Tarver v. E.I. Du Pont De Nemours and Co.
| Decision Date | 24 March 1994 |
| Parties | 93-1005 La |
| Court | Louisiana Supreme Court |
Marlon V. Harrison, Baton Rouge, Marlin N. Gusman, New Orleans, for applicant.
Robert L. Roland, Watson, Blanche, Wilson & Posner, Baton Rouge, for respondent.
[93-1005 La. 1] DENNIS, Justice. *
The Department of Revenue and Taxation (Department) brought this suit against E.I. Du Pont De Nemours and Company (Du Pont) to collect additional corporate franchise taxes for the year 1981. The case hinges on the correct interpretation of La.R.S. 47:604-05, and the Department's Rule 604, which govern the valuation of capital stock for the purpose of calculating corporate franchise taxes. The issue is whether the statutes and the rule require that capital stock must always be valued at least at book value, as the Department contends, or, when capital stock is issued in a tax free reorganization, valued at an amount equal to the basis of the assets received therefor, regardless of book value, as argued by Du Pont. The trial court rendered judgment in favor of the Department and against Du Pont for additional corporate franchise taxes. The court of appeal reversed, holding that the rule subjects the statutes to several interpretations, and that the one most favorable to the taxpayer must be applied 616 So.2d 216. Accordingly, the appeals court remanded the case to the trial court for a recalculation of the corporate franchise tax using the interpretation urged by Du Pont. We amend the court of appeal judgment to reinstate the trial court's decree.
The amount of corporate franchise tax owed is based on the amount of the corporation's capital stock, surplus, undivided [93-1005 La. 2] profits, and borrowed capital. La.R.S. 47:601 A. The method for determining the amount of capital stock is set forth in La.R.S. 47:604 which provides:
For the purpose of ascertaining the tax imposed in this Chapter, capital stock, whether having par value or not, shall be deemed to have such value as is reflected on the books of the corporation, subject to examination and revision by the collector, but in no event shall such value be less than is shown on the books of the taxpaying corporation (emphasis added).
Where capital stock is issued for assets and the transaction is treated as a tax free exchange under R.S. 47:131, 132, 133, 135, 136, 137 and 138, the collector shall consider the cost of the assets as determined under R.S. 47:605A and the value of any intangibles acquired as the value of the stock issued to acquire such assets. Capital stock shall include full shares, fractional shares, and any script certificates convertible into shares of stock.
La.R.S. 47:605 A provides in pertinent part:
For the purpose of ascertaining the tax imposed in this Chapter, surplus and undivided profits shall be deemed to have such value as is reflected on the books of the corporation, subject to examination and revision by the collector from the information contained in the report filed by the corporation as hereinafter provided and from any other information obtained by the collector; but in no event shall such revision reflect the value of any asset in excess of the cost thereof to the taxpayer at the time of acquisition; in the case of an acquisition which qualifies as a tax free exchange under R.S. 47:131, 132, 133, 135, 137 and 138, cost to the taxpayer at the time of acquisition shall be deemed to be the basis of such property determined under R.S. 47:146, 148, and 152; provided that in no event shall such value be less than is shown on the books of the taxpaying corporation (emphasis added).
Pursuant to its rule-making power, the Department of Revenue and Taxation adopted Rule 604 to implement these statutes; Rule 604 provides in pertinent part:
604.1 For the purpose of determining the amount of capital stock upon which the tax imposed by R.S. 47:601 is based, such stock shall in every instance have such value as is reflected on the books of the corporation, subject to whatever increases to the recorded book values may be found necessary by the Secretary of Revenue and Taxation to reflect the true value of the stock; in no case shall the value upon which the tax is based be less than is shown on the books of the corporation.
604.2 In any case in which capital stock of a corporation has been issued in exchange for assets, the capital stock shall have a value equal to the fair market value of the assets received in exchange for the stock, plus any intangibles received in the exchange except as provided in the following paragraph.
604.3 In any such case in which capital stock of a corporation is transferred to one or more persons in exchange for assets, and the only consideration for the exchange was stock or securities of the corporation, and [93-1005 La. 3] immediately after the exchange such person or persons owned at least eighty percent of the total voting power of all voting stock and at least eighty percent of the total number of shares of all of the stock of the corporation, the value of the stock exchanged for the assets so acquired shall be the same as the basis of the assets received in the hands of the transferor of the assets, plus any intangibles received in the exchange. The only...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Billiot v. B.P. Oil Co.
...may be made in search of the intent of the legislature. La.Civ.Code art. 9; Tarver v. E.I. Du Pont De [93-1118 La. 23] Nemours and Co., 634 So.2d 356 (La.1994). With respect to the issue under consideration, Article 2315.3 is not susceptible of different meanings and its application as writ......
-
Bannister Props., Inc. v. State, 2018 CA 0030
...of the intent of the legislature." La. C.C. art. 9. This principle applies to tax statutes. Tarver v. E.I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co., 634 So. 2d 356, 358 (La. 1994). When the language of the law is susceptible of different meanings, it must be interpreted as having the meaning that best conf......
-
Bannister Props., Inc. v. State
...made in search of the intent of the legislature." La. C.C. art. 9. This principle applies to tax statutes. Tarver v. E.I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co. , 634 So.2d 356, 358 (La. 1994). When the language of the law is susceptible of different meanings, it must be interpreted as having the meaning......
-
Yesterdays of Lake Charles, Inc. v. Calcasieu Parish Sales, 14-413
...shall be adopted. Tarver v. E.I. Du Pont de Nemours and Co., 616 So.2d 216 (La.App. 5 Cir. 1993), affirmed 93-1005 (La. 3/24/95); 634 So.2d 356. Clyde Juneau co., Inc. v. Caddo-Shreveport Sales and Use Tax Comm'n, 28433, p. 6 (La.App. 2 Cir. 6/26/96), 677 So.2d 610, 613 (emphasis added). Be......