentation to the panel, Tanksley pitched an idea unrelated to Cream . At a meet-and-greet following the pitches, however, Tanksley spoke with Daniels one-on-one, and the two discussed the show. Daniels apparently expressed interest, so Tanksley provided him with a DVD and a script of the series. Tanksley's complaint does not allege any further contact between him and Daniels. In 2015, nearly seven years later, Fox aired the debut episode of the Daniels-created series Empire , which also revolves around an African-American record executive who runs his own music label.
The following are brief descriptions of each show.1
Winston St. James is the founder and owner of Big Balla Records based in Philadelphia. Cream documents the challenges Winston faces as he attempts to run his record label while dealing with a variety of personal and family problems. Cream features numerous, prolonged sex scenes and portrays Winston and other characters as highly promiscuous. The show has several story arcs of varying prominence; the main three are outlined below.
Herpes: Throughout the show, Winston has a number of sexual forays with various characters, including his two assistants, Chantal and Tiffany. Towards the end of the first episode, Winston grabs his groin in obvious pain and instructs an assistant to schedule a doctor's appointment for him immediately. Early in the second episode, Winston learns from his doctor that he has herpes. In this scene, the dialogue between Winston and his doctor is conspicuously educational for a drama, and includes many clinical details about herpes prevention and treatment. Episode two concludes with Tanksley (out of character) delivering a lengthy public service announcement about sexually transmitted diseases
. In the third episode, the audience learns that Winston's two assistants also have herpes, and there are intra-office recriminations over the source of the outbreak. At the end of the third episode, Winston learns that Chantal's husband has been visiting a prostitute who has herpes, dramatically revealing her as the unexpected source of the outbreak at Big Balla Records.
Domestic Abuse: Early in the first episode, Winston's younger sister, Angelica, is physically abused by her boyfriend, Shekwan. He is upset over Angelica's failure to get him an audition with Big Balla Records. After discovering the source of Angelica's injuries, Winston agrees to give Shekwan an audition, but also arranges to have him murdered. The first episode ends with two of Winston's associates shooting Shekwan many times from the shadows of an alley. Following the first episode, the actress who plays Angelica delivers a public service announcement about domestic abuse. In the second episode, Shekwan survives the shooting and makes a full—miraculous, even—recovery. Winston then allows Shekwan to make a record, but attempts to sabotage him with a comically bad song. To Winston's chagrin, the song ends up being massively successful, with many suppliers calling Winston's office directly to order several thousand copies.
Company Takeover: Winston's ex-girlfriend, Brenda, and his father, Sammy, are introduced in the final scene of the second episode. The audience learns that Winston's younger brother and sister are actually his and Brenda's children. Winston's parents raised the children because of Brenda's past drug abuse. Sammy—now apparently estranged from his ex-wife and Winston—pledges to help Brenda get her children back and vows to take control of Big Balla Records. Sammy and Brenda then have sex and the episode ends. In the third episode, Winston's mother, Nora, gets in a fight with Brenda and suffers a fatal heart attack. At her funeral, the audience learns for the first time that Nora owned fifty percent of Big Balla Records. Sammy confronts Winston and demands Nora's share of the company, which Winston refuses. Later, Sammy learns that Nora gave her shares to her grandchildren, i.e., Winston's children. Following another sex scene with Brenda, Sammy schemes to drive a wedge between Winston and his children by revealing the truth about their parentage. In this way, Sammy hopes to gain control of Big Balla Records. After learning that Winston is actually her father, Angelica tells him that she never wants to see him again. The third episode ends with the actress who plays Nora delivering a public service message about the apparent crisis of grandparents raising their grandchildren.
Lucious Lyon is the founder and CEO of Empire Entertainment, a prominent record label based in New York City. Lucious rose from a life of poverty and crime in Philadelphia to become a music and entertainment mogul. The members of Lucious' immediate family also play central roles in the series. As outlined below, Empire 's first season is defined by several story arcs.
Succession: Unquestionably, Empire decision is complicated by the fact that each of his sons has a unique set of talents and liabilities. His oldest son, Andre, is a Wharton graduate and the current CFO of Empire Entertainment. Andre, however, lacks musical talent, and Lucious, as an acclaimed artist in his own right, believes that Empire should be led by a musician. The middle son, Jamal, is a talented R&B singer and songwriter, but struggles to gain his father's approval because he is gay. Due to a presumed hostility to homosexuality in the African-American community, Lucious is doubtful that Jamal could successfully lead Empire Entertainment. Lucious' youngest son, Hakeem, is an emerging, charismatic rapper who embodies the hip-hop lifestyle. Lucious initially favors Hakeem because of his star potential, but Hakeem's immaturity and undisciplined behavior force Lucius to reconsider.
Lucious' Past: Before becoming an entertainment mogul, Lucious dealt drugs and committed various other crimes, some violent. In various ways throughout the series, Lucious' past threatens to undermine everything he has built at Empire. In the pilot episode, Lucious' ex-wife, Cookie, is released from prison after serving a seventeen-year sentence. The audience learns that Cookie took the rap for Lucious so he could use proceeds from a drug sale to launch his career and, eventually, Empire Entertainment. Upon her release, Cookie, whom Lucious divorced shortly after her incarceration began, confronts Lucious at Empire headquarters and demands fifty percent of the company. When Lucious resists, Cookie threatens to inform the SEC that Empire Entertainment was started with drug money, a particularly potent threat in light of Empire's upcoming IPO.
Later in the pilot, Lucious' longtime friend Bunkie attempts to blackmail him by threatening to tell police about Lucious' past crimes. Lucious arranges to meet Bunkie by the river at night, and shoots him in the face. The investigation into Bunkie's death, and Lucious' suspected involvement, play out...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Miller v. Black Diamond Capital Mgmt., L.L.C. (In re Bayou Steel BD Holdings, L.L.C.)
...v. Wells Fargo , 824 F.3d 333, 341 (3d Cir. 2016) ; see also Schmidt v. Skolas , 770 F.3d 241, 249 (3d Cir. 2014).43 Tanksley v. Daniels , 902 F.3d 165, 172 (3d Cir. 2018) ; see also McTernan v. City of York , 577 F.3d 521, 526 (3d Cir. 2009) ; Davis , 824 F.3d at 341.44 See Kost v. Kozakie......
-
Zohar CDO 2003-1, Ltd. v. Patriarch Partners, LLC (In re Zohar III, Corp.)
...Cir. 2014) ; S. Cross Overseas Agencies, Inc. v. Wah Kwong Shipping Grp., Ltd ., 181 F.3d 410, 429 (3d Cir. 1999).79 Tanksley v. Daniels , 902 F.3d 165, 172 (3d Cir. 2018) ; see also McTernan v. City of York , 577 F.3d 521, 526 (3d Cir. 2009) ; Davis , 824 F.3d at 341.80 As will become clea......
-
Kelley v. O'Malley, 2:17-cv-01599-NBF
...upon which relief could be granted.’ " Tanksley v. Daniels , 259 F.Supp.3d 271, 304 (E.D. Pa. 2017), aff'd, No. 17-2023, 902 F.3d 165, 2018 WL 4087884 (3d Cir. Aug. 28, 2018) (citations omitted); In re Burlington Coat Factory Sec. Litig. , 114 F.3d 1410, 1434 (3d Cir. 1997) (" ‘Futility’ me......
-
Mundy v. City of Pittsburgh
... ... limited to the complaint, but may also consider evidence ... integral to or explicitly relied upon therein.” ... Tanksley v. Daniels , 902 F.3d 165, 172 (3d Cir ... 2018) (internal quotations omitted). “In deciding a ... Rule 12(b)(6) motion, a court must ... ...
-
FEDERAL PLEADING STANDARDS IN STATE COURT.
...4 Mass. (4 Tyng) 451, 451-52 (1808). (194.) Dole, 4 Mass. (4 Tyng) at 451-52. (195.) Id. (196.) Id. (197.) See, e.g., Tanksley v. Daniels, 902 F.3d 165, 175 (3d Cir. (198.) E.g., Witter v. Brewster, 1 Kirby 422, 423 (Conn. 1788) ("As to the other exception--that the jury have found contrary......
-
COPYRIGHT AND THE BRAIN.
...Sprigman. Alex Kaczmarek, Gina Middleton, and Rasha Sajid provided top- notch research assistance. (1.) See, e.g., Tanksley v. Daniels, 902 F.3d 165, 174 (3d Cir. 2018); Rentmeester v. Nike, Inc., 883 F.3d 1111, 1121 (9th Cir. (2.) Mark A. Lemley, Our Bizarre System for Proving Copyright In......
-
Decisions in Brief
...to spend more resources to prove copyright infringement. Copyright Suit against Empire Show Creators Fizzles Out Tanksley v. Daniels , 902 F.3d 165, 127 U.S.P.Q.2d 1802 (3d Cir. 2018). In 2005, plaintiff Tanksley wrote Cream , a three-episode pilot focusing on an African American–owned hip ......
-
Case Comments
..."Empire," which involves who will succeed the founder of a movie empire who has ALS, the dismissal was affirmed. Tanksley v. Daniels, 902 F.3d 165, 127 U.S.P.Q.2d 1802 (3rd Cir. 2018).COPYRIGHTS - SINGLE APPLICATION As of 2013 the Copyright Office allowed a single application to register on......